Morgan Stanley case spotlights legal hurdles for indie recruits

A former Morgan Stanley adviser who joined LPL last month won back the right to serve his clients

Jun 10, 2014 @ 1:31 pm

By Mason Braswell

A former Morgan Stanley broker who took client information when he went independent with LPL Financial can begin serving his clients again after a federal judge dissolved a restraining order against him.

At the end of May, Judge Ronald B. Leighton of the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Washington overturned a temporary restraining order against Scott Maloy and denied Morgan Stanley's request to permanently bar the broker from soliciting his former clients.

“Clients are not property,” Mr. Leighton said, according to a transcript of the proceedings. “They're not indentured servants. They're not hostages.”

Once the judge denied the motion for permanent injunction, effectively closing the case, Morgan Stanley dropped litigation and is proceeding with a separate arbitration claim with the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority Inc.

The judge's denial comes as firms continue to fight tooth and nail to retain client assets, a metric that has become even more important as firms look to shift their business model to collect a fee on the percentage of assets under management, according to Andrew Parish, an industry recruiter and founder of AdvisorHub Inc.

“Firms are highly protective of their assets under management,” he said. “And given that there's been this pivot over the last two or three years into wealth management as the goose that lays the golden egg, that AUM is what produces those eggs.”

Morgan Stanley filed for a temporary injunction nine days after Mr. Maloy left. The case revolved around a box of shredded client documents and a series of e-mails he sent to himself in November 2012 and October 2013 with some non-public client information, including a death certificate, according to court documents, transcripts and an interview with Mr. Maloy.

The firm accused him of breaching contract and violating the Protocol for Broker Recruiting, which allows brokers to move between firms as long as they take limited client information, such as names and phone numbers. Both LPL and Morgan Stanley have signed the agreement, but firms still frequently look for potential violations, according to Danny Sarch, of career consulting firm Leitner Sarch Ltd.

“Firms look at immediately, is this a protocol firm and can we catch them doing anything that isn't in the protocol,” Mr. Sarch said. “They're looking for sloppiness and reasons that they can shut people down.”

In his defense, Mr. Maloy said the records, sent in November 2012 and October 2013, were e-mailed well in advance of his move and were necessary because as a single father, he frequently worked from home. The documents were shredded because the firm was remodeling the office and trying to go paperless, he said.

“If you read the case carefully, there's a very clear explanation,” Mr. Maloy said. “Firms are violating the spirit of their own protocol to make example of their brokers.”

Moreover, while the temporary restraining order was in place for approximately one week in advance of a hearing on May 22, Morgan Stanley also was contacting Mr. Maloy's approximately 85-90 households, approximately 80% to 90% of which he transferred from his days at A.G. Edwards Inc., according to court documents. He had only transferred four by the time the order came down, he said.

“They haven't heard from me and somehow there's word that there's litigation involved,” Mr. Maloy testified. “For those who haven't spoken to me, they're probably assuming the worst, that there's like a Bernie Madoff thing going on or something.”

Mr. Leighton ultimately found, however, that the information that Mr. Maloy took was not compelling enough to harm Morgan Stanley to the point that an injunction was necessary.

“The protocol is a good idea and if there was any substantial evidence that Mr. Maloy was violating his obligations under the protocol in any material way, I would gladly issue the preliminary Injunction,” he said.

Mr. Maloy is not out of the woods yet. Although he has beaten the injunction, he still faces a Finra arbitration claim from Morgan Stanley. His attorney, Stephanie Bloomfield of Gordon Thomas Honeywell Malanca Peterson & Dahheim, declined to comment on the Finra proceedings. She said only that it was on related grounds.

“The matter is properly before Finra. Morgan Stanley will allow the arbitration process to move forward and a panel of Finra arbitrators to decide the ultimate outcome of the case,” said Christine Jockle, spokeswoman for Morgan Stanley.

“I have been here many times with registered representatives and brokers,” Mr. Leighton said, according to a transcript of the proceedings. “The last time it was Morgan Stanley wearing the shoes of LPL.”


What do you think?

View comments

Recommended for you

Sponsored financial news

Upcoming Event

Apr 30


Retirement Income Summit

Join InvestmentNews at the 12th annual Retirement Income Summit - the industry's premier retirement planning conference.Much has changed - and much remains to be learned. Attend and discuss how the future is full of opportunity for ... Learn more

Featured video


Advisers beware: tax law has unintended consequences

Commission accounts could be preferable for some clients, and advisers could be incentivized to move from employee broker-dealers to independent channels.

Recommended Video

Path to growth

Latest news & opinion

Courting the Asian-American TEST

They have higher incomes and more assets than the general population, but fewer than one in five Asian-Americans has a financial adviser.

Cutting through the red tape of adviser regulation is tricky

Don't expect a simple rollback of rules under the Trump administration in 2018 — instead, regulators are on pace to bolster financial adviser oversight.

Bond investors have more to worry about than a government shutdown

Inflation worries, international rates pushing Treasuries yields higher.

State measures to prevent elder financial abuse gaining steam

A growing number of states are looking to pass rules preventing exploitation of seniors.

Morgan Stanley reports a loss of advisers after exiting the protocol for broker recruiting

The firm said it lost 47 brokers in the fourth quarter, the most in any quarter of 2017.


Hi! Glad you're here and we hope you like all the great work we do here at InvestmentNews. But what we do is expensive and is funded in part by our sponsors. So won't you show our sponsors a little love by whitelisting It'll help us continue to serve you.

Yes, show me how to whitelist

Ad blocker detected. Please whitelist us or give premium a try.


Subscribe and Save 60%

Premium Access
Print + Digital

Learn more
Subscribe to Print