Expert attributes investor failures to flawed thinking

Sep 19, 2005 @ 12:01 am

By Dan Jamieson

IRVINE, Calif. - In 1896, when the Dow Jones Industrial Average began, the index stood at 41. The Dow tracks only appreciation, so here's a question: What would its value be today if dividends had been reinvested?

That question was posed to 50 financial advisers at a meeting here last week of the Southern California chapter of the Denver-based Investment Management Consultants Association.

The questioner was Meir Statman, a prominent academician in the field of behavioral finance, who spoke at the meeting.

Most of the advisers guessed that with reinvested dividends over that long time period, the Dow would be higher by a factor of 10 or 20, maybe to the 100,000 or 200,000 level.

Wrong, said Mr. Statman, a professor of finance at Santa Clara (Calif.) University. Reinvested dividends would have brought the Dow up to more than 900,000.

This example illustrated the cognitive bias of "anchoring," or getting hung up by past values of an asset or index, Mr. Statman said.

Hard-wired for failure

Cognitive flaws such as this cause investors to make all sorts of mistakes.

Mr. Statman went through a long list: Investors tend to take profits too soon and keep losers too long. They irrationally remember what an asset was worth at some arbitrary peak. They're overconfident in their abilities to pick stocks or time the market.

People have illogical regrets about past financial decisions. And, of course, a certain number of them take credit for winners and blame their advisers for all the losers.

That last observation drew nods of agreement from advisers.

While acknowledging that some of these impossibly difficult clients should be dumped, Mr. Statman said that blaming others is natural human behavior and can be dealt with by educating investors about behavioral flaws.

"Make science your ally," he said.

The field of behavioral finance seeks to develop theories that will help deal with flawed, but normal, human behavior, Mr. Statman said. In behavioral finance theory, investors are motivated by achieving goals, not avoiding unnecessary risk, which is the premise of modern portfolio theory.

An optimized portfolio, Mr. Statman said, is nothing more than a "bundle of risk and return," which doesn't do anything by itself to motivate clients. He said it is better to segment the portfolio by distinct goals, such as retirement, college and charitable giving, and then run separate Monte Carlo simulations on each piece.

Having enough for retirement might warrant a high probability of success, while charitable giving might be less important.

"For some goals, having the money is really important, for others, not so much," Mr. Statman said.

"Better brokers have intuitively understood behavioral finance all along," said one wirehouse rep who attended the meeting and asked that his name and firm not be used. Clients need to understand that their adviser has technical proficiency, this rep said, "but it always comes down to the relationship," and that's where behavioral finance theory can help, he said.

'Temperament sorter'

One online tool brokers can use to improve communication with clients is, which has a "temperament sorter" that categorizes people by behavioral styles.

Mr. Statman said advisers can test both themselves and willing clients.

Steve Schoen, president of Allied Consulting Group in Los Angeles and acting treasurer of the Southern California IMCA chapter, said that last week's event brought in 60 members.

Unlike other chapters, it is funding its activities without the help of sponsors.


What do you think?

View comments

Recommended for you

Featured video


Big trends in RIA acquisition

Consolidation is continuing. Acquisitions and mergers are on the rise. Is there an AUM threshold that advisers need to reach for a practice to be viable? Captrust's Rush Benton offers some perspective.

Latest news & opinion

Nontraded REITs to post worst sales since 2002

The industry is on track to raise just $4.4 billion, well off the $19.6 billion it raised just four years ago, as new regulations hinder sales.

Broker protocol for recruiting a boon for clients

New research finds advisers whose firms have joined the agreement take better care of customers.

Meet our 2017 Women to Watch

Introducing 20 female financial advisers and industry executives who are distinguished leaders, advancing the business of providing advice through their creativity and hard work.

Raymond James executives call on industry to keep broker protocol

Also ask firms to pay for the administration of the protocol to 'ensure its longevity and relevance.'

Senate committee approves tax plan but full passage not assured

Several Republican senators expressed reservations about the bill, and the GOP cannot afford too many defections.


Subscribe and Save 60%

Premium Access
Print + Digital

Learn more
Subscribe to Print