Smart-beta returns track their Morningstar categories

A few are just a bit smarter than the average

Jan 5, 2017 @ 12:59 pm

By John Waggoner

Your fund may have the smartest beta around, but your returns are still ultimately going to stem from the fund's primary investment playground.

Smart beta funds are index funds that use a set of rules to modify performance, preferably for the better. A basic smart-beta fund might be a large-company ETF that invests in stocks with a long history of rising dividends. A more complex one might specify additional buying rules, such as buying only those stocks whose dividend is greater than the Standard & Poor's 500 stock index, or whose price-to-earnings ratio is below the S&P 500.

Despite the many new entrants into the field with sophisticated buy and sell rules, the top performers in smart beta mirrored the top performers in traditional open-ended funds. For example, the top-performing diversified U.S. smart-beta ETF in 2016 was ProShares Russell 2000 Dividend Growers (SMDV), which invests in small-company stocks with a history of increasing dividends. The fund's components are equally weighted, and no single sector is allowed to have more than a 30% weighting. The fund gained 35.6% last year, according to Morningstar, the Chicago investment trackers.

Morningstar categorizes ProShares Russell 2000 Dividend Growers as a small-company value fund. The category was this year's leader among open-end funds, gaining an average 25.68%. iShares Russell 2000 Value fund (IWN), an index fund, gained 31.64%.

Similarly, the worst-performing smart beta ETFs were in Morningstar's large- or mid-cap growth categories. The laggard of the U.S. smart-beta group was PowerShares DWA Tactical Sector Rotation (DWTR). The equal-weighted fund of funds uses a momentum strategy to invest in top-performing sectors. It fell 2.85% in 2016.

Morningstar categorizes the fund as a mid-cap growth fund. The group, like all growth categories, lagged value funds last year. Open-ended midcap growth funds gained 5.92% last year, vs. 17.91% for mid-cap value funds.

International smart-beta funds followed the same pattern, but a few funds stood out. The top-performing diversified international smart-beta fund was PowerShares FTSE RAFI Emerging markets ETF (PXH), which soared 32.43% in 2016, vs. 8.47% for diversified emerging markets funds.

The fund invests in emerging markets stocks that have the highest fundamental value score, as determined by Research Affiliates. It's not infallible: The fund tumbled 22.83% in 2015, vs. 13.79% for the average diversified emerging markets fund.

Smart-beta funds that hedged their currency exposure also looked smart last year. WisdomTree United Kingdom Hedged Equity ETF (DXPS) soared 21.08% last year, despite the Brexit vote and a nearly 50% plunge in the British pound. In contrast, First Trust United Kingom AlphaDEX ETF (FKU), which uses a number of factors in its smart-beta pudding, fell 16.07% last year.

Whether or not smart-beta funds provide a meaningful advantage to investors, the fund industry is likely to keep pumping them out this year.

“We expect 2017 will be a year when more advisers seek out multi-factor ETFs that feel more like active management than (iShares S&P 500 Index) IVV and its market-cap weighted peers, but are cheaper than the 1.1% for a large-cap mutual fund,” wrote Todd Rosenbluth, director of ETF and mutual fund research for CFRA.

But finding a winner is much more difficult than just picking last year's leader. “If they do,” Mr. Rosenbluth notes, “we hope they finish their homework and look inside the portfolios first.”

0
Comments

What do you think?

View comments

Recommended for you

Upcoming Event

Oct 09

Conference

Diversity & Inclusion Awards

Attend the industry’s first event celebrating diversity and inclusion as well as recognizing those who are leading the financial services profession in this important endeavor. Join InvestmentNews, as we strive to raise awareness, educate... Learn more

Featured video

INTV

The bizarro world of DOL and SEC rule supporters

Managing editor Christina Nelson talks with senior reporter Mark Schoeff Jr. about why groups that supported the Labor Department's fiduciary rule oppose much of the SEC advice package, and vice versa.

Latest news & opinion

10 most affordable U.S. cities for renters

Here are the U.S. cities that are most affordable for renters, according to Business Student.com, which compared the cost of rent to average salaries.

9 best - new - financial adviser jokes

Scroll through for nine new financial adviser laughs.

Captrust, prominent 401(k) advice firm, ramps up its wealth management business

Captrust wants to grow annual revenue from wealth management to 50% from 30% over the next five years.

Fidelity CEO says zero-fee funds aimed at expanding its universe

Johnson says way to prosper in financial services is 'by building relationships.'

SEC advice rule contains a huge hole

Jay Clayton aims to clear up investor confusion by drawing a distinction between brokers and advisers in the agency's proposed package of revised standards. But where do dual registrants fit?

X

Hi! Glad you're here and we hope you like all the great work we do here at InvestmentNews. But what we do is expensive and is funded in part by our sponsors. So won't you show our sponsors a little love by whitelisting investmentnews.com? It'll help us continue to serve you.

Yes, show me how to whitelist investmentnews.com

Ad blocker detected. Please whitelist us or give premium a try.

X

Subscribe and Save 60%

Premium Access
Print + Digital

Learn more
Subscribe to Print