InvestmentNews INsider

The INsiderblog

InvestmentNews reporters offer their take on intriguing or controversial articles from around the web.

DOL fiduciary rule has enforcement gaps — and they could widen

Parts of the rule not subject to a contract requirement don't offer investors an avenue to recover losses if they receive bad advice

Sep 11, 2017 @ 2:42 pm

By Greg Iacurci

The Department of Labor's fiduciary rule, as it's currently written, has some enforcement gaps. And they could widen, especially for annuity products, depending on how the Trump administration's review of the rule shakes out.

The primary enforcement mechanism of the Obama-era regulation, which raises investment advice standards in retirement accounts, is a "best-interest contract" between an investor and financial institution such as a broker-dealer.

Beginning in January, firms that wish to use certain compensation arrangements, like commissions, must enter into a contract with an IRA investor affirming the broker's fiduciary relationship to the investor and that the investor is receiving advice that's in his/her best interest. The investor, in turn, will have a way to bring suit against the institution for breach of contract.

But, what if there's no contract? As it turns out, nothing would really change for IRA investors seeking to recover losses stemming from poor investment advice.

This is the current state of affairs. In June, the rule significantly expanded who is considered a fiduciary adviser. Because the rule's contract requirement doesn't kick in until January, there's currently no way to enforce this newly-minted fiduciary status. The DOL last month proposed a delay to the contract provision until July 2019.

So, for the next two years it is likely to be business as usual.

When the rule does fully go into effect, one thing is clear: Enforcement would still be nonexistent in a few areas. According to Micah Hauptman, financial services counsel at the Consumer Federation of America, those situations would be:

• When a broker or insurance agent recommends a fixed-rate annuity using money already in an IRA (not via a rollover);

• When a level-fee adviser recommends moving money that was already in an IRA to the adviser.

The fiduciary rule doesn't require a contract for these transactions. For example, brokers can recommend fixed-rate annuities using what's known as Prohibited Transaction Exemption 84-24, which doesn't come with a contract requirement.

The Insured Retirement Institute and other insurance industry advocates have been lobbying for all annuities, including variable and indexed annuities, to be sold under PTE 84-24. This could come to fruition depending on the outcome of a review of the rule being conducted by the Trump administration's DOL. If it does, investors would be limited to the enforcement mechanisms already in place.

For variable annuities, which are regulated as securities products, the avenue of relief would be via Finra arbitration for a violation of the "suitability" standard of conduct, a standard that's less stringent than the fiduciary standard.

The remedy is different for fixed and indexed annuities, which are regulated as insurance, not securities, products. There is no private enforcement mechanism for insurance agents.

A displeased purchaser has a few options, according to Sheryl Moore, president and CEO of Moore Market Intelligence, a market research firm:

• Most states have a 30-day free-look period, during which they can return the annuity for the premiums they paid.

• Thereafter, they still have the option of writing a formal complaint to the insurance company. The insurance company's response to such a complaint is dependent upon their findings and philosophy.

• The annuity purchaser also has the option of contacting their insurance commissioner to look into the matter. The insurance division's response will also depend upon their findings.

Though observers say it's unlikely, the Trump administration could ultimately remove the contract requirement altogether, and leave a rule that's essentially all bark and no bite.

Some proponents of the fiduciary rule believe that, absent a contract, retirement investors could benefit from the rule's expanded pool of "fiduciary" advisers in Finra arbitration proceedings. Mr. Hauptman says he believes that's an "open legal question," though.

"Just because there would be expanded circumstances in which a broker meets the definition doesn't necessarily mean that there is an explicit cause of action the investor could bring for violation of that standard," he said.

But, observers think the outlook is even hazier for insurance products. Even Phyllis Borzi, former assistant labor secretary during the Obama administration and a chief architect of the fiduciary rule, expressed a degree of skepticism.

She believes the expanded fiduciary definition would help investors in arbitration, but "there's an open question as to what the effect might be" on non-securities products not subject to Finra arbitration for disputes.

0
Comments

What do you think?

View comments

Recommended for you

Upcoming Event

May 02

Conference

Women Adviser Summit

The InvestmentNews Women Adviser Summit, a one-day workshop now held in four cities due to popular demand, is uniquely designed for the sophisticated female adviser who wants to take her personal and professional self to the next level.... Learn more

Featured video

Events

The power of data

Your clients have financial news and data at their fingertips, but donít know how to interpret it. Katy Gibson of Envestnet|Yodlee and Blake Kannady of Envestnet discuss the power of leveraging aggregated data.

Recommended Video

Path to growth

Latest news & opinion

Tax reform: 7 essential strategies for financial advisers

While advisers face the difficult task of analyzing the law's impact, they will also have a significant opportunity to prove their value by implementing money-saving strategies for clients as well as their own businesses.

Bill requiring fiduciary disclosure reintroduced in New Jersey

Measures would obligate financial advisers to tell clients they do not have to act in their best interests.

Merrill Lynch to let advisers text with clients

Texting has been a popular mode of communication for years, but in the past the firm's regulations have prevented advisers from using it.

Bear market for bonds has arrived, Gross says

10-year Treasury rate's move above 2.5% confirms outlook for fixed income, legendary bond manager says.

Mary Beth Franklin's advice for optimizing Social Security claiming strategies

InvestmentNews' retirement guru Mary Beth Franklin offers strategies you can put into place that may significantly increase your clients' Social Security draw.

X

Hi! Glad you're here and we hope you like all the great work we do here at InvestmentNews. But what we do is expensive and is funded in part by our sponsors. So won't you show our sponsors a little love by whitelisting investmentnews.com? It'll help us continue to serve you.

Yes, show me how to whitelist investmentnews.com

Ad blocker detected. Please whitelist us or give premium a try.

X

Subscribe and Save 60%

Premium Access
Print + Digital

Learn more
Subscribe to Print