The Washington INsider

New Jersey could be first in fiduciary 'blue wave' with pending proposal

State poised to jump to lead in resisting forthcoming SEC advice rule

Oct 9, 2018 @ 2:13 pm

By Mark Schoeff Jr.

A calm surface on the waters of investment advice reform is about to be broken by what could be the beginning of a fiduciary blue wave at the state level.

Next Monday, the New Jersey Bureau of Securities is expected to release for public comment a proposed rule that would require all financial advisers in the state to put their clients' interests ahead of their own when making investment recommendations.

This statewide fiduciary duty could very well conflict with the final advice rule the Securities and Exchange Commission is expected to promulgate later this year or in early 2019. With the SEC reviewing thousands of comments about its proposal, the advice reform issue has been relatively quiet for a few weeks. That is set to change.

Other states could join New Jersey in drafting their own standard. In Nevada, there is already a fiduciary law on the books. But the state's securities regulator has not yet proposed the regulations that would implement it.

With New Jersey in the state fiduciary lead, here's what to watch for.


Unlike investment advice legislation introduced in the New Jersey and New York legislatures, the New Jersey regulation — as well as the Nevada law — targets the behavior of financial advisers. Requiring them to act in the best interests of their clients instead of just disclosing whether they are fiduciaries would make the regulation much tougher than the bills.


The other aspect of rulemaking that can make it more potent than legislation is that it can move much faster. The securities bureau in New Jersey ultimately reports to Governor Phil Murphy. Generally, an executive branch is nimbler than a legislature, where bills almost always face political crosswinds, even when one party dominates both chambers.


The speed advantage of regulation comes with a vulnerability: Rules are more likely than laws to be overturned in court.

"If this rule ends up being restrictive on broker-dealers, I would imagine they'll challenge the validity of the rulemaking in court," said Jamie Hopkins, professor of retirement planning at The American College. "It's always easier to get something out the door through rulemaking. The drawback is that it would have less deference [in court] than a state statute."

There already are warnings that the New Jersey proposal would violate federal preemption laws. The American Retirement Association asserts that federal retirement law, the Employee Retirement Income Security Act, would trump a New Jersey rule.

"There is a strong argument to be made that any regulation of fiduciary advisory services to employer-sponsored retirement plans and their participants and beneficiaries would be preempted by ERISA — a case that has been outlined in an opinion letter commissioned by us and authored by [law firm] Trucker Huss, and which we intend to share with the New Jersey regulators as they consider this new initiative," Joseph Caruso, ARA government affairs counsel, said in a statement.


When Mr. Murphy announced the New Jersey rulemaking, it removed any doubt about where he stands on investment advice reform. The former Goldman Sachs executive, a Democrat, is firmly on the side of investor advocates who have denounced the killing of the Labor Department's fiduciary rule in a federal appeals court and have asserted that the SEC proposal is too weak.

Other states, especially those that are blue — with Democratic majorities in the state legislature or a Democrat in the governor's office — may follow New Jersey's lead and propose their own advice standards.

On an issue that is becoming increasingly partisan, it's not hard to imagine more resistance to what Democratic governors may perceive as the Trump administration's lack of support for investor protection.

"I expect some states will jump into that [fiduciary] arena," Mr. Hopkins said.

The fiduciary waters will start churning again in a few days.


What do you think?

View comments

Recommended for you

Upcoming Event

Nov 13


Best Practices Workshop

For the sixth year, InvestmentNews will host the Best Practices Workshop & Awards, bringing together the industry’s top-performing and most influential firms in one room for a full-day. This exclusive workshop and awards program for the... Learn more

Featured video


InvestmentNews celebrates diversity & inclusion in the financial advice business

Highlights of the Excellence in D&I Awards, showcasing the achievements of 26 individuals and firms that are moving the needle when it comes to diversity and inclusion.

Latest news & opinion

Social Security and the fear of missing out

How to lower expectations when clients think they're owed a bigger Social Security benefit.

7 things advisers should do today to boost diversity and inclusion

Creating diversity and inclusion within financial advice firms is challenging, but these InvestmentNews Excellence in Diversity & Inclusion award winners have suggestions that firms can put into practice today

The midterm elections: What's at stake for financial advisers

A shift in control of the House could change the course of important issues, including the SEC advice rule, tax reform and retirement policies.

What to tell your clients after they've won the lottery

The current combined Mega Millions and Powerball jackpots are more than $850 million. What should you tell your clients if they have a winning ticket?

2019 Medicare premiums announced

Slight increase in Part B premium to $135.50 per month is in line with expectations.


Hi! Glad you're here and we hope you like all the great work we do here at InvestmentNews. But what we do is expensive and is funded in part by our sponsors. So won't you show our sponsors a little love by whitelisting It'll help us continue to serve you.

Yes, show me how to whitelist

Ad blocker detected. Please whitelist us or give premium a try.


Subscribe and Save 60%

Premium Access
Print + Digital

Learn more
Subscribe to Print