Why Robert Shiller is so suspicious of the Trump rally

The Nobel Prize-winning economist notes that stocks are almost as expensive now as they were on the eve of the 1929 crash

Mar 14, 2017 @ 1:11 pm

By Bloomberg News

The last time Robert Shiller heard stock-market investors talk like this in 2000, it didn't end well for the bulls.

Back then, the Nobel Prize-winning economist says, traders were captivated by a "new era story" of technological transformation: The internet had re-defined American business and made traditional gauges of equity-market value obsolete. Today, the game changer everyone's buzzing about is political: Donald J. Trump and his bold plans to slash regulations, cut taxes and turbocharge economic growth with a trillion-dollar infrastructure boom.

"They're both revolutionary eras," says Mr. Shiller, who's famous for his warnings about the dot-com mania and housing-market excesses that led to the global financial crisis. "This time a 'Great Leader' has appeared. The idea is, everything is different."

For Mr. Shiller, the power of a new-era narrative helps answer one of the most hotly debated questions on Wall Street as stocks set one high after another this year: Why are traders so fixated on the upsides of a Trump presidency when the downside risks seem just as big? For all his pro-business promises, the former reality TV star's confrontational foreign policy and haphazard management style have bred uncertainty — the one thing investors are supposed to hate most.

Charts illustrating the conundrum have been making the rounds on trading floors. One, called "the most worrying chart we know" by Societe Generale SA at the end of last year, shows a surging index of global economic policy uncertainty severing its historical link with credit spreads, which have declined in recent months along with other measures of investor fear. The VIX index, a popular gauge of anxiety in the U.S. stock market, has dropped more than 30% since Mr. Trump's election.

"I don't generally call the entire market wrong — investors are very smart, highly motivated individuals — but I find it hard to say why stock markets are so un-volatile right now,'' says Nicholas Bloom, a Stanford University economist who co-designed the uncertainty gauge with colleagues from the University of Chicago and Northwestern University.

The simplest explanation may be that share prices have less to do with Mr. Trump than with tangible improvements in the economy and corporate earnings. With the U.S. unemployment rate well below 5% and S&P 500 Index profits projected to reach all-time highs this year, perhaps it shouldn't be surprising that equities are doing so well.

But there's more to the market's resilience than just numbers, according to Ethan Harris, Bank of America Merrill Lynch's global economist in New York. Like the fable of the boy who cried wolf, Mr. Harris says pessimistic forecasters have so badly over-estimated the consequences of big events — the rolling European debt crisis since 2010, the U.S. debt-ceiling standoff in 2011, Brexit in 2016 — that traders have become conditioned to ignore them. Even when bears are right, the past eight years have shown that central banks are more than willing to save the day when markets fall.

"It's been a period of repeated shocks, and I think people get toughened against that," Mr. Harris says. "It seems like uncertainty is the new norm, so you just learn to live with it."

For Hersh Shefrin, a finance professor at Santa Clara University and author of a 2007 book on the role of psychology in markets, the rally is just another example of investors' remarkable penchant for tunnel vision. Mr. Shefrin has a favorite analogy to illustrate his point: the great tulip-mania of 17th century Holland.

Even the most casual students of financial history are familiar with the frenzy, during which a rare tulip bulb was worth enough money to buy a mansion. What often gets overlooked, though, is that the mania happened during an outbreak of bubonic plague.

"People were dying left and right," Mr. Shefrin says. "So here you have financial markets sending signals completely at odds with the social mood of the time, with the degree of fear at the time."

Mr. Shiller says when markets are as buoyant as they are now, resisting the urge to pile in is hard regardless of what else might be happening in society.

"I was tempted to do it, too," he says. "[Mr.] Trump keeps talking about a new spirit for America and so you could (A) believe that or (B) you could believe that other investors believe that."

On whether stocks are nearing a top, Mr. Shiller can't say with any certainty. He's loathe to make short-term forecasts.

Despite the well-timed publication of his book "Irrational Exuberance" just as the dot-com bubble peaked in early 2000, the Yale University economist had warned (with caveats) that shares might be overvalued as early as 1996. Investors who bought and held an S&P 500 fund in the middle of that year made about 8% annually over the next decade, while those who invested at the start of 2000 lost money. The S&P 500 sank 49% from its high in March 2000 through a bottom in October 2002. The index has gained 6% this year.

What Mr. Shiller will say now is that he's refrained from adding to his own U.S. stock positions, emphasizing overseas markets instead. One factor that makes him cautious on American shares is the S&P 500's cyclically-adjusted price-earnings ratio: While the metric is still about 30% below its high in 2000, it shows stocks are almost as expensive now as they were on the eve of the 1929 crash.

"The market is way over-priced,'' he says. "It's not as intellectual as people would think, or as economists would have you believe.''

0
Comments

What do you think?

View comments

Recommended for you

Upcoming Event

Apr 30

Conference

Retirement Income Summit

Join InvestmentNews at the 12th annual Retirement Income Summit - the industry's premier retirement planning conference.Much has changed - and much remains to be learned. Attend and discuss how the future is full of opportunity for ... Learn more

Featured video

Events

What's next at CAIS?

With a strong 2017 behind them, CAIS doesn't want to lose sight of its clients as it embarks on 2018. Matt Brown explains how a new adviser council will help the firm grow in the year ahead.

Video Spotlight

Help Clients Be Prepared, Not Surprised

Sponsored by Prudential

Recommended Video

Path to growth

Latest news & opinion

Broker, retirement groups make last-minute pleas to change tax legislation

Pass-through provisions are target of groups representing employee-model brokerage firms, as well as retirement plan advisers.

House and Senate reach tentative compromise for tax overhaul

Lawmakers still need to get a cost analysis of their agreement, so it's not yet definite, according to a source.

Advisers' biggest fears for 2018

What keeps advisers up at night.

One adviser's story of losing his son to the opioid epidemic

John W. Brower, president and CEO of JW Brower & Associates, shares the story behind his son's death from a heroin overdose and how it inspired him to help others break the cycle of addiction.

Tax reform will boost food, chemicals, rail stocks. Technology? Not so much

Conagra and Berkshire Hathaway are two stocks that should benefit most from changes in the tax code.

X

Subscribe and Save 60%

Premium Access
Print + Digital

Learn more
Subscribe to Print