Retirement Watch

How proposed caps could impact IRA and 401(k) accounts

Both the 2016 and 2017 proposed fiscal budgets included a $3.4 million limit on retirement savings for an individual

Oct 14, 2016 @ 11:00 am

By Jamie Hopkins

For the past few years President Barack Obama's fiscal year budgets have included a variety of proposed changes to the retirement system in the United States. Both the 2016 and 2017 proposed fiscal budgets included a $3.4 million cap on retirement savings for an individual. The cap would be imposed on the aggregate of an individual's retirement accounts, 401(k)s and IRAs.

Really, this proposal would represent minimal tax savings impact for the federal government, and is primarily designed to target wealthier Americans. In fact, the budget proposal even states that the cap would still allow Americans to save for a “reasonable level of consumption in retirement,” implying that savings in excess of $3.4 million might perhaps be considered unreasonable. However, critics of the proposal claim that it impacts very few people, and could, by its very existence, create the impression that the government is putting a damper on retirement savings.

(More: DOL fiduciary rule could cause half of potential IRA rollover assets to stay put: Report)

How many people would this proposed change actually impact? According to a 2014 report published by the Government Accountability Office concerning IRA account holders, there are almost 9,000 Americans who have accumulated more than $5 million in an IRA. However, the proposed cap would be a soft cap, allowing more than $3.4 million in an IRA or 401(k), as long as the amounts that exceed the cap are earnings, not contributions. Another interesting finding in the Government Accountability Office report was the estimate that there are 1,000 Americans with more than $10 million dollars saved in an IRA. While there are questions about the accuracy of the GAO's estimates, we know that these mega million dollar IRAs do exist among the very, very rich. Mitt Romney, for example, reported having an IRA worth between $20 million to $102 million.

(More: Legislation supporting multiple employer plans could become reality by year-end)

The next question is how would the proposed cap actually impact these gargantuan accounts? Well, with contribution limits today at $5,500 per year for an IRA, accumulating a huge amount of money inside of an IRA seems impossible at first glance. Additionally, back in 2002, contribution limits for traditional IRAs were only $3,000 a year, not including the age 50 catch-up contribution. However, SEP IRAs, 401(k) plans and defined benefit plans can be used to accumulate a much more substantial amount of money because the annual contribution limits are far greater. An individual can contribute between $53,000 and $59,000 annually in a 401(k) depending on the type of plan and the age of the individual. Additionally, if an employee maxes out a defined benefit plan, it could be worth north of $3 million.

In fact, the $3.4 million cap was established by calculating the lump-sum amount that would be needed to secure a 100% joint and survivor annuity of $210,000 per year starting at age 62, which is the maximum benefit one can accrue at age 62 in a defined benefit plan today. So, while someone is unlikely to contribute enough money to an IRA to ever reach the cap, an individual could reach the cap in a 401(k) plan or defined benefit plan.

(More: Outsourced 401(k) fiduciary services emerge after DOL rule)

However, even in most 401(k) plans or defined benefit plans, it is unlikely that an individual would have more than $3.4 million dollars of contributions, even for someone with more than $10 million in an IRA. Really, to reach $10 to $100 million in qualified plan assets you would most likely need some employer stock in the 401(k) plan and have that stock experience tremendous growth. A balanced investment approach is unlikely to get you there. In that situation, it is more likely that most of the money is a result of growth and investment earnings. So even for individuals with multi-million dollar IRAs and 401(k) balances, the proposed cap would simply limit their ability to contribute more money to an IRA or 401(k), but would do little at that point to limit their ability to receive the tax-deferred growth benefits offered in the retirement account.

Jamie Hopkins is a professor of tax at the American College's Retirement Income Certified -Professional program. Follow him on Twitter @jamiehopkins521.


What do you think?

View comments

Recommended for you

Upcoming Event

Nov 13


Best Practices Workshop

For the sixth year, InvestmentNews will host the Best Practices Workshop & Awards, bringing together the industry’s top-performing and most influential firms in one room for a full-day. This exclusive workshop and awards program for the... Learn more

Featured video


What's behind the TCA, ETrade deal?

Deputy editor Bob Hordt talks with senior columnist Jeff Benjamin about what each party in the recent acquisition stands to gain by joining forces.

Latest news & opinion

As DOL fiduciary rule dies, variable annuities come alive — sales up for first time since 2014

Indexed annuity sales also broke their previous quarterly sales record.

Cambridge Investment Research bags mid-sized broker-dealer

Broker Dealer Financial Services, an IBD with 150 reps and advisers, and $3.5 billion in assets, will become a Cambridge OSJ.

HighTower on prowl for new CEO, Weissbluth to become chairman

Move is latest in Chicago-based RIA consolidator's effort to expand senior leadership team.

What's in a name? For TCA by ETrade, everything

Trust Company of America is gone, and there's big buzz over the name change. But turning the custodian into an industry powerhouse will take a lot longer — if it happens at all.

When it comes to regulating AI in financial services, murky waters are ahead

Laws are unclear on how the technology fits in with compliance.


Hi! Glad you're here and we hope you like all the great work we do here at InvestmentNews. But what we do is expensive and is funded in part by our sponsors. So won't you show our sponsors a little love by whitelisting It'll help us continue to serve you.

Yes, show me how to whitelist

Ad blocker detected. Please whitelist us or give premium a try.


Subscribe and Save 60%

Premium Access
Print + Digital

Learn more
Subscribe to Print