Retirement Watch

Thinking like a retiree is quite different than thinking like an investor

Retirement income planning is now established as a vital component of financial planning

Sep 20, 2015 @ 12:01 am

By Wade Pfau

In mid-September, retirement income luminaries gathered in Indianapolis to celebrate the 10th anniversary of the Retirement Income Industry Association. RIIA's birth in Boston in 2005 represents the time that disparate thoughts began to coalesce about how retirement income planning differs from traditional accumulation-focused retirement planning. After having reached the mountain summit, how do clients make it back down?

The genesis of RIIA was founder Francois Gadenne's realization as an early retiree himself that thinking like a retiree is quite different than thinking like an investor. Dirk Cotton, host of the Retirement Café blog and winner of this year's thought leadership award, provides a great analogy to understand this. Consider a breakfast plate filled with eggs and bacon. For this breakfast, the chicken is involved, but the pig is committed. Simply put, retirement is the time that individuals transition from chickens to pigs and have to start thinking differently.

Early on, RIIA members realized that retirement income meant more than just financial accounts, as a household must deploy its entire balance sheet of assets (which add human and social capital to financial capital) to meet its liabilities (future household expenses and obligations). Solving the retirement income problem means focusing on the client's entire financial picture. This viewpoint did not fit into the existing silos and compartmentalization of the financial services profession, and so RIIA grew as an independent group advocating a more holistic client-centered focus fundamentally tethered to a “view across the silos.”

RIIA conferences always bring together an eclectic group of academics and practitioners for discussion and debate about what belongs in the retirement income toolkit. Perhaps most far-reaching in implications from this conference was Moshe Milevsky's keynote presentation about tontine thinking, which gets at the heart of the retirement income problem. Individuals do not know how long they will live. This is longevity risk. For those seeking to manage this risk on their own, it requires spending conservatively in an effort to make sure funds remain to cover the possibility of living to age 90, or 100, or beyond. It's not a particularly efficient way to go about things.

Tontine thinking proposes a solution to this risk by recognizing that those retirees who die young do not spend as much as those who live long. These differing uncertain spending needs can be pooled in what later discussions identified as the crowdsourcing of retirement, allowing everyone in the pool to spend more when alive, because the short-lived will subsidize the long-lived. It is a straightforward way to manage longevity risk while still maintaining an investment portfolio, without requiring any further contractual guarantees from an insurance company.

Simply, a pool of investors combine forces with a joint investment portfolio, and as time passes the remaining survivors share the proceeds from the investment income and returns. Sharing the investment results among survivors means those who do live are able to get higher returns than the investments alone can offer. Meanwhile, those who died still got to spend more than otherwise, because they could spend more aggressively knowing the subsidies would be there for them if needed.

Several years ago I served as a curriculum director for RIIA, and it really impacted my thinking. I became one of the “cross-silo people” that Elvin Turner identified as showing up in more and more places. Advisers are seeking education and training in this area. For instance, The American College's Retirement Income Certified Professional (RICP) designation has grown exponentially since its introduction in 2013. Now almost 10,000 individuals have completed or are working through the curriculum. RIIA's own Retirement Management Analyst (RMA) designation also continues to develop and evolve into multiple levels of content.

Next May, InvestmentNews will be celebrating its own 10th anniversary for the Retirement Income Summit, designed to help financial advisers work through what Bob Powell identifies as the field's “complexity, confusion, and conflict.” Retirement income planning is now established as a vital component of financial planning.

Wade D. Pfau is a professor of retirement income in the Ph.D. program in financial services and retirement planning at The American College. He is also a principal at McLean Asset Management and inStream Solutions. He maintains the website.


What do you think?

View comments

Recommended for you

Upcoming Event

Jul 09


Boston Women Adviser Summit

The InvestmentNews Women Adviser Summit, a one-day workshop now held in six cities due to popular demand, is uniquely designed for the sophisticated female adviser who wants to take her personal and professional self to the next level.... Learn more

Featured video


The power of commodities in 2019

Historically commodities have outperformed stocks at the end of expansions and in early recessions. So why haven't commodities rebounded? John Love of USCF explains.

Latest news & opinion

Look for more changes at Cetera Financial Group

CEO Robert Moore's resignation signals further adjustments at the IBD network.

10 top scams targeting seniors

Phone calls to a Senate committee hotline show trends in frauds perpetrated against seniors.

Robert Moore, Cetera CEO, stepping down for health reasons

Chairman Ben Brigeman will serve as interim chief executive while a search for a permanent CEO is conducted.

The AMT is no longer a problem for many clients

With income thresholds higher and a lower SALT deduction after tax reform, the AMT will realistically only apply to wealthy Americans with out-of-the-ordinary tax events.

Cetera, other broker-dealers refuse to sign Ohio National contracts

Advisers wonder what the lack of a formal brokerage agreement means from a regulatory standpoint.


Hi! Glad you're here and we hope you like all the great work we do here at InvestmentNews. But what we do is expensive and is funded in part by our sponsors. So won't you show our sponsors a little love by whitelisting It'll help us continue to serve you.

Yes, show me how to whitelist

Ad blocker detected. Please whitelist us or give premium a try.


Subscribe and Save 60%

Premium Access
Print + Digital

Learn more
Subscribe to Print