The biggest drawbacks of the retail robo-advisers

For those looking for more than just account-level “multiple choice” investing, there's no substitute for an adviser

Feb 12, 2016 @ 10:26 am

By Sheryl Rowling

+ Zoom

In my last article, I addressed what robo-advisers do right. In general, robo-advisers provide investors who have any size portfolio the opportunity for convenient, low-cost, tax-efficient investment management. No matter the shortcomings I might mention in this article, this egalitarian offering opens the door for all to invest.

Online automated investing, although easy, is not the same thing as comprehensive wealth advisory services. For those looking for more than just account-level “multiple choice” investing, there's not a substitute for a financial adviser. Of course, I am biased (so no need to point that out in the comments!), but I also think I have points to back up my opinion. Here's what robo-advisers can't do:

• Develop a customized financial plan that addresses not only investments, but also cash flow, detailed retirement planning, insurance needs, college funding, estate planning and tax planning. An appropriate investment plan is best achieved when looking at the entire situation, not just a quick risk-profile survey.

• Save on taxes by investing on the “household” level. Investing account-by-account makes it easy to track, but it ignores perhaps the largest tax-savings opportunity: location optimization. By managing all of an investor's accounts as one portfolio, the adviser can place less tax-efficient investments into the client's individual retirement account and hold more tax-efficient investments in the taxable account. That way, for example, taxes aren't immediately payable on bond interest held in the IRA, and appreciating stocks held in the taxable account will ultimately be subject to capital gains rates, rather than ordinary tax rates if held in the IRA.

• Be there for advice and hand-holding on a personal level. A personal financial adviser can answer questions like “What happens if I sell my house this year?” or “Should I buy or lease my new car?” When the market is going crazy, a personal financial adviser can reassure and relate impacts to the particular client's situation.

• Help clients achieve all of their goals, not just investment goals.

(More robo insights: Are there too many robo platforms crowding the market?)

Of course, depending on the adviser, clients might also get “one-stop shop” services, such as tax return preparation or insurance.

There is a price for advice over and above the built-in costs of investing. It's a choice that each investor can make based on specific needs and wants.

I, personally, use the services of an attorney to prepare estate documents rather than filling out downloaded forms from the internet. I also pay for compliance consultants instead of using an online solution.

Then again, I might go for a hybrid approach — looking up my symptoms on the internet while still going to a doctor. For me, personal interaction with a trusted professional is imperative.

Sheryl Rowling is head of rebalancing solutions at Morningstar Inc. and principal at Rowling & Associates. She considers herself a non-techie user of technology.


What do you think?

View comments

Recommended for you

Featured Research

The 2015 InvestmentNews Adviser Technology Study

This in-depth study provides a blueprint for the industry, providing actionable information to advisers, along with the latest solutions to help them drive profitability, efficiency and growth for their firm.

Latest news & opinion

The appeal and pitfalls of holding unconventional assets in retirement accounts

While non-traditional asset classes held in individual retirement accounts may have return and portfolio diversification benefits, there are "unique complexities" that limit their value for most investors.

Wells Fargo's move to boost signing bonuses could give it a lift

Wirehouse is seen as trying to shore up adviser ranks that took a hit after banking scandal

New Jersey fines David Lerner Associates for nontraded REIT sales

Firm will pay $650,000 for suitability, compliance and books and records violations.

Report predicts $400 trillion retirement savings gap by 2050

Shortfall driven by longer life spans and disappointing investment returns.

Wells Fargo will ramp up spending to lure brokers

Wirehouse, after losing 400 brokers in first quarter, is bucking trend among rivals who have said they are going to cut back on spending big bucks recruiting veteran advisers


Subscribe and Save 60%

Premium Access
Print + Digital

Learn more
Subscribe to Print