In the ETF world, spoils still go to the biggest and cheapest

New entrants dominate Morningstar ETF conference

Sep 6, 2017 @ 4:41 pm

By John Waggoner

The ETF industry has grown largely due to passively managed, low-cost investments. Over time, these funds have an indisputable edge over their actively managed rivals.

"Actively managed funds have underperformed versus passively managed funds, especially over longer time periods, and experienced higher mortality rates," Ben Johnson, director of global ETF research at Morningstar, said at the Morningstar ETF conference that kicked off in Chicago Wednesday.

At the event, 712 participants and dozens of exhibitors are mulling the future of a rapidly maturing $3 trillion industry.

Actively managed funds have watched a net $183.5 billion flee in the past 12 months, according to Morningstar estimates, while $671.1 billion has flooded passively managed funds. None of this has been lost on investors or financial advisers.

The battle for the low-cost dollar has largely gone to the behemoths of the industry. Vanguard alone accounted for $337.6 billion in net flows the past 12 months, while iShares gobbled up another $191.5 billion. Few other fund companies have the economies of scale to offer funds with such low annual expenses — typically less than 10 basis points a year. For any small fund company, the barrier to entry in the low-cost contest is insurmountable.

The result has been an explosive growth in smart beta funds. There are 650 strategic beta exchange-traded products in the U.S. now, with assets of $621.9 billion in assets, Morningstar says. That's a third of all exchange-traded products; 40% of all new exchange-traded products launched in the past three years have been strategic beta products. (Morningstar prefers "strategic beta" to "smart beta," which it sees as a marketing term. "Not all strategic beta funds are smart," Mr. Johnson said.)

Strategic beta funds tend to attract the most money if they have a large, well-known sponsor and a decent track record against their peers. The largest asset-gatherers in the past 12 months have been those with basic value tilts, such as Vanguard Value ETF (VTV), which saw an estimated $3.8 billion in net new flows this year.

The question: Do they perform as advertised? Funds that claim to reduce risk haven't really been tested. A 5,000-point drop in the Dow would be an ideal testing ground, albeit a painful one. In what downturns have occurred recently, the results have been mixed at best. For funds that use some other weighting than market capitalization, the best returns have been from large-cap blend, value and growth, as well as small-cap blend. Equal-weighted funds, particularly large-cap, also fared well.

Mr. Johnson noted, however, that, "As we go back in time, the sample gets very small." Just 13 large-cap value strategic beta funds have 10-year records. Those with good records versus their cap-weighted brethren tended to lean towards cheaper and smaller stocks.

The most successful recent additions to the strategic beta universe, however, have combined active strategies with big sales forces. Goldman Sachs ActiveBeta US Large cap Equity ETF (GSLC), for example, has grown to $2.4 billion since its 2015 inception. The fund's expense ratio is nine basis points. "It's a case example of the fact that investors aren't waiting three years to buy new products," said Todd Rosenbluth, senior director of ETF and mutual fund research at CFRA. "You can leverage your brand and tap into the relationships you have."

Nevertheless, the assets are still flowing to the largest, cheapest ETFs. "Cheap, market-cap weighted ETFs are still still reigning in a crowded, non-market-cap weighted world," Mr. Rosenbluth said.


What do you think?

View comments

Recommended for you

Sponsored financial news

Upcoming Event

Apr 30


Retirement Income Summit

Join InvestmentNews at the 12th annual Retirement Income Summit - the industry's premier retirement planning conference.Much has changed - and much remains to be learned. Attend and discuss how the future is full of opportunity for ... Learn more

Featured video


Advisers beware: tax law has unintended consequences

Commission accounts could be preferable for some clients, and advisers could be incentivized to move from employee broker-dealers to independent channels.

Recommended Video

Path to growth

Latest news & opinion

Pass-through provision in new tax law could benefit REITs, MLPs

Investors in such instruments are eligible for a 20% tax deduction as a result of the pass-through provision.

UBS adviser count continues to decline

Firm to merge U.S., global wealth management units on Feb. 1

TD Ameritrade launches all-night trading for ETFs

Twelve funds now can be traded after-hours, but the list will grow, company says.

Cutting through the red tape of adviser regulation is tricky

Don't expect a simple rollback of rules under the Trump administration in 2018 — instead, regulators are on pace to bolster financial adviser oversight.

Bond investors have more to worry about than a government shutdown

Inflation worries, international rates pushing Treasuries yields higher.


Hi! Glad you're here and we hope you like all the great work we do here at InvestmentNews. But what we do is expensive and is funded in part by our sponsors. So won't you show our sponsors a little love by whitelisting It'll help us continue to serve you.

Yes, show me how to whitelist

Ad blocker detected. Please whitelist us or give premium a try.


Subscribe and Save 60%

Premium Access
Print + Digital

Learn more
Subscribe to Print