Appeals court upholds dismissal of Wells Fargo 401(k) lawsuit

Participant argued that the plan could have offered a better-performing, nonproprietary TDF

Aug 6, 2018 @ 10:54 am

By Robert Steyer

A federal appeals court in St. Louis upheld a U.S. District Court judge's dismissal of an ERISA breach claim against Wells Fargo & Co. by a participant in the company's 401(k) plan, who alleged fiduciaries could have offered a better-performing nonproprietary investment choice.

The complaint "failed to plausibly allege a breach of fiduciary duty," according to the unanimous ruling by a three-judge panel. "The complaint failed to state a claim upon which relief can be granted."

In the case of Meiners et al. vs. Wells Fargo & Co et al., a U.S. District Court Judge in Minneapolis had dismissed the complaint in May 2017.

(More: Wells Fargo sued, again, for using in-house funds in 401(k) plan)

The participant, John Meiners, had argued that including the Wells Fargo Dow Jones Target Date Funds series was an ERISA violation because a similar target-date series from Vanguard Group had better returns.

"A comparison of the returns of two different funds is insufficient" to prove a fiduciary breach, U.S. District Court Judge David S. Doty wrote. The Wells Fargo series, he noted, had a higher allocation of bonds than the Vanguard series.

"The District Court correctly determined that Meiners' omission of any meaningful benchmark in his complaint mean that he failed to allege any facts showing the Wells Fargo [target-date funds] were an imprudent choice," the appeals court wrote. "As a result, Meiners' complaint failed to state a claim for relief under ERISA and we affirm its dismissal."

The Wells Fargo & Co. 401(k) Plan had $45.9 billion in assets as of Dec. 31, 2017, according to its latest 11-K filing.

(More: 401(k) lawsuits being brought more aggressively against retirement plan advisers)

Robert Steyer is a reporter for InvestmentNews' sister publication Pensions & Investments.

0
Comments

What do you think?

View comments

Most watched

INTV

Young professionals see lots of opportunity to reinvent the advice experience

Members of the 2019 InvestmentNews class of 40 Under 40 have strategies to overcome the challenges of being young in a mature industry.

INTV

Young advisers envision a radically different business in five years

Fintech and sustainable investing are two factors being watched closely by some of the 2019 class of InvestmentNews' 40 Under 40.

Latest news & opinion

Target-date fund design may be wrong for retirees

Researchers suggest the funds don't adequately hedge against sequence-of-returns risk in retirement.

InvestmentNews' 2019 class of 40 Under 40

Our 40 Under 40 project, now in its sixth year, highlights young talent in the financial advice industry. These individuals illustrate the tremendous potential of those coming up in the profession. These stories will surprise, entertain, educate and inspire.

New Jersey fiduciary rule: Pressure leads to public hearing, comment deadline extension

Industry push results in chance to air grievances on July 17 and another month to present objections.

Galvin to propose fiduciary rule for Massachusetts brokers

The secretary of the commonwealth is proposing a fiduciary standard in response to an SEC investment-advice rule he views as too weak.

Summer reading recommendations from financial advisers

Here are some books that will keep you informed and entertained during summer's downtime

X

Hi! Glad you're here and we hope you like all the great work we do here at InvestmentNews. But what we do is expensive and is funded in part by our sponsors. So won't you show our sponsors a little love by whitelisting investmentnews.com? It'll help us continue to serve you.

Yes, show me how to whitelist investmentnews.com

Ad blocker detected. Please whitelist us or give premium a try.

X

Subscribe and Save 60%

Premium Access
Print + Digital

Learn more
Subscribe to Print