House GOP urges SEC to hold off on fiduciary rule

Committee members want agency to justify need for regulation before it moves forward

Mar 20, 2011 @ 12:01 am

By Mark Schoeff Jr.

Republicans on the House Financial Services Committee are urging the Securities and Exchange Commission to refrain from imposing a universal fiduciary duty of care for retail investment advice.

“It is our view that the commission has not identified and defined clear problems that would justify a rulemaking, and does not have a solid basis upon which to move forward,” stated a March 17 letter to SEC Chairman Mary Schapiro from Rep. Scott Garrett, R-N.J., chairman of the Capital Markets Subcommittee, and 13 of his GOP colleagues on the panel.

The Republicans criticized a January SEC staff report, mandated by the Dodd-Frank financial reform law, recommending that a universal fiduciary standard of care be required to protect investors, who the report contends are confused by the differing rules for investment advisers and broker dealers.

Currently, advisers must offer advice that is in a client's best interest, while broker-dealers adhere to a less stringent rule that says their guidance must be suitable for an investor's needs, timelines and risk appetite.

The Dodd-Frank measure authorizes the SEC to proceed with rulemaking on fiduciary duty. But the House Republicans, echoing the dissent to the report from Republican SEC commissioners Kathleen Casey and Troy Paredes, wrote: “A much stronger analytical and empirical foundation than provided by the study is required” before the SEC writes a rule.

An SEC spokesman declined to comment about the letter.

The Republicans suggested that the SEC “conduct a thorough cost benefit analysis that considers consumer preferences” and also “assess the broader practical impact” of a universal fiduciary duty on “the entire financial marketplace.”

They said that they intend to hold a hearing “in the coming weeks.”

In addition, the lawmakers told the SEC to consider how a universal standard of care would align with the fiduciary rule the Labor Department is writing under federal retirement law.

They also said that the SEC must take into account the ramifications of a staff report on investment adviser oversight.

That study, also mandated by Dodd-Frank and delivered in January, provides three recommendations to Congress to increase adviser examinations: authorize the SEC to charge user fees to fund the monitoring, establish a self-regulatory organization, and allow the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority Inc. to expand its jurisdiction to include advisers who are dually registered as broker-dealers.

An advocate for fiduciary duty maintains that the letter isn't necessarily a defeat for him and his allies.

David Tittsworth, executive director of the Investment Adviser Association, noted that, like Ms. Casey and Mr. Paredes, the congressional Republicans didn't explicitly state opposition to the idea of universal fiduciary duty.

“Nobody can read too much into this right now,” Mr. Tittsworth said.

“The [fiduciary duty] issues have always been controversial,” he said. “This underscores that they're going to remain controversial.”

In fact, Mr. Tittsworth said that he is looking forward to a hearing, which might cover fiduciary duty as well as the potential for an adviser SRO.

“A hearing does not equal regulation,” he said. “It does not equal legislation, but it can take the issue to a different level.”

E-mail Mark Schoeff Jr. at


What do you think?

View comments

Recommended for you

Featured video


Advisers beware: tax law has unintended consequences

Commission accounts could be preferable for some clients, and advisers could be incentivized to move from employee broker-dealers to independent channels.

Recommended Video

Path to growth

Latest news & opinion

Bond investors have more to worry about than a government shutdown

Inflation worries, international rates pushing Treasuries yields higher.

Morgan Stanley reports a loss of advisers after exiting the protocol for broker recruiting

The firm said it lost 47 brokers in the fourth quarter, the most in any quarter of 2017.

Morgan Stanley's wealth management fees climb to all-time high

Improvement reflect firm's shift of more clients into fee-based accounts priced on asset levels, which boosts results as markets rise.

Legislation would make it harder for investors to sue mutual funds over high fees

A plaintiff would have to state in their initial complaint why fiduciary duty was breached, and then prove the violation with 'clear and convincing evidence.'

Relying on trainees, Merrill Lynch boosts adviser headcount in 2017

Questions remain about long-term effectiveness of wirehouse's move away from recruiting experienced brokers.


Hi! Glad you're here and we hope you like all the great work we do here at InvestmentNews. But what we do is expensive and is funded in part by our sponsors. So won't you show our sponsors a little love by whitelisting It'll help us continue to serve you.

Yes, show me how to whitelist

Ad blocker detected. Please whitelist us or give premium a try.


Subscribe and Save 60%

Premium Access
Print + Digital

Learn more
Subscribe to Print