Only 5% of analysts' ratings are 'sells' — and they're almost always wrong

Ones who get it right really stand out from the pack, say industry watchers

May 20, 2011 @ 12:56 pm

+ Zoom

Motorola Mobility Holdings Inc. had rallied 40% from its spinoff when Adnaan Ahmad started covering the stock with a “sell” rating. The mobile-phone maker has lost nearly all its gain since his Jan. 21 report.

“The market was pricing in strong profits for its handset business, which I found outrageous for a company that's not a low-cost leader or a niche vendor,” said Ahmad, a London-based analyst at Berenberg Bank who has also covered phone stocks for Morgan Stanley and Merrill Lynch & Co.

Ahmad is one of the few analysts who issued “sell” recommendations and fewer still whose advice turned out to be right during the biggest U.S. market rally since 1955. Just 5.1% of analyst ratings are “sells,” according to data compiled by Bloomberg. Among 1,890 analysts tracked by Bloomberg for this story, fewer than 1% advised investors to unload a Standard & Poor's 500 stock that later showed a decline, or rose only after they upgraded it, the data show.

“Any calls that an analyst makes that's right deserves some praise and sells are so few and far between,” said Bruce Bittles, chief investment strategist at Milwaukee-based Robert W. Baird & Co., which oversees $85 billion. “An analyst who's a good analyst and does great, honest work, if he puts out a ‘sell' signal, it should be looked at.”

Oil Drilling

Diamond Offshore Drilling Inc. had rallied 73% by October 2009 from its March low when Scott Gruber of Sanford C. Bernstein & Co. initiated coverage with “underperform.” The Houston-based deepwater oil driller fell 33 percent, from $94.17 to $62.83, compared with an 11% decline by the S&P 500 Oil & Gas Drilling Index, through July 26, when New York-based Gruber lifted his rating to “market perform.” Diamond Offshore has since climbed back to $72.06.

Charles Cerankosky, the Cleveland-based analyst of Northcoast Research Holdings LLC, has maintained his “sell” call since June 2009 for Supervalu Inc., when the Eden Prairie, Minnesota-based owner of Save-A-Lot and Albertsons grocery stores was trading at about $13. The stock has declined 20% in the past year, and is now at $11, as sales slumped 7.5% in fiscal 2011 from the prior period.

Motorola, after pioneering mobile-phone technology in the 1980s and 1990s, saw its market share fall to 2.4% last year from 21.9% in the second quarter of 2006, according to researcher Gartner Inc. Motorola Mobility, made up of the mobile-phone and set-top box businesses, was spun off from what is now Motorola Solutions Inc. after billionaire investor Carl Icahn pressed for a split to improve performance.

Competition Concern

More than 50% of analysts recommend the stock today, while 38% rate it as a “hold.” Three analysts have a bearish recommendation. Ahmad said that while some analysts may think Motorola Mobility will get help from an improving industry and Chief Executive Officer Sanjay Jha's leadership, he's concerned about the company's competition.

“I thought the company was going to be stuck between a rock and a hard place, and hence margins were going to come under pressure,” Ahmad said. “That's been happening much more quickly than I anticipated.”

The Libertyville, Illinois-based company's stock has lost 31% since Ahmad's “sell” rating, falling from $34.88 on Jan. 21 to $23.96 yesterday.

The bearish recommendations identified by Bloomberg preceded a decline in the stock price between January 2009 to April 6, 2011. The S&P 500 companies tracked were those with at least 15 ratings and the analysts had to have given at least one recommendation in 2011.

Analysts give fewer “sell” ratings because stocks tend to rise over time, according to Eric Teal of First Citizens Bancshares Inc. and Timothy Ghriskey of the Solaris Group LLC. That makes calls like Ahmad's notable for their rarity and accuracy, they said.

Market Doubles

The S&P 500 doubled from its March 2009 low to 1,363.61 on April 29, its highest level since June 5, 2008, as government stimulus measures and corporate earnings that have topped analyst estimates. Only 10 stocks in the S&P 500 are lower now than when the bull market began in March 2009, according to Bloomberg data. The S&P 500 rose 0.2% to 1,343.6 at 4 p.m. yesterday.

“Analysts are swimming upstream,” said Teal, chief investment officer at First Citizens in Raleigh, North Carolina, which manages about $5.2 billion. “History indicates that markets rise over time, so it's challenging for analysts to identify those companies that won't benefit from at least a rising tide.”

