The best- and worst-performing target date funds

Apr 23, 2014 @ 12:05 pm

Target date 2016-20

3-month return1-year return3-year return5-year returnNet assets ($M)Expense ratio*
Top 10
Manning & Napier Target 2020 I (MTNIX)2.60%11.40%8.31%14.36%$177.80.86%
Legg Mason Target Retirement 2020 A (LMWAX)2.34%10.65%7.51%15.79%$6.11.15%
American Century One Choice 2020 R6 (ARBDX)2.03%N/AN/AN/A$23.80.55%
BMO Target Retirement 2020 R-6 (BTRGX)1.97%12.36%8.74%16.22%$110.30.54%
PNC Target 2020 I (PDTCX)1.95%8.27%N/AN/A$1.10.76%
Harbor Target Retirement 2020 Inst (HARJX)1.95%6.95%6.72%12.27%$28.60.68%
Wells Fargo Advantage DJ Target 2020 A (STTRX)1.89%6.69%5.57%11.21%$2,887.80.86%
American Century One Choice 2020 A (ARBMX)1.86%9.52%7.94%12.94%$1,283.61.07%
JHancock Retire Living through 2020 A (JLDAX)1.82%12.11%7.76%16.62%$1,217.41.33%
Vanguard Target Retirement 2020 Inv (VTWNX)1.81%11.98%8.74%14.93%$25,390.00.16%
Bottom 5
Presidential Managed Risk 2020 A (PZBAX)0.86%7.18%N/AN/A$20.51.05%
DWS LifeCompass 2020 S (SPGRX)0.98%10.72%6.99%13.85%$172.90.82%
Vantagepoint Milestone 2020 Inv M (VPROX)1.05%11.53%8.01%13.74%$680.50.83%
Pimco RealRetirement 2020 A (PTYAX)1.13%0.63%3.80%9.74%$103.21.11%
Hartford Target Retirement 2020 A (HTWAX)1.14%8.91%6.40%14.56%$148.21.05%

Target date 2021-25

Top 103-month return1-year return3-year return5-year returnNet assets ($M)Expense ratio*
Manning & Napier Target 2025 I (MTOAX)2.82%13.30%N/AN/A$16.60.87%
Legg Mason Target Retirement 2025 A (LMXAX)2.33%11.99%8.15%16.49%$8.41.15%
BMO Target Retirement 2025 I (BRTFX)2.20%N/AN/AN/A$0.030.69%
Harbor Target Retirement 2025 Inst (HARMX)2.08%8.49%6.93%13.56%$10.60.69%
Great-West Lifetime 2025 I T (MXALX)2.05%8.10%7.12%N/A$299.10.89%
American Century One Choice 2025 R6 (ARWDX)2.02%N/AN/AN/A$18.90.57%
Great-West Lifetime 2025 II T (MXCLX)1.96%10.81%8.16%0.00%$1,489.00.92%
GuideStone Funds MyDestination 2025 GS4 (GMWZX)1.94%11.39%8.54%17.49%$579.71.21%
Great-West Lifetime 2025 III T (MXELX)1.88%13.36%9.08%0.00%$89.30.92%
American Century One Choice 2025 A (ARWAX)1.85%10.55%8.32%13.76%$2,081.51.10%
Bottom 5
Hartford Target Retirement 2025 R3 (HTKRX)0.98%10.42%7.10%15.00%$82.91.35%
TIAA-CREF Lifecycle 2025 Retirement (TCLFX)1.10%13.90%9.40%16.20%$2,285.70.69%
Vantagepoint Milestone 2025 Inv M (VPRNX)1.11%13.50%8.86%15.14%$563.80.84%
BlackRock LifePath Active 2025 Inv A (BAPDX)1.19%11.70%7.80%14.83%$27.00.90%
Fidelity Freedom 2025 (FFTWX)1.20%12.00%7.57%15.55%$8,881.20.73%

