Dismissal of small 401(k) plan excessive-fee lawsuit 'highly atypical'

The case, which involved a $9 million plan, was voluntarily dismissed by plaintiffs in an unusual turn of events

Jul 1, 2016 @ 10:58 am

By Greg Iacurci

+ Zoom

An excessive-fee lawsuit seen as a potential bellwether for a shift of such suits down to the small 401(k) plan market has, in a rare move, been voluntarily dismissed by plaintiffs only a few weeks after it was filed.

Plaintiffs in the suit Damberg et al v. LaMettry's Collision Inc. et al had alleged fiduciaries of a $9 million 401(k) plan breached their duties under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 by allowing excessive fees to be charged for plan investments, record keeping and administration.

At the time the suit was filed in May, legal experts said the suit could well prove to be a “harbinger” for excessive-fee suits moving down market from multibillion-dollar plans.

However, plaintiffs decided to “voluntarily dismiss this action without prejudice,” according to a document filed June 17 in the U.S. District Court for the District of Minnesota. There was no explanation provided for the dismissal.

The defense was scheduled to file a response to the original complaint by Friday, July 1, but wasn't given the opportunity to do so because of the abrupt dismissal of the case.

“This is all very strange,” said William Sjoholm, an attorney at DeWitt Ross & Stevens who represented the defendants. “We thought the lawsuit in the beginning was strange, and having it dismissed seemed appropriate. But that's really stranger considering they went through the time and effort to start the lawsuit in the first place.”

J. Ashwin Madia, principal at Madia Law and attorney for the plaintiffs in the LaMettry's lawsuit, didn't return a request for comment.

Marcia Wagner, principal at The Wagner Law Group, who's unaffiliated with the case, said it's “highly atypical” a suit would be voluntarily withdrawn.

“When something's withdrawn so quickly, I wonder if it's a personal element,” she said. Whereas such lawsuits concerning large plans are more impersonal, because corporations involved have hundreds if not thousands of employees, legal affairs feel much less so among smaller employers, she said.

The two plaintiffs representing the class both had their employment terminated involuntarily, Mr. Sjoholm said, adding that it's impossible to know if this was a motivation for the lawsuit.

Although the plaintiffs could technically bring suit again (because the case was dismissed without prejudice) it would be “even more atypical” to do so, according to Ms. Wagner.

0
Comments

What do you think?

View comments

Recommended for you

Featured video

INTV

Stephanie Bogan: How financial advisers can achieve more by reframing their realities

By revaluating the choices they make and the outcomes that result from them, financial advisers can make sure they're properly serving those most important to them — their clients, according to Stephanie Bogan, founder of Educe Inc.

Latest news & opinion

Morgan Stanley says recruiting and attrition have slowed down

If wirehouses can successfully reduce their reliance on signing bonuses to recruit brokers, they could increase profits.

Managed accounts look attractive to 401(k) advisers, but how do you measure performance?

The customization that makes them a good investment option presents a benchmarking challenge.

National Holdings' acquisition of broker-dealer WFG Investments and its 200 advisers called off

Under an alternative plan, WFG's advisers will be relocated to three broker-dealers, including one owned by National Holdings.

House committees ready two assaults on DOL fiduciary rule this week

One is a vote on a bill to kill Labor's rule and replace it with a disclosure-based best-interest standard, while the second is legislation to prevent funding for enforcement of the regulation.

Can Buckley run the house that Bogle built?

Maintaining a lead in a low-margin business brings unprecedented challenges for Vanguard's new CEO.

X

Subscribe and Save 60%

Premium Access
Print + Digital

Learn more
Subscribe to Print