The S&P 500 rose 5.7% annually from 1930 through 2010, data compiled by Bloomberg show. The benchmark gauge did fall 57% from its October 2007 record through March 2009, amid the worst recession since the Great Depression.

‘A Lot Easier'

“It was a lot easier to put ‘sells' on in the fall of 2008 than it is today,” said Ghriskey, chief investment officer at Solaris in Bedford Hills, New York, which manages $2 billion.

Christopher Blansett, a San Francisco-based alternative energy analyst at JPMorgan Chase & Co., covers 12 companies, according to Bloomberg data. Five are rated “underweight,” four are recommended “overweight” and three are “neutral.”

Blansett, who has worked at JPMorgan for almost seven years, rated MEMC Electronic Materials Inc. in June 2009 with an “underweight.” The stock traded as high as $20.94 at the time. The maker of silicon wafers for semiconductors and solar panels has lost about half its value since then, at $10.40 yesterday.

“We're probably the most bearish people on the solar outlook on the Street” among larger firms, Blansett said. “You tie that with the fact that MEMC has increasingly shifted their business toward solar and they've increasingly impaired their balance sheet in order to increase the company's focus on that sector. We just don't see any reason why the stock's going to work anytime soon.”

Note Sale

MEMC has missed analyst estimates for the past four quarters. The St. Peters, Missouri-based company has 10 “buy” ratings, 11 “holds” and four “sells.” It sold $550 million of senior notes March 3, according to Bloomberg data.

“Tech investors really dislike companies owning debt,” Blansett said. “The fundamental concept is these stocks and these industries are cyclical. Tech investors look for companies with good balance sheets to have buffer when the cycle rolls over. You get very concerned when there's a company with a lot of debt.”

Blansett said that analysts that have built strong relationships with investors may be more confident in making bearish calls, while newer analysts may find it harder until they build their investor base and contacts with company management.

“It's tough to be negative on a stock. That might reduce your level of corporate access and overall interaction with the company,” he said. “Some people don't have the stamina to deal with being underweight companies for a very long time because it can be very painful.”

Housing Crisis

Michael Widner, a Baltimore-based analyst with Stifel Nicolaus & Co., rated D.R. Horton Inc. with a “sell” twice, in April 2009 and August 2009. The Fort Worth, Texas-based homebuilder plunged more than 70% in about two months to a low of $4.34 in November 2008 during the housing crisis.

Horton slumped 9.1% after Widner's first “sell” recommendation in April when it had climbed to about $10, and 12% after his second, when it again approached $12. He lifted his rating to a “hold” in June. The stock closed at $11.76 yesterday.

“I'm not in a business for a popularity contest,” he said. “Investors recognize there's a value to honesty. My niche is to provide good research and tell people what I think. Even though people may not like to hear ‘It's time to sell,' they respect it when it turns out you were right.”

--Bloomberg News--


What do you think?

View comments

Recommended for you

Sponsored financial news

Upcoming Event

Jun 27


Emerging Market Debt: 5 Forces at Work

When it comes to emerging market debt, there are a series of forces that help you drive better results for your clients. In today's continually changing market environment, it is critical to know the forces at play to help keep your investment... Learn more

Accepted for 1 CE Credit from the CFP Board. Approved by IMCA for 1 CIMA®/CIMC®/CPWA® CE credit. Approved for 1 CFA Credit.

Featured video


Federated's Orlando: The economic and financial midyear outlook

As a country, are we stuck in neutral? Federated's Phil Orlando explains what he believes needs to happen to create an economic surge. (Hint: It rhymes with "crump.")

Video Spotlight

Will It Last As Long As Your Clients Do?

Sponsored by Prudential

Video Spotlight

The Catalyst

Sponsored by Pershing

Latest news & opinion

10 funds with largest 3-year outflows

Even well-managed funds that have beaten the S&P 500’s 10.1% average annual gain have watched investors flee.

Wirehouse training programs are back

At one time, major brokerage houses ran large, expensive training programs for thousands of young brokers, and now it looks as if they are about to return to that model.

New military pension rules need financial advisers to step up and serve

Matching defined contribution plan expected to see more money, more need for sound advice.

Brian Block's $4 million bonus was tied to a key metric at ARCP

Prosecution rests case in fraud trial against CFO of American Realty Capital Properties.

Edward Jones is winning the Google search war

Brokerage firm's digital marketing investment helps land it at the top of local and overall search engine results, report finds.


Subscribe and Save 60%

Premium Access
Print + Digital

Learn more
Subscribe to Print