Target date 2026-30

Top 103-month return1-year return3-year return5-year returnNet assets ($M)Expense ratio*
Manning & Napier Target 2030 I (MTPIX)2.71%14.60%9.93%16.82%$188.10.86%
Legg Mason Target Retirement 2030 A (LMVAX)2.36%13.47%8.80%17.19%$5.21.15%
Harbor Target Retirement 2030 Inst (HARPX)2.06%10.71%7.61%15.03%$24.50.72%
PNC Target 2030 I (PDTEX)2.01%12.24%N/AN/A$1.60.87%
American Century One Choice 2030 R6 (ARCUX)2.01%N/AN/AN/A$20.20.59%
Putnam RetirementReady 2030 A (PRRQX)1.93%12.96%8.24%16.42%$43.91.05%
BMO Target Retirement 2030 R-6 (BTRLX)1.93%16.16%10.05%18.18%$96.10.61%
American Century One Choice 2030 A (ARCMX)1.84%11.61%8.75%14.68%$1,245.71.12%
BlackRock Lifepath Index 2030 Inst (LINIX)1.82%11.24%N/AN/A$605.30.26%
Vanguard Target Retirement 2030 Inv (VTHRX)1.74%14.96%9.81%17.17%$21,022.20.17%
Bottom 5
DWS LifeCompass 2030 A (PLUSX)0.70%13.70%7.55%15.78%$60.91.07%
Presidential Managed Risk 2030 A (PZCAX)0.77%7.89%N/AN/A$12.61.06%
MainStay Retirement 2030 A (MRTTX)0.85%15.04%9.27%16.22%$163.31.08%
BlackRock LifePath Active 2030 Inv A (BAPEX)0.86%12.87%7.82%15.56%$28.60.93%
TIAA-CREF Lifecycle 2030 Retirement (TCLNX)1.01%15.55%9.95%17.32%$2,200.30.70%

Target date 2031-35

Top 103-month return1-year return3-year return5-year returnNet assets ($M)Expense ratio*
Manning & Napier Target 2035 I (MTQIX)2.67%16.04%N/AN/A$12.00.87%
Legg Mason Target Retirement 2035 A (LMNAX)2.23%15.60%9.65%18.18%$6.11.15%
Harbor Target Retirement 2035 Inst (HARUX)2.15%13.16%8.46%16.33%$6.50.74%
Putnam RetirementReady 2035 A (PRRWX)2.01%15.25%9.37%17.49%$33.61.09%
American Century One Choice 2035 R6 (ARLDX)1.90%N/AN/AN/A$14.80.61%
Great-West Lifetime 2035 I T (MXGLX)1.84%12.24%8.65%N/A$230.70.95%
American Century One Choice 2035 A (ARYAX)1.80%12.87%9.30%15.75%$1,616.81.15%
BlackRock Lifepath Index 2035 Inst (LIJIX)1.78%12.39%N/AN/A$264.00.27%
Great-West Lifetime 2035 II T (MXILX)1.71%14.90%9.57%N/A$1,150.80.97%
Vanguard Target Retirement 2035 Inv (VTTHX)1.71%16.41%10.30%18.15%$22,141.30.18%
Bottom 5
TIAA-CREF Lifecycle 2035 Retire (TCLRX)0.83%17.13%10.39%18.27%$2,246.10.72%
BlackRock LifePath Active 2035 Inv A (BAPGX)0.84%14.08%7.68%16.05%$15.70.96%
BMO Target Retirement 2035 I (BRTJX)0.90%N/AN/AN/A$0.10.76%
ING Retirement Solution 2035 I (IRSNX)0.96%14.67%N/AN/A$0.10.90%
Hartford Target Retirement 2035 R5 (HTLTX)1.03%14.79%9.12%17.74%$64.30.85%

