Numbers Game

Numbers Gameblog

Latest research and trends from around the financial advisory business, updated regularly highlighting stats, charts, infographics and all things data.

Women's rise to senior positions at advisory firms has stalled

The business remains, especially in firm ownership and client-facing professional roles, a male-dominated field

Oct 13, 2015 @ 10:17 am

By Matt Sirinides

Women are well-represented in the financial advice industry from an overall staffing perspective — making up about half of total employees at a typical advisory firm — but that picture changes dramatically when we look deeper.

In breaking out the roles women hold, it is clear the business remains, especially in firm ownership and client-facing professional roles, a male-dominated field.

According to InvestmentNews Research's latest advisory firm benchmarking data, just 19% of people in partner-level positions, or with titles indicating ownership, are women. When it comes to employee advisers — non-owner advisers holding the Lead (Level 1), Service (Level 2) or Support (Level 3) titles — 36% are women.

While advisers in more senior roles tend to be male — a trend that hasn't budged since the 2013 InvestmentNews Adviser Compensation and Staffing Study — changes could be ahead.

(Don't miss: The 2015 Compensation and Staffing Study)

Women saw gains in entry- and intermediate-level positions that traditionally lead to more-senior professional roles. In the 2015 iteration of our study, 49% of entry-level advisers — the support adviser (Level 3) position, often known as a paraplanner, analyst or associate — were female. That was up from 44% in the 2013 study.

Women also tend to inhabit one of two other entry-level paths that can lead to client-facing professional roles down the line. Client service administrator, a job function that directly supports adviser interactions with clients, has an 84%/16% female/male split.

But research analysts and portfolio managers, roles that also can lead to more-senior advisory positions, are staying stubbornly male; both are staffed at an identical 82% male to 18% female ratio.

(Related read: What it takes to retain women advisers)

When we examine data on promotions and experience by gender, it is not difficult to find evidence for why — despite the number of women in lower-level advisory roles' rising since our last study — the number of female lead professionals has stagnated. While women and men were almost equally likely to have been promoted in the past year in the support adviser role, when we look one level up at service advisers, men were nearly twice as likely to have been promoted in the past year (21.4% vs. 12.9%).

These service advisers meet with clients and deliver the services but are not expected to win new business for the firm — with titles such as wealth adviser, financial adviser or associate adviser.

In both cases, women usually had more experience than their male counterparts, indicating they're more likely to remain in the same role longer.

A big part of that stagnancy could be business development, or winning new business in general. The sales culture and sales mentality is what leads to the upper echelons of compensation and status at firms, and it could be that women aren't successfully breaking into those roles. What we can say from evidence in the study is that new adviser positions that carve out these responsibilities, such as business development officer or business development specialist, are overwhelmingly male (96% for partners and 72% for employees), which underscores the fact that these responsibilities or opportunities aren't necessarily being embraced by or allocated to women.

(Staffing insights: The highest paying jobs at advisory firms)

Another post where women play a smaller role is in firm ownership or as primary relationship managers. We did not see much evidence of expansion in these categories in the study results.

Encouraging, however, is the increasing number of young, professional-track female advisers joining the business. Enormous advantages are inherent for advisers who serve their own representative demographic. With women increasingly serving as the primary breadwinners and financial decision makers in their households, those firms who turn an eye to gender diversity when actively recruiting and developing talent are setting themselves up for advantages they'll carry well into the future.


What do you think?

View comments

Recommended for you

Featured video


Joe Duran: How to compete in a technologically changing world

The CEO of United Capital explains why advisers should have a strong presence on smartphones, make the most of video capabilities and go "bionic" to free themselves from time-consuming chores.

Latest news & opinion

Raymond James executives call on industry to keep broker protocol

Also ask firms to pay for the administration of the protocol to 'ensure its longevity and relevance.'

Senate committee approves tax plan but full passage not assured

Several Republican senators expressed reservations about the bill, and the GOP cannot afford too many defections.

House passes tax bill, focus turns to Senate

Tax reform legislation expected to have more of a challenge in upper chamber.

SEC enforcement of advisers drops in Trump era

The agency pursued 82 cases against advisers and firms in fiscal year 2017, down from 98 the previous year.

PIABA accuses Finra of conflicts of interest

Public Investors Arbitration Bar Association report slams self-regulator over its picks for board of governors.


Subscribe and Save 60%

Premium Access
Print + Digital

Learn more
Subscribe to Print