Massachusetts securities chief William Galvin launches investigation of broker 'kickbacks'

Says states need to take the lead in securities investigations as Trump moves to cut back financial regulation

Aug 15, 2017 @ 2:33 pm

By Mark Schoeff Jr.

Massachusetts' top securities regulator, Commonwealth Secretary William Galvin, launched an investigation Tuesday into charges that brokers were receiving 'kickbacks' for routing sales orders to certain stock exchanges.

The probe was inspired in part by a recent New York Times oped by Jonathan Macey, a Yale law professor, and David Swensen, Yale's chief investment officer, who claimed that brokers seeking payment for order flows — instead of choosing the exchange with the best prices for their clients — are taking money out of their clients' pockets.

"Brokers routinely take kickbacks, euphemistically referred to as 'rebates,' for routing orders to a particular exchange," Mr. Macey and Mr. Swensen wrote in a July 18 piece. "As a result, the brokers produce worse outcomes for their institutional investor clients — and therefore, for individual pension beneficiaries, mutual fund investors and insurance policy holders — and ill-gotten gains for the brokers."

Mr. Galvin said in a statement that his office is "looking into the veracity of these assertions."

In an interview, he added that he is also motivated by what he called the Trump administration's effort to cut back financial regulations.

"As it was in previous administrations when this was the attitude, it's up to the states to take the lead," Mr. Galvin said.

He has sent inquiry letters to Charles Schwab & Co. Inc., Scottrade Inc., TD Ameritrade Inc., Fidelity Brokerage Services, E*Trade Securities, Edward D. Jones & Co. and Morgan Stanley & Co. His office did not release the letters.

"Institutional brokers are responsible for placing millions of dollars of average investors' life savings in their employers' pension plans, as well as in mutual funds and variable annuities," Mr. Galvin said in the statement. "If financial rebates or kickbacks create a conflict that results in less than the best deal for the investors, this practice must stop. It is the obligation of regulators to have reasonable assurance that the customer is not being harmed, and that is the reason I instructed my Securities Division to begin this investigation."

The Securities and Exchange Commission has wrestled with best execution for decades. It's a topic that doesn't lend itself to easy solutions, according to Todd Cipperman, principal at Cipperman Compliance Services, because other factors, such as timing and order size, go into calculating best execution.

"There's more to execution than price," Mr. Cipperman said. "Often, the lowest commission is not what determines the best execution. Just because they're paying [a broker] doesn't mean it's not the lowest price. It's a really complicated issue."

In order to protect themselves, Mr. Cipperman recommends that brokers demonstrate why they choose an exchange.

"Make sure you do some best-execution testing so you can justify why you used a particular trading venue," he said.

0
Comments

What do you think?

View comments

Recommended for you

B-D Data Center

Use InvestmentNews' B-D Data Center to find exclusive information and intelligence about the independent broker-dealer industry.

Rank Broker-dealers by

Featured video

INTV

Why millennial demand for ESG is falling on deaf ears

Editorial director Fred Gabriel and senior columnist Jeff Benjamin say there's a disconnect between the big appetite for environmental, social and governance funds in 401(k) plans and their offering.

Latest news & opinion

ESG options scarce in 401(k) plans

There's growing interest among plan participants, but reluctance to add funds that take into account environmental, social and governance factors persists.

Envestnet acquires MoneyGuide for $500 million

Deal will allow Envestnet to deepen integrations between MoneyGuide and its other wealth management solutions.

Genworth move could signal big shift in distribution of long-term-care insurance

Insurers may turn to direct-to-consumer sales only, bypassing brokers and insurance agents.

Morgan Stanley threatens to pull out of Nevada over state's fiduciary rule

Wirehouse says it would not be able to work there under state's current proposal.

Advisers see college admissions scandal as tip of the iceberg

Parents' conduct is described as 'disgusting' but not surprising given the current state of higher education.

X

Hi! Glad you're here and we hope you like all the great work we do here at InvestmentNews. But what we do is expensive and is funded in part by our sponsors. So won't you show our sponsors a little love by whitelisting investmentnews.com? It'll help us continue to serve you.

Yes, show me how to whitelist investmentnews.com

Ad blocker detected. Please whitelist us or give premium a try.

X

Subscribe and Save 60%

Premium Access
Print + Digital

Learn more
Subscribe to Print