DOL fiduciary rule caused $14 billion in stock losses for investment firms: report

But the election of Donald Trump gained those firms back $56 billion in market value, as investors expected a rollback of financial regulations

Sep 5, 2018 @ 2:07 pm

By Greg Iacurci

The Department of Labor's fiduciary rule led to "tremendous" losses for brokerage and other investment firms, causing billions of dollars to be shed from their market valuations as investors feared the rule would hurt profitability, according to a new report.

The report examines the stock prices of 36 publicly traded brokerage, mutual fund and life insurance companies, finding they lost a total $14 billion in value as a direct result of the fiduciary rule.

That correlates to a 2.5% loss in the group's overall market capitalization, which was $571 billion as of mid-February 2015, days before President Barack H. Obama directed the Labor Department to propose its conflict-of-interest rule governing investment advice in retirement accounts.

The report 's four co-authors — Cliff Moll, Robert Kunkel and Bruce Niendorf of the University of Wisconsin Oshkosh, and Kristine Beck of California State University in Northridge — dub the fiduciary rule's market impact the "Obama Effect."

"We find a large Obama Effect," they said. "This result is not surprising, since the profitability and value of investment firms is reduced by the inability to collect conflict-of-interest fees."

The White House Council of Economic Advisers said investment companies collect $17 billion annually due to conflicted investment advice to retirement savers.

The report, titled "How Do Investment Companies Fare Under Obama and Trump Fiduciary Rules" and set to publish in an upcoming issue of the Journal of Accounting and Finance, adds together three events over 2015-16: Mr. Obama's call to action, publication of the proposed fiduciary rule in the Federal Register and publication of the final rule.

The report also quantifies the so-called "Trump Effect," measuring the positive market impact for investment firms of President Donald J. Trump's presidential election victory, coupled with Republican control of Congress.

As a candidate, Mr. Trump signaled his wish for broad deregulation, saying just a month before the election that he would slash as much as 70% of federal regulations. Anthony Scaramucci, an adviser to Mr. Trump who subsequently served a short stint as White House communications director, said during the campaign that Mr. Trump would "repeal" the fiduciary rule if elected.

The report authors found the Trump Effect to be much greater than the Obama Effect. Cumulatively, the three dozen investment companies, which included firms such as Morgan Stanley, Raymond James Financial Corp. and TD Ameritrade Holding Corp., gained $56 billion in market value as a result of the election results.

The report calls this an "astonishing" increase.

"Given that Americans saving for retirement will likely continue to pay conflict-of-interest fees, the financial markets are optimistic about the future revenue streams of these investment companies," according to the report. "With the election of Trump, investment companies recovered all the losses from the Obama Effect and more."

Authors note, however, that investors priced in the expectation of rollbacks to financial regulations in addition to the fiduciary rule.

Since his election, Mr. Trump also has signed a rollback of some banking rules codified in the Dodd-Frank financial reform law. He also installed an ardent critic of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau — Mick Mulvaney — to be the agency's acting director. In February 2017, months before the fiduciary rule was scheduled to take effect, Mr. Trump directed the Labor Department to review the fiduciary rule, which subsequently died in court.


What do you think?

View comments

Upcoming event

Sep 24


Diversity & Inclusion Awards

Attend an event celebrating diversity and inclusion as well as recognizing those who are leading the financial services profession in this important endeavor. Join InvestmentNews, as we strive to raise awareness, educate and inspire an... Learn more

Most watched


Young professionals see lots of opportunity to reinvent the advice experience

Members of the 2019 InvestmentNews class of 40 Under 40 have strategies to overcome the challenges of being young in a mature industry.


Young advisers envision a radically different business in five years

Fintech and sustainable investing are two factors being watched closely by some of the 2019 class of InvestmentNews' 40 Under 40.

Latest news & opinion

New Jersey fiduciary rule: Pressure leads to public hearing, comment deadline extension

Industry push results in chance to air grievances on July 17 and another month to present objections.

InvestmentNews' 2019 class of 40 Under 40

Our 40 Under 40 project, now in its sixth year, highlights young talent in the financial advice industry. These individuals illustrate the tremendous potential of those coming up in the profession. These stories will surprise, entertain, educate and inspire.

Galvin to propose fiduciary rule for Massachusetts brokers

The secretary of the commonwealth is proposing a fiduciary standard in response to an SEC investment-advice rule he views as too weak.

Summer reading recommendations from financial advisers

Here are some books that will keep you informed and entertained during summer's downtime

4 strategies for Roth conversions

There's never been a better time to do a Roth conversion, and here are several ways to go about it.


Hi! Glad you're here and we hope you like all the great work we do here at InvestmentNews. But what we do is expensive and is funded in part by our sponsors. So won't you show our sponsors a little love by whitelisting It'll help us continue to serve you.

Yes, show me how to whitelist

Ad blocker detected. Please whitelist us or give premium a try.


Subscribe and Save 60%

Premium Access
Print + Digital

Learn more
Subscribe to Print