How 401(k) deductions were saved in budget drama

Diverse efforts and a tweet from Trump came together for rescue

Jan 22, 2018 @ 11:29 am

By Hazel Bradford

Fears of drastic changes to retirement savings tax advantages during the recent tax reform deal failed to materialize, thanks to the efforts of an unusual coalition, old-fashioned lobbying and a presidential tweet.

The allure of reducing the tax preferences for pretax retirement savings plans to raise federal revenue is nothing new. Ideas have been floated by Republicans and Democrats alike whenever money is needed to pay for tax cuts, federal spending and debt demands, and other fiscal crises.

But for many Washington observers, those tax advantages came closer than ever to real peril in 2017, which saw the biggest push for tax reform in more than 30 years along with the biggest price tag: more than $1.5 trillion in tax cuts and projected lost revenue that had to be offset.

Panic started to spread among retirement plan executives and service providers when White House and Republican tax negotiators in Congress refused to rule out the idea of "Rothification," a dramatic shift to post-tax Roth accounts from pre-tax savings preferences for traditional 401(k) accounts.

As tax-negotiating committees started to work on legislation, other ideas cropped up. One cause for alarm was a Senate proposal to prohibit individuals earning $500,000 or more annually from making catch-up contributions. That sparked memories of proposals from Barack Obama's administration to means-test retirement plans and impose lower contribution caps to shift the benefit more toward the middle class.

Another rumored change was capping pre-tax contribution levels to as little as $2,400, down from current annual caps of $18,000, or $24,000 for those older than 50. That idea, said one lobbyist who asked not to be identified, "was a tactical decision that backfired" and instead galvanized opposition to any retirement-related changes.

The gravity of what was at stake led to formation of the Save Our Savings Coalition, a combination of former go-it-alone trade groups, financial services firms, plan sponsor organizations and even the AARP, represented — or more accurately, herded — by Groom Law Group, which started strategizing when President Donald Trump brought his tax-cut mantra to Washington.

First-time Coalition

"This is the first time we've banded together, and it was very successful," said Brian Graff, CEO of the American Retirement Association in Arlington, Va., an umbrella organization for groups representing 25,000 pension professionals, actuaries, plan advisers and others. "There was a tremendous amount of lobbying, but it was also PR and grass roots," Mr. Graff said.

Leaks from Democratic congressional staffers opposed to the Republican tax plan also helped to draw previously silent members of Congress into the fray.

As members of Congress were educated by coalition members about the potentially negative impact on retirement savings, "they came out when it became real. The coalition ran a pretty successful grass-roots and inside-the-Beltway campaign, and were able to educate members of Congress on both sides," said Michael Kreps, a Groom principal and former Senate pension aide.

Media coverage of what was at stake for retirement savers led to direct involvement by President Trump with an Oct. 23 tweet: "There will be NO change to your 401(k). This has always been a great and popular middle-class tax break that works, and it stays!" That tweet, said many on the front lines, made a tremendous difference by shutting off debate within the administration and Congress.

When it became apparent that many middle-class retirement savers would be hurt by the changes, "it became too perilous to pursue," said Geoff Manville, principal, government relations at Mercer LLC in Washington. "I think Congress properly realized that a major restructuring of the system is a gamble we cannot afford to take, especially when we are dealing with retirement security."

It also helped that other revenue-raisers were found, such as trimming state and local tax deductions and cutting the Affordable Care Act health insurance mandate, "but I'd like to believe that they backed off for policy reasons first and foremost," said Mr. Manville.

In the end, said Derek Dorn, managing director and head of regulatory engagement and policy for TIAA-CREF in New York and a former Senate aide, "there was an appreciation (by members of Congress) that the revenue savings were specious and the policy case particularly weak."

Coalition members are taking a well-earned break, but promise to remain vigilant. "There will continue to be pressure," said Mr. Manville. "Once a revenue-raiser is introduced, it never goes away. It's on the shelf."

Hazel Bradford is a reporter for InvestmentNews' sister publication Pensions & Investments.


What do you think?

View comments

Recommended for you

Upcoming Event

May 14


Retirement Income Summit

Join InvestmentNews at the 12th annual Retirement Income Summit - the industry's premier retirement planning conference.Much has changed - and much remains to be learned. Attend and discuss how the future is full of opportunity for ... Learn more

Featured video


How to improve productivity

Expanding your business can be a challenge for advisers. Tim Welsh of Nexus Strategy offers some helpful strategies to take your practice to the next level.

Latest news & opinion

Q&A with Abigail Johnson and Kathleen Murphy of Fidelity Investments

The Fidelity CEO, along with the president of personal investing, discuss record earnings, allegations of sexual misconduct and the challenges facing a changing industry.

The Women’s Issue

News, video and expert opinion about women in financial advice

Meet the 2018 Women to Watch

These female financial advisers and other industry leaders are recognized for their successes and support of other women in the financial advice business.

Some good news about female recruitment in financial advice

Each of four core advisory positions tracked in InvestmentNews' benchmarking study has seen an uptick in women entrants.

10 ETFs that are up more than 35% this year

Amid the stock market carnage, there are still some funds posting big gains.


Hi! Glad you're here and we hope you like all the great work we do here at InvestmentNews. But what we do is expensive and is funded in part by our sponsors. So won't you show our sponsors a little love by whitelisting It'll help us continue to serve you.

Yes, show me how to whitelist

Ad blocker detected. Please whitelist us or give premium a try.


Subscribe and Save 60%

Premium Access
Print + Digital

Learn more
Subscribe to Print