DOL fiduciary rule driving fundamental shift in variable annuity market

A dramatic shift in the market share of IRA-sold versus non-qualified variable annuities is starting to play out

Aug 24, 2017 @ 1:45 pm

By Greg Iacurci

The Department of Labor's fiduciary rule is shaking things up in the variable annuity market.

While the regulation has accelerated the downward trend in overall variable annuity sales for the past several quarters, only recently has the rule's impact extended to the market share of different VA products.

The fiduciary rule, which raises investment-advice standards in retirement accounts, affects investment products sold in qualified accounts, such as individual retirement accounts, rather than non-qualified accounts.

Just over 60% of VAs were sold into the qualified market somewhat consistently since the fiduciary rule was finalized in April 2016. That figure started to decline in the most recent quarter for the first time.

According to data from Limra, an insurance industry group, the share of variable annuities sold into IRA contracts dipped to 58% in the second quarter, a decline of five percentage points year-over-year.

"We saw some significant drops in the IRA business in 2016. But this is the first time we've really seen the market share start to move," Todd Giesing, the director of annuity research at the Limra Secure Retirement Institute, said.

There's been a "steady decline" in VA sales, among both qualified and non-qualified products, since April 2015, when the fiduciary rule was first proposed, Mr. Giesing said. This year, though, IRA business is down while non-qualified business is up. Non-qualified VA sales were up 5% in the second quarter, according to Limra.

"This is likely a fiduciary impact," Mr. Giesing said. "The target with the fiduciary rule is on the IRA market."

The fiduciary rule's first phase of implementation started June 9. The second and final phase is set to begin Jan. 1, but the Trump administration is seeking an 18-month delay.

Industry observers expected this sort of dynamic to play out, but its real-world impact is now becoming apparent.

Variable annuities in IRAs have historically been sold on commission, a type of compensation arrangement that requires broker-dealers and other distributors to jump through more regulatory hoops and take on greater legal risk under the fiduciary rule. As a result, distributors have shied away from commission sales.

"In my opinion, I would expect there would be continued pressures on IRA variable annuity sales moving forward," Mr. Giesing said.

Insurers have tried to pivot by developing fee-based, or "advisory," annuities that come with many of the same features available on commission IRA products. These types of products carry a lesser regulatory burden than commission products. But these products only represent roughly 2% of the total VA market.

Total VA sales were $24.7 billion in the second quarter, down 8% year-over-year, according to Limra. It was the 14th consecutive quarter of year-over-year declines, with the wirehouse and bank distribution channels seeing the biggest drops in Q2, with sales in each down roughly 20%.

Limra estimates sales will drop 10%-15% in 2017 to less than $100 billion, the lowest level since 1998.


What do you think?

View comments

Recommended for you

Featured video


When can advisers expect an SEC fiduciary rule proposal and other regs this year?

Managing editor Christina Nelson and senior reporter Mark Schoeff Jr. discuss regulations of consequence to financial advisers in 2018, and their likely timing.

Recommended Video

Path to growth

Latest news & opinion

Fidelity charging new fee on Vanguard assets held in 401(k) plans

The 0.05% fee is ostensibly a response to Vanguard's distribution model, but may also make the company's funds less attractive due to higher cost.

UBS adviser count continues to decline

Firm to merge U.S., global wealth management units on Feb. 1

TD Ameritrade launches all-night trading for ETFs

Twelve funds now can be traded after-hours, but the list will grow, company says.

Cutting through the red tape of adviser regulation is tricky

Don't expect a simple rollback of rules under the Trump administration in 2018 — instead, regulators are on pace to bolster financial adviser oversight.

Bond investors have more to worry about than a government shutdown

Inflation worries, international rates pushing Treasuries yields higher.


Hi! Glad you're here and we hope you like all the great work we do here at InvestmentNews. But what we do is expensive and is funded in part by our sponsors. So won't you show our sponsors a little love by whitelisting It'll help us continue to serve you.

Yes, show me how to whitelist

Ad blocker detected. Please whitelist us or give premium a try.


Subscribe and Save 60%

Premium Access
Print + Digital

Learn more
Subscribe to Print