Target date 2036-40

Top 103-month return1-year return3-year return5-year returnNet assets ($M)Expense ratio*
Manning & Napier Target 2040 I (MTTIX)2.59%17.39%9.84%18.08%$122.50.87%
Legg Mason Target Retirement 2040 A (LMYAX)2.28%17.59%10.47%18.96%$6.21.15%
Harbor Target Retirement 2040 Inst (HARYX)2.10%15.50%9.03%17.49%$19.20.76%
Putnam RetirementReady 2040 A (PRRZX)2.08%17.05%10.26%18.21%$23.61.15%
PNC Target 2040 I (PDTGX)2.04%14.58%N/A0.00%$1.20.91%
American Century One Choice 2040 R6 (ARDUX)1.99%N/AN/A0.00%$13.20.64%
Invesco Balanced-Risk Retire 2040 A (TNDAX)1.92%1.41%8.11%15.61%$78.61.23%
BMO Target Retirement 2040 R-6 (BTRQX)1.91%18.14%10.77%19.17%$67.90.61%
American Century One Choice 2040 A (ARDMX)1.86%14.11%9.82%16.73%$903.21.18%
BlackRock Lifepath Index 2040 Inst (LIKIX)1.82%13.39%N/AN/A$379.50.27%
Bottom 5
Presidential Managed Risk 2040 A (PZDAX)0.33%9.40%N/AN/A$8.61.05%
BlackRock LifePath Active 2040 Inv A (BAPHX)0.55%14.85%8.09%16.30%$19.60.98%
DWS LifeCompass 2040 A (TGTAX)0.67%15.80%8.13%16.55%$27.51.10%
MainStay Retirement 2040 A (MSRTX)0.75%16.79%9.93%17.10%$112.51.08%
TIAA-CREF Lifecycle 2040 Retire (TCLOX)0.81%18.11%10.81%18.58%$2,962.70.72%

Target date 2041-45

Top 103-month return1-year return3-year return5-year returnNet assets ($M)Expense ratio*
Manning & Napier Target 2045 I (MTUIX)2.56%18.04%N/AN/A$5.20.88%
Putnam RetirementReady 2045 A (PRVLX)2.15%18.00%10.67%18.58%$17.51.20%
Harbor Target Retirement 2045 Inst (HACCX)2.11%17.78%9.68%18.54%$3.80.78%
American Century One Choice 2045 R6 (ARDOX)2.08%N/AN/A0.00%$11.50.67%
Legg Mason Target Retirement 2045 A (LMKAX)2.06%17.37%10.11%18.74%$3.81.15%
BMO Target Retirement 2045 I (BRTOX)1.99%N/AN/A0.00%$0.040.76%
American Century One Choice 2045 A (AROAX)1.86%15.06%10.18%17.26%$1,139.81.22%
BlackRock Lifepath Index 2045 Inst (LIHIX)1.78%14.43%N/AN/A$135.90.28%
Vanguard Target Retirement 2045 Inv (VTIVX)1.69%17.51%10.75%18.46%$13,366.00.18%
Fidelity Freedom Index 2045 W (FIOFX)1.66%14.07%8.40%N/A$583.50.16%
Bottom 5
BlackRock LifePath Active 2045 Inv A (BAPJX)0.43%15.73%8.82%16.63%$9.41.00%
Hartford Target Retirement 2045 R3 (HTNRX)0.80%14.50%8.11%17.56%$32.81.40%
TIAA-CREF Lifecycle 2045 Inst (TTFIX)0.83%18.34%11.06%18.77%$902.00.47%
ING Retirement Solution 2045 I (IRSPX)0.86%16.52%N/AN/A$0.10.92%
MassMutual RetireSMART 2045 A (MMKAX)1.02%17.27%9.74%N/A$14.41.25%

Target date 2046-50

Top 103-month return1-year return3-year return5-year returnNet assets ($M)Expense ratio*
Manning & Napier Target 2050 I (MTYIX)2.51%18.13%10.27%18.74%$56.50.87%
Putnam RetirementReady 2050 A 2.14%18.69%10.98%18.85%$11.71.24%
Legg Mason Target Retirement 2050 A (LMJAX)2.11%17.40%10.20%18.88%$4.21.15%
Invesco Balanced-Risk Retire 2050 A (TNEAX)2.07%1.50%8.21%15.97%$40.51.36%
PNC Target 2050 I (PDTIX)2.01%15.51%N/A0.00%$1.30.91%
Harbor Target Retirement 2050 Inst (HAFFX)1.99%19.53%10.34%18.99%$20.70.79%
American Century One Choice 2050 R6 (ARFEX)1.98%N/AN/A0.00%$7.80.68%
American Century One Choice 2050 A (ARFMX)1.87%15.37%10.32%17.59%$484.61.23%
BlackRock Lifepath Index 2050 Inst (LIPIX)1.77%15.24%N/AN/A$131.30.28%
JHancock Retire Living through 2050 1 (JLKOX)1.72%17.68%N/AN/A$202.70.92%
Bottom 5
Presidential Managed Risk 2050 A (PZEAX)-0.08%9.91%N/AN/A$5.01.04%
BlackRock LifePath Active 2050 Inv A (BAPKX)0.37%16.66%8.93%16.92%$8.61.02%
MainStay Retirement 2050 A (MSRLX)0.66%17.67%10.14%17.68%$68.81.08%
TIAA-CREF Lifecycle 2050 Inst (TFTIX)0.83%18.43%11.07%18.80%$507.60.47%
USAA Target Retirement 2050 (URFFX)0.86%13.67%7.82%17.09%$569.60.88%

Target date 2051-55

Top 103-month return1-year return3-year return5-year returnNet assets ($M)Expense ratio*
BMO Target Retirement 2055 I (BRTSX)2.69%N/AN/AN/A$0.040.76%
Manning & Napier Target 2055 I (MTZIX)2.53%18.19%N/AN/A$0.90.87%
Putnam RetirementReady 2055 A 2.17%18.93%10.63%N/A$1.91.26%
American Century One Choice 2055 R6 (AREUX)2.06%N/AN/AN/A$3.10.69%
American Century One Choice 2055 Inv (AREVX)1.89%16.12%10.80%N/A$92.00.99%
BlackRock Lifepath Index 2055 Inst (LIVIX)1.82%16.16%N/AN/A$30.90.29%
Vanguard Target Retirement 2055 Inv (VFFVX)1.71%17.50%10.84%N/A$1,328.50.18%
AllianzGI Retirement 2055 A (GLIAX)1.70%9.94%N/AN/A$6.31.10%
Fidelity Freedom Index 2055 W (FDEWX)1.60%14.76%N/AN/A$87.70.16%
Nationwide Destination 2055 A (NTDAX)1.56%17.36%9.89%N/A$15.80.92%
Bottom 5
BlackRock LifePath Active 2055 Inv A (BAPLX)0.17%17.28%N/AN/A$2.41.03%
TIAA-CREF Lifecycle 2055 Inst (TTRIX)0.83%18.46%N/AN/A$69.40.47%
ING Retirement Solution 2055 I (IRSVX)0.86%16.62%N/AN/A$0.10.92%
ING Solution 2055 Portfolio I (IISPX)1.02%16.90%9.58%N/A$96.80.89%
Fidelity Freedom 2055 (FDEEX)1.03%16.00%N/AN/A$350.80.82%

As of March 31. N/A = not available (fund has been in operation for less than the year indicated). *Net prospectus Source: Morningstar Inc.

Featured video

INTV

Ed Slott: The conversation advisers need to have with spousal IRA beneficiaries

Clients who inherit IRAs from their spouses need to decide whether to remain beneficiaries or do spousal rollovers. One important factor in that decision is their age, according to Ed Slott, founder of Ed Slott's Elite IRA Advisor Group.

Latest news & opinion

Is LPL's deal sweet enough for NPH's 3,200 reps and advisers?

They will have to decide if the signing package they are being offered by LPL makes sense. A lot is hanging in the balance.

Eduardo Repetto to leave Dimensional Fund Advisors

Gerald O'Reilly, currently co-CIO, will take over as co-CEO with David Butler.

Alternative strategies boomed after crisis, but haven't been tested

Because the S&P 500 has outperformed, convincing clients they need protection is a hard sell.

7 ways advisers fixed clients' biggest financial dilemmas

Sometimes it takes creativity, along with knowledge and outside help, to get a client out of a jam.

LPL Financial buys NPH, a broker-dealer network with 3,200 advisers

The deal, part of which is based on the advisers and revenue that eventually will move from NPH, could potentially cost LPL $448 million.

X

Subscribe and Save 60%

Premium Access
Print + Digital

Learn more
Subscribe to Print