With margins crashing, broker-dealers look to merge: report

Independent B-D deal flow is focused on big transactions, while RIA deals more frequent, Fidelity says

Sep 21, 2017 @ 2:15 pm

By Bruce Kelly

As operating margins of independent broker-dealers have crashed over the last decade, two types of business models have emerged as the industry steadily consolidates: large firms with scale and smaller, more focused firms serving a niche.

That's one of the main conclusions from a new report released today by Fidelity Investments, which drew upon interviews with industry leaders participating in broker-dealer and registered investment adviser mergers and acquisitions.

The past decade has been a long slog for independent broker-dealers, according to the report titled, Fidelity Wealth Management M&A Series: Insights from Independent Broker-Dealers.

The number of IBDs has declined 28%, with 904 open for business in 2015, compared to 1,255 such firms that were up and running in 2005. And with increased regulation pressuring profits, broker-dealer operating margins dropped from 12% in 2006 to just 3% in 2016, according to Fidelity Clearing & Custody Solutions, the business division that completed the research for the report.

(More: Thinking about M&A? Keep these three issues in mind)

At the start of the year, industry executives and consultants said they believed more consolidation was coming. Independent brokers have seen margins compress steadily since the credit crisis, as record-low interest rates ate into their bottom lines. New regulations have hampered the sale of high commission products such as nontraded real estate investment trusts and variable annuities, further increasing the pressure on firm finances.

Large firms, those with 1,000 or more brokers and advisers, have several advantages in the current market, the report said. They can use acquisitions as a complement to recruiting and can lure smaller broker-dealers to drop their registration with the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority Inc. and become a branch, or super OSJ, according to the Fidelity report.

The current emphasis of complying with the Department of Labor's fiduciary rule and maintaining an open platform of products are other advantages that large firms have over smaller players.

Meanwhile, niche firms have several advantages of their own. They can focus on a distinct business plan, offer advisers greater flexibility and independence, and also look for ways to boost adviser productivity to sustain healthy margins, the report said.

This year has so far seen five deals involving independent broker-dealers with $136 billion in assets changing hands, with LPL Financial's acquisition in August of the four firms in the National Planning Holdings network being the largest by far. Advisers with the NPH broker-dealers manage approximately $120 billion.

That compares to $80 billion of assets spread across 82 mergers and acquisitions among RIAs, and tracked by Fidelity so far this year.

(More: Private equity investors zero in on the RIA business)

"There are many emerging multibillion-dollar RIA firms, but they are still far behind the significant scale of the largest independent broker-dealers, which have substantial assets and adviser bases," said Scott Slater, vice president, practice management and consulting, Fidelity Clearing & Custody Solutions, in a statement. "So, while we are seeing fewer IBD deals compared to RIA deals, those that are taking place are significant, both in size and in how they are creating innovative business options and platforms for advisers."

However, independent broker-dealers clearly lag RIAs in one key area: adviser productivity. Indeed, lower productivity of advisers at IBDs compared to other business channels strains firms' profits, according to the report.

The average assets per IBD adviser, excluding those affiliated with insurance company broker-dealers, are $32.9 million, whereas advisers at independent RIAs on average are handling clients with total assets twice that amount, about $66.6 million.


What do you think?

View comments

Recommended for you

RIA Data Center

Use InvestmentNews' RIA Data Center to filter and find key information on over 1,400 fee-only registered investment advisory firms.

Rank RIAs by

B-D Data Center

Use InvestmentNews' B-D Data Center to find exclusive information and intelligence about the independent broker-dealer industry.

Rank Broker-dealers by

Upcoming Event

Apr 30


Retirement Income Summit

Join InvestmentNews at the 12th annual Retirement Income Summit - the industry's premier retirement planning conference.Much has changed - and much remains to be learned. Attend and discuss how the future is full of opportunity for ... Learn more

Featured video


Ric Edelman: 3 factors transforming the financial advisory industry

We are at the "knee in the curve" of a transformation of the financial advice industry, according to Ric Edelman. But what's next and how will it shape your practice of the future?

Video Spotlight

Help Clients Be Prepared, Not Surprised

Sponsored by Prudential

Recommended Video

Path to growth

Latest news & opinion

Tax update: Brady says sales tax deduction in final bill

Taxpayers will be able to deduct state income taxes or state sales taxes in addition to property levies — up to a $10,000 cap.

Critics say regulation hasn't curbed overly rosy projections for indexed universal life insurance

They say rule didn't go far enough and more stringent measures may be necessary.

Broker, retirement groups make last-minute pleas to change tax legislation

Pass-through provisions are target of groups representing employee-model brokerage firms, as well as retirement plan advisers.

House and Senate reach tentative compromise for tax overhaul

Lawmakers still need to get a cost analysis of their agreement, so it's not yet definite, according to a source.

Advisers' biggest fears for 2018

What keeps advisers up at night.


Subscribe and Save 60%

Premium Access
Print + Digital

Learn more
Subscribe to Print