Vanguard rolls out actively managed factor ETFs

The six ETFs and one mutual fund, which will focus on volatility, value, momentum, liquidity and quality, mark a departure from the money manager's storied promotion of passive index funds

Nov 28, 2017 @ 2:02 pm

By John Waggoner

Vanguard announced Tuesday its entry into factor ETFs, a move that's a sharp departure from its index-based exchange-traded funds — and, quite possibly, one designed to appeal to advisers.

Vanguard plans to roll out six new factor ETFs next year, specializing in minimum volatility, value, momentum, liquidity and quality. A sixth ETF will be a multifactor approach. The Valley Forge, Pa., company also will roll out a multifactor open-ended mutual fund.

Factor funds take one or more investment strategies, or factors, into their securities selection. Morningstar Inc. lists 21 factor mutual funds and 60 factor ETFs. Factor ETFs have attracted an estimated $3.1 billion the past 12 months, according to Morningstar.

The move is significant for several reasons.

The first is simply the Vanguard effect: The mutual fund behemoth vacuums up investor assets like an elephant sipping from a baby pool. Investors have poured an estimated $348.6 billion net inflow to Vanguard mutual funds and ETFs the 12 months ended October 31, according to Morningstar, giving the company a 23.6% market share. (Those figures exclude money market funds and fund of funds).

The five single-factor ETFs will have an estimated expense ratio of 0.13%, while the multifactor ETF and mutual fund will weigh in at 0.18%. iShares, the largest factor-fund provider, weighs in at 0.15% to 0.32% for its largest factor ETFs, and archrival Fidelity charges 0.29% for its factor offerings.

Vanguard's entry into the arena should send shivers down its competitors' spines. Its factor funds would be cheaper than iShares' offerings, which are the current leaders.

"The average Vanguard ETF has more than $10 billion in assets, and given their strong brand with advisers and retail investors, we expect these factor products to be successful in gathering assets early," said Todd Rosenbluth, senior director of ETF and mutual fund research at CFRA.

The new Vanguard ETFs are also a sharp departure from Vanguard's long-time promotion of capitalization-weighted index funds, championed by its founder, Jack Bogle. A 2011 Vanguard research paper, for example, "supports market-cap-weighted indexes over these alternative equity benchmarks, both for their theoretical basis and their practicality." A 2015 paper concluded, "By definition, alternatives to market-cap-weighted indexes, such as smart-beta strategies, should be considered active strategies, because their rules-based methodologies tend to generate meaningful security-level deviations, or tracking error, versus a broad market-cap index."

The new ETFs will follow no index, but rather broad guidelines as to how they select stocks, Mr. Rosenbluth said. And unlike other Vanguard ETF offerings, the new ETFs will reveal their holdings daily.

"Investors won't have the full road map, but they will have guidelines," Mr. Rosenbluth said. "They will be able to conduct due diligence based on holdings and costs rather than waiting three years."

Vanguard acknowledges that, like all factor funds, their performance won't track a broad-based index, and that some factors can go out of style for extended periods of time. For that reason, the funds might appeal more to advisers than individual investors. The multifactor ETF and mutual fund, however, seems more targeted at individual investors, said Dan Wiener, editor of the Independent Adviser for Vanguard Investors.

Mr. Wiener was skeptical of how useful the ETFs will be. The company has rolled out factor funds in Europe and Canada, but their assets aren't impressive, at least by Vanguard standards. The Canadian Vanguard Minimum Volatility ETF, for example, was rolled out in June 2016 and has $18 million in assets.

"Smart beta is a marketing gimmick: It's a way for companies to put an indexing sheen on active management," Mr. Wiener said. "All factors go in and out of favor and timing your purchases and sales of one or another factor is a fool's errand."

And, he said, Vanguard's record at multifactor investing is middling at best.

"Vanguard's multifactor product sounds an awful lot like their existing quantitative strategies used on funds like Strategic Equity, Strategic SmallCap Equity and U.S. Value," he said. "Sure, there are differences, but the bottom line is that Vanguard's record on these quant funds is decidedly poor."


What do you think?

View comments

Recommended for you

Upcoming Event

Oct 23


Women Adviser Summit - San Francisco

The InvestmentNews Women Adviser Summit, a one-day workshop now held in four cities due to popular demand, is uniquely designed for the sophisticated female adviser who wants to take her personal and professional self to the next level.... Learn more

Featured video


Retirement: it's no longer about feeding pigeons from a park bench.

Today's retiree's expect so much from retirement than previous generations and advisers are in prime position to help their clients what's important and what's not.

Latest news & opinion

CFA Institute adding crypto, blockchain to curriculum

Subjects will be added to its Level I and II coursework for the first time next year.

Trump tax plan making dividend ETFs hot

Funds that are seeing inflows largely steer clear of sectors like utilities.

Wells Fargo Advisors continues to see a decline in brokers

Company also set aside $114 million over fees for rich clients.

Morningstar to replace funds in its managed portfolios with nine of its own

New sub-advised funds, offered exclusively through financial advisers, are intended to lower costs and provide 'greater flexibility.'

Average client assets top $2 million for first time

Charles Schwab's latest RIA Benchmarking Study reports organic growth is driving increased AUM and revenues.


Hi! Glad you're here and we hope you like all the great work we do here at InvestmentNews. But what we do is expensive and is funded in part by our sponsors. So won't you show our sponsors a little love by whitelisting It'll help us continue to serve you.

Yes, show me how to whitelist

Ad blocker detected. Please whitelist us or give premium a try.


Subscribe and Save 60%

Premium Access
Print + Digital

Learn more
Subscribe to Print