BlackRock's two-tier ETF pricing system is working

The company remains the top seller of U.S. ETFs while fending off Vanguard and shielding much of its business from the punishing effects of price competition

Apr 26, 2017 @ 11:18 am

By Bloomberg News

BlackRock Inc. signaled its willingness to engage in a price war last October by cutting fees on 15 exchange-traded funds, going head-to-head with faster-growing ETF rivals Vanguard Group and Charles Schwab Corp. in the fight for investors flocking to passive products.

"A new era is dawning for advisers and long-term investors," Mark Wiedman, global head of iShares, BlackRock's $1.4 trillion ETF unit, said at the time.

What he didn't mention was that prices weren't changing on most of BlackRock's ETF assets — where fees remain far higher for institutional buyers who crave easy-to-trade securities. The discounts are aimed at retail customers and financial advisers who mostly seek cheap funds.

BlackRock is basing its pricing on the idea that not all ETF buyers are the same, and the strategy seems to be working. BlackRock attracted a record $64.5 billion into its iShares products during the first quarter, with money going into both types of ETFs.

The company has been able to remain the top seller of U.S. ETFs while fending off Vanguard and shielding much of its business from the punishing effects of price competition.

"By skill or luck, they have pulled it off," said Dave Nadig, chief executive officer of San Francisco-based research firm "If you are BlackRock you have to be happy."


Still, BlackRock isn't immune to price pressures. Over the past year, its revenue grew more slowly than its assets, reflecting the squeeze on fees across the fund industry.

IShares is the largest force in the expanding market for ETFs, which generally track indexes while trading all day like stocks. U.S.-listed ETFs have attracted $154 billion in cash this year, with BlackRock hauling in the most, followed by Vanguard, the second-biggest provider by assets.

"Investors continue to gravitate to low-cost funds and ETFs," said Freddy Martino, a spokesman for Vanguard. "At Vanguard, they can be assured of complex-wide low costs all the time."

Five years ago, BlackRock was losing market share to Vanguard, whose focus on cost-conscious advisers building efficient portfolios paid off as the indexing wave took hold. Vanguard was the top ETF seller in 2010 and 2011.

BlackRock's response then was to introduce the core funds in 2012 with lower fees than its traditional funds. For example, the iShares MSCI EAFE ETF, which tracks stocks in Europe and Asia, carries an expense ratio of 33 cents for every $100 invested, while the iShares Core MSCI EAFE ETF charges 8 cents. Across the lineup, the core ETFs charge an average of 10 cents, compared with 38 cents for the older funds, according to data compiled by Bloomberg.

The core ETFs have about $300 billion in U.S. assets and are growing at a quicker clip than the non-core funds. Importantly for BlackRock, the success of the core ETFs hasn't killed the higher-priced business, whose roughly $800 in billion in assets remain the key driver of iShares revenue. In the first quarter of 2017, BlackRock's traditional U.S. ETFs attracted $24.3 billion compared with $28.8 billion for the core ETFs, according to data compiled by Bloomberg.


Institutions such as hedge funds have stuck with the pricier ETFs because they treat the products as trading vehicles. They may be betting on market direction, as many did after the election of Donald J. Trump in November, or hedging a specific position. Often those buyers hold ETFs briefly, so they don't incur the full cost of the annual expense.

Many of the more expensive ETFs also have options attached to them that create more ways to trade.

"We don't believe that BlackRock is cannibalizing itself to any meaningful extent," JPMorgan Chase & Co. analyst Kenneth Worthington said in a research note last month.

BlackRock CEO Laurence D. Fink agrees.

"If we did not do those price cuts last year we would not have had those flows," Mr. Fink said in an April 19 interview.


A comparison of BlackRock's main ETFs for emerging-market stocks shows how different two seemingly similar products can be. The iShares MSCI Emerging Markets ETF has five times the trading volume and 100 times the options activity of the iShares Core MSCI Emerging Markets ETF, though expenses are five times higher, according to BlackRock data.

Not everyone is a fan of the two-tiered pricing.

Robo adviser Wealthfront Inc. seeks partners "wholeheartedly committed to lowering investors' costs," CEO Andy Rachleff said in a recent blog post titled "Why We Avoid BlackRock ETFs."

Mr. Rachleff, whose clients hold about $6 billion in ETFs and other products, said that if BlackRock cut its fees to match Vanguard's across the board, it would cost the firm more than $500 million in profits. "BlackRock designed this ruse to maintain their profitability," he wrote of the pricing policy.

Martin Small, head of U.S. iShares at BlackRock, said the company segments its business to cater to different clients and works with a range of customers to choose the ETFs "that best fit their investment objectives. That is good for our clients and our shareholders."


What do you think?

View comments

Recommended for you

Upcoming Event

Apr 30


Retirement Income Summit

Join InvestmentNews at the 12th annual Retirement Income Summit - the industry's premier retirement planning conference.Much has changed - and much remains to be learned. Attend and discuss how the future is full of opportunity for ... Learn more

Featured video


What's next for adviser consolidation?

After a strong start to M&A activity in 2017, the year stalled in the third quarter. What's ahead? M&A Expert David Devoe explains.

Video Spotlight

Help Clients Be Prepared, Not Surprised

Sponsored by Prudential

Recommended Video

Path to growth

Latest news & opinion

One adviser's story of losing his son to the opioid epidemic

John W. Brower, president and CEO of JW Brower & Associates, shares the story behind his son's death from a heroin overdose and how it inspired him to help others break the cycle of addiction.

Tax reform will boost food, chemicals, rail stocks. Technology? Not so much

Conagra and Berkshire Hathaway are two stocks that should benefit most from changes in the tax code.

Brace for steepest rate hikes since 2006 in new year

Citigroup, JPMorgan Chase predict average interest rates across advanced economies will climb to at least 1 percent in 2018.

Why private equity wants a piece of the RIA market

Several factors, including consolidation in the independent advice industry and PE's own growing mountain of cash, are fueling the zeal to invest.

Finra bars former UBS rep for private securities transactions

Regulator says Kenneth Tyrrell engaged in undisclosed trades worth $13 million.


Subscribe and Save 60%

Premium Access
Print + Digital

Learn more
Subscribe to Print