Vanguard share of target-date fund market becoming 'obscene'

The fund giant has ridden the wave of investors seeking lower costs, primarily as a result of retirement-plan lawsuits

Mar 4, 2019 @ 2:05 pm

By Greg Iacurci

Vanguard Group extended its dominance over the target-date fund market last year as the flow of retirement assets into index funds continued unabated, with employers seeking to reduce the cost of their 401(k) plans.

Vanguard swelled its target-date assets by $26 billion in 2018, the biggest increase of any firm, according to Sway Research, which studies asset management distribution in retirement plans.

With $649 billion held in its target-date mutual funds and collective investment