Estate lawyers fear being cut out of will

Aug 8, 2005 @ 12:01 am

By Rick Miller

CHICAGO - In the wake of the Terry Schiavo right-to-die case, Congress has been considering ways to promote living wills to the general public.

But some estate planning lawyers are concerned that proposed legislation would sideline them in the end-of-life planning process.

The Advance Directives Improvement and Education Act of 2005, introduced in the Senate in February and followed by a House version in May, calls for enlisting health-care providers in "disseminating information" and "assisting in the preparation of advance directives," also called living wills. The bills make no mention of the role of lawyers in drafting such documents.

"What troubles me is the assumption that a doctor or a medical environment is the right place for this discussion to happen, because in my experience, it is not," said David A. Rubin, an estate planning lawyer in St. Louis.

"The way they are structuring this is, it is going to automatically steer people into that environment, because that's the way they are going to save money," he added. "They are going to find their way into that Venus' flytrap, and once they are in, they are never going to find their way out."

Mr. Rubin, using the Internet, is urging estate planners to contact politicians and state bar associations against the legislation. Among the act's most troublesome proposals, according to him and others, is that it would make an end-of-life planning consultation with a doctor reimbursable under Medicare.

This creates a financial incentive for people to go doctors instead of going to a lawyer, critics of the legislation say.

"What will happen is that the attorneys will be excluded from the process, and the fact is that it is the attorneys who are going to have to litigate these things, and enforce them and interpret them," said Jeffery J. Drach, an elder-law specialist who runs the Drach Elder Law Center in Wausau, Wis.

"I think this bill is pandering to this Terry Schiavo situation," added Steven Leventhal, an estate planning lawyer in Bend, Ore. "I think it is putting people at risk."

The lawyers are at odds with the Chicago-based American Bar Association, which already has come out in support of the act. In fact, this is the third Congress during which the ABA has supported legislation with similar language, noted Charles Sabatino, director of the ABA's Commission on Law and Aging.

"The ABA has no investment in making [the drafting of living wills] a lawyer's task. Lawyers do this regularly, and it is an important part of estate planning, but lawyers don't have a monopoly on it and shouldn't have," he said.

Since a majority of Americans do not have a living will, there needs to be "unified effort" among the medical profession, social-service providers and lawyers to get the message out, Mr. Sabatino added. "It's not the domain of any one of our professions."

The House and Senate bills, which have bipartisan support, come before Congress with the Schiavo case fresh in the public consciousness. Ms. Schiavo was in a persistent vegetative state for 15 years while her husband and parents battled in the courts over removing her from life support.

Ms. Schiavo, who died in March, focused national attention on the need for living wills, which spell out whether a person wants life-sustaining medical care should they become terminally ill or brain damaged.

In addition to the Medicare provision, the legislation calls for creating a Department of Health and Human Services public education campaign to raise awareness about advanced directives and the establishment of a clearinghouse where consumers can receive state-specific information.

Also, the act would make advanced directives portable from state to state - an aspect that even critics of the legislation support.

The intention is not to endorse one profession over another, said Christine Hanson, a spokeswoman for Sen. Bill Nelson, D-Fla., who has sponsored the Senate version of the bill. A House version was introduced by Rep. Sandy Levin, D-Mich. Both bills have been referred to committees.

"Sen. Nelson has said he thinks it is a decision that should be made with your doctor, with your lawyer, with your family, your clergy," Ms. Hanson said. "It's not a means of cutting out lawyers. The fact of the matter is, not every single American goes to a lawyer, so we are trying to find a common denominator."

Hospitals already are required to ask patients if they want information on living wills when they are admitted, she noted. Mr. Nelson has proposed in a separate bill that people be asked if they want information on living wills when they sign up for a driver's license, as well.

The information clearinghouse being proposed also would be a means for any profession or group to provide information to the public, Ms. Hanson added.

The awareness campaign and clearinghouse are among the aspects that bother Mr. Leventhal, the Oregon lawyer.

The legislation would open up the practice of offering living wills to "any business who wants to sell these documents out of a storefront by people who don't have the training."

"The person, in my opinion, to really explain these is not the doctor, is not the hospital, is not somebody selling a document - Advanced Health Care Directives Inc.- none of those parties will explain these end-of-life decisions the way a competent attorney will do it," Mr. Leventhal said.

Mr. Rubin is concerned that the bill would affect the livelihood of estate-planning lawyers. The need for a living will can prompt people to consult a lawyer and then might lead to discussions about estate planning or preparing other documents such as a will or power of attorney.

"It hurts our livelihood, because really, people should be using the Schiavo situation and these kinds of questions as a way of encouraging everybody to go see a lawyer. And instead what this is doing is, it's going to encourage people to go see a doctor," Mr. Rubin said.


What do you think?

View comments

Upcoming event

Sep 10


Denver Women Adviser Summit

The InvestmentNews Women Adviser Summit, a one-day workshop now held in six cities due to popular demand, is uniquely designed for the sophisticated female adviser who wants to take her personal and professional self to the next level.... Learn more

Most watched


Schwab's Jeff Kleintop: Prep for volatility given China trade uncertainties

China could be considered a developed market in five to seven years , according to Jeff Kleintop, chief global investment strategist, Charles Schwab.


Young advisers envision a radically different business in five years

Fintech and sustainable investing are two factors being watched closely by some of the 2019 class of InvestmentNews' 40 Under 40.

Latest news & opinion

TIAA exits the life insurance business

The move is a big deal for RIAs, experts say, since TIAA was one of only a few insurers to offer fee-only life policies.

Advisers step up efforts to help clients manage student loan debt

As some Democrats campaign to wipe the slate clean, financial planners focus on limiting the amount students borrow.

Funding for Reg BI, other SEC advice reform efforts denied in Waters amendment

House likely to approve measure that effectively kills rule package, but it faces uphill battle in Senate

Wall Street lashes out at Sanders' plan to pay off student debt with a securities trading tax

Financial pros argue that a transaction levy will hurt mom-and-pop investors along with investment houses.

GPB paid B-Ds and reps steep commissions to sell troubled private placements

GPB paid commissions of 9.3%, or $167 million altogether, on the firm's private placements.


Hi! Glad you're here and we hope you like all the great work we do here at InvestmentNews. But what we do is expensive and is funded in part by our sponsors. So won't you show our sponsors a little love by whitelisting It'll help us continue to serve you.

Yes, show me how to whitelist

Ad blocker detected. Please whitelist us or give premium a try.


Subscribe and Save 60%

Premium Access
Print + Digital

Learn more
Subscribe to Print