A four-way duel among robo-adviser biz models: Which is best?

Breaking down the big categories of online financial advice including what they offer and how much it costs

Apr 21, 2014 @ 11:37 am

By Michael Kitces

In recent weeks, several of the so-called “robo-advisers” have raised a significant amount of venture capital, attempting to build on their early successes and scale their businesses and disrupt the traditional financial services industry. In fact, with $95M of capital raised in just the past few weeks, the question has even been raised about whether a robo-adviser "bubble" is emerging.

Notwithstanding the amount of money flowing into the robo-adviser "channel," though, it's crucial to note that the leading robo-advisers actually run substantively different business models and have very different value propositions. And with each iterating on a different underlying model, a sort of horse race is emerging and the growth (or lack thereof) for each platform in the coming years — along with how each navigates the next inevitable bear market that will eventually come along — may reveal a great deal about what value consumers do and don't place on different parts of the (robo) adviser value proposition.

Accordingly, the four key robo-adviser models to be aware of are:

Monitor and Give Suggestions (For Consumers To Implement Themselves). This business model charges what is usually a flat monthly fee (e.g., $15 to $50 a month month depending on account size) to monitor all of an individual's accounts (through account aggregation tools), and provide periodic recommendations on what to buy and sell, either to swap out poor performers and high-cost funds for better-performing low-cost ones, or to provide re-balancing recommendations. Key players in this category include Jemstep and MarketRiders.

Online-based Portfolio Manager. This business model charges a percentage of AUM (typically 0.15% to 0.5%) to directly manage assets (which means the funds are actually transferred to the online investment adviser). Services implicitly include investment selection and implementation, and also typically include re-balancing and tax-loss harvesting. Key players in this category include Wealthfront and Betterment (along with FutureAdvisor, though it only reported $13.4M on its latest ADV as of September 2013, compared with recent announcements of $500M of Betterment and $800M for Wealthfront).

Technology Platform for Advisers. In a notable pivot, Betterment was the first to break ranks from the other robo-advisers and offer an "Institutional" version of its platform to partner with advisers. Called Betterment Institutional, the platform will offer all the investment management, trading, and technology support of the Betterment direct-to-consumer platform, but in a private-label version that's available for advisers to offer to their clients.

Technology-augmented Humans. In this category are the "robo-advisers" staffed by real human advisers who are simply delivering their solutions from a technology-augmented platform, for either an AUM fee or a flat monthly fee. Notably, because these platforms ultimately deliver human advisers to work directly with clients, simply on a virtual basis, they are arguably not really "robo-advisers" at all, but simply technology-augmented humans (or "cyborg" advisors), not unlike a number of traditional advisory firms that are capable of working with clients virtually. Key players in this category including Personal Capital and LearnVest.

So what do you think? Which business model and value proposition will win? Will it be the technology-augmented human advisers or the platforms that help human advisers run their own firms more like a robo-adviser on their own? Will the online portfolio manager solutions be able to get clients to change their behavior and stay the course in a bear market? Will the suggestions-to-do-yourself model gain traction or stumble? Or is there room enough for all of them to co-exist and survive and thrive?

Michael Kitces is a partner and director of research for Pinnacle Advisory Group, and publisher of the financial planning industry blog Nerd's Eye View. You can follow him on Twitter at @MichaelKitces, or connect with him on Google+.


What do you think?

View comments

Recommended for you

Featured Research

The 2015 InvestmentNews Adviser Technology Study

This in-depth study provides a blueprint for the industry, providing actionable information to advisers, along with the latest solutions to help them drive profitability, efficiency and growth for their firm.

Featured video


When can advisers expect an SEC fiduciary rule proposal and other regs this year?

Managing editor Christina Nelson and senior reporter Mark Schoeff Jr. discuss regulations of consequence to financial advisers in 2018, and their likely timing.

Recommended Video

Path to growth

Latest news & opinion

Bond investors have more to worry about than a government shutdown

Inflation worries, international rates pushing Treasuries yields higher.

State measures to prevent elder financial abuse gaining steam

A growing number of states are looking to pass rules preventing exploitation of seniors.

Morgan Stanley reports a loss of advisers after exiting the protocol for broker recruiting

The firm said it lost 47 brokers in the fourth quarter, the most in any quarter of 2017.

Morgan Stanley's wealth management fees climb to all-time high

Improvement reflect firm's shift of more clients into fee-based accounts priced on asset levels, which boosts results as markets rise.

Legislation would make it harder for investors to sue mutual funds over high fees

A plaintiff would have to state in their initial complaint why fiduciary duty was breached, and then prove the violation with 'clear and convincing evidence.'


Hi! Glad you're here and we hope you like all the great work we do here at InvestmentNews. But what we do is expensive and is funded in part by our sponsors. So won't you show our sponsors a little love by whitelisting investmentnews.com? It'll help us continue to serve you.

Yes, show me how to whitelist investmentnews.com

Ad blocker detected. Please whitelist us or give premium a try.


Subscribe and Save 60%

Premium Access
Print + Digital

Learn more
Subscribe to Print