InvestmentNews INsider

The INsiderblog

InvestmentNews reporters offer their take on intriguing or controversial articles from around the web.

Active management is no panacea for down markets

Study by Harold Evensky finds that belief is more sales pitch than reality

Sep 10, 2013 @ 12:01 am

By Jason Kephart

This fall's market forecast calls for an increase in volatility, which means that financial advisers can expect to hear a lot about how active stock pickers can help cushion against a drawdown.

However, much like the fabled stock picker's market, the message is more sales pitch than reality.

The theory — or marketing pitch — says that active managers can better protect assets when stocks take a nosedive because they can do things such as raise cash, stick to the highest-quality stocks or a combination of both. An index, meanwhile, has to stay fully invested at all times, so it will take investors to the market's bottom.

Unfortunately for active managers, a recent study that looked at the past 20 years of mutual fund returns found the promise of active management in down markets is too good to be true.

“It's a good story, but most managers don't succeed in down markets,” said Harold Evensky, co-author of the study and president of Evensky & Katz LLC.

The study, “Modern Fool's Gold: Alpha in Recessions,” looked at the monthly returns of 1,511 mutual funds from 1990 to 2010 and found that, on average, actively managed stock funds weren't able to add enough alpha to offset their fees during recessions.

“From an investor standpoint, they added no value,” Mr. Evensky said.

The funds' performance during recessions was an improvement over how they behaved when the economy was growing.

During periods of expansion, the average mutual fund cost investors about 1% of performance a year, the study found.

Of course, not all managers fail to add alpha during a downturn. Think of American Funds circa the technology bubble, for example. The vast majority of those that did were unable to repeat the feat during the next downturn.

In fact, just one out of five portfolio managers who outperformed during a past recession was able to do so again, according to the study.

American Funds, the company Mr. Evensky calls the “Rolls Royce” of actively managed equity funds, was one of those that failed to repeat its success during the tech bubble when the financial crisis struck.

Even though the statistics paint a dire picture for active management, Mr. Evensky isn't in the all-passive investments camp.

“The index wins most of the time, but we're agnostic,” he said.

“We look at the people, the process and the performance,” Mr. Evensky said. “If an active manager can pass those screens, there's a good chance of our clients getting some of that fund in the future.”

As Mr. Evensky said, most advisers would benefit from keeping an open mind about actively managed funds.

It is important to let the fund's process, expenses and performance drive the decision making. though, instead of a story that sounds too good to be true.


What do you think?

View comments

Recommended for you

Featured video


Where in the U.S. are RIAs growing the fastest?

InvestmentNews' deputy editor Robert Hordt talks to senior columnist Jeff Benjamin about his report on how registered investment advisers are faring in different regions of the country.

Latest news & opinion

Midwestern magic? RIA assets soared nearly 30% there last year

Theories for what's driving the growth spurt abound, but it surpassed all other regions of the country.

8 apps advisers love for getting stuff done

We reached out to advisers to find out which apps they are using to run their business more efficiently.

10 tax moves to squeeze in before the year ends

Here are some tax moves clients can still make before year-end.

Richard Neal: the new face driving retirement policy in Washington

As he becomes head of the House Ways and Means Committee, Rep. Richard Neal (D-Mass.) is poised to make some big changes.


Hi! Glad you're here and we hope you like all the great work we do here at InvestmentNews. But what we do is expensive and is funded in part by our sponsors. So won't you show our sponsors a little love by whitelisting It'll help us continue to serve you.

Yes, show me how to whitelist

Ad blocker detected. Please whitelist us or give premium a try.


Subscribe and Save 60%

Premium Access
Print + Digital

Learn more
Subscribe to Print