MassMutual 401(k) suit takes litigation into new territory

Complaint raises possibility that group annuities, stable value products could become focus of future actions

Nov 8, 2013 @ 2:35 pm

By Darla Mercado

A recently filed case involving allegations that 401(k) plan sponsors charged excessive fees is raising questions on whether general account products, group annuities and stable-value products might also become a focal point in future litigation.

Dennis Gordan, a participant in Massachusetts Mutual Life Insurance Co.'s retirement plan, filed suit against the insurer along with a slate of fellow participants in the insurer's thrift plan on Tuesday in the U.S. District Court in Massachusetts.

He alleged that MassMutual, its investment fiduciary and plan administrative committees, as well as a group of executives, offered “almost exclusively” proprietary funds via a group annuity contract made available to the workers.

The suit is no ordinary 401(k) fee case.

For one thing, Mr. Gordan is represented by Jerry Schlichter of Schlichter Bogard & Denton LLP, an attorney who's won settlements against Cigna Corp., Caterpillar Inc. and Bechtel Corp. in 401(k) fee suits. Mr. Schlichter also is representing participants in Ameriprise Financial Inc.'s 401(k) in a suit against the company.

This latest suit also could give rise to a wave of litigation on group annuities, stable-value and general account products, noted Marcia Wagner, managing director at The Wagner Law Group.

“There is an amazing amount of potential for cross-subsidization, where the cost of the product will subsidize record keeping, marketing and compensation,” she said. “The problem is that in many of these products, that's not disclosed. With stable value, it's almost impossible to tell the rate of return and how it's calculated.”

“It's not just group annuities, but stable-value and general accounts that will be the next shoe to fall,” Ms. Wagner said.

Mr. Schlichter declined to predict whether there would be a rise in litigation based on these products, but he stressed that firms that manufacture financial products owe a fiduciary duty to their workers.

“Fiduciaries who populate a plan with their own products have a duty to determine whether those products are complying with the fiduciary standard; they can't favor their proprietary products,” Mr. Schlichter said.

In the MassMutual case, participants could choose to use MassMutual separate investment accounts or the insurer's general account, also known as a fixed-interest account, within the annuity, according to the suit. Terms of the annuity contract figured prominently in the allegations.

For instance, the suit cites a provision in the contract that barred the plan sponsor from adopting “any change or amendment that would have an adverse effect on MassMutual's administrative procedures or the financial experience of MassMutual.”

As much as 40% of the plan's assets were in the carrier's fixed-interest account, according to the suit. Mr. Gordan claimed that the insurer and its executives had more than $500 million in working capital for their general account, all coming from MassMutual's employees' retirement savings. Further, the company made additional revenue from spread — the difference between what the investments in the general account earned and what was credited to the plan, according to the suit.

Fees on the general-account product, counting for record keeping and risk charges, totaled between 115 and 175 basis points, according to the suit. Meanwhile, earnings from spread reached multiples of those figures and were never disclosed to participants, Mr. Gordan alleged.

“We believe the comprehensive retirement benefits we offer our participants help them save toward a secure financial future,” said Patty Norris Lubold, a MassMutual spokeswoman. “We will defend vigorously against these baseless allegations.”

0
Comments

What do you think?

View comments

Recommended for you

Sponsored financial news

Upcoming Event

Apr 30

Conference

Retirement Income Summit

Join InvestmentNews at the 12th annual Retirement Income Summit - the industry's premier retirement planning conference.Much has changed - and much remains to be learned. Attend and discuss how the future is full of opportunity for ... Learn more

Featured video

INTV

When can advisers expect an SEC fiduciary rule proposal and other regs this year?

Managing editor Christina Nelson and senior reporter Mark Schoeff Jr. discuss regulations of consequence to financial advisers in 2018, and their likely timing.

Recommended Video

Path to growth

Latest news & opinion

Cutting through the red tape of adviser regulation is tricky

Don't expect a simple rollback of rules under the Trump administration in 2018 — instead, regulators are on pace to bolster financial adviser oversight.

Bond investors have more to worry about than a government shutdown

Inflation worries, international rates pushing Treasuries yields higher.

State measures to prevent elder financial abuse gaining steam

A growing number of states are looking to pass rules preventing exploitation of seniors.

Morgan Stanley reports a loss of advisers after exiting the protocol for broker recruiting

The firm said it lost 47 brokers in the fourth quarter, the most in any quarter of 2017.

Morgan Stanley's wealth management fees climb to all-time high

Improvement reflect firm's shift of more clients into fee-based accounts priced on asset levels, which boosts results as markets rise.

X

Hi! Glad you're here and we hope you like all the great work we do here at InvestmentNews. But what we do is expensive and is funded in part by our sponsors. So won't you show our sponsors a little love by whitelisting investmentnews.com? It'll help us continue to serve you.

Yes, show me how to whitelist investmentnews.com

Ad blocker detected. Please whitelist us or give premium a try.

X

Subscribe and Save 60%

Premium Access
Print + Digital

Learn more
Subscribe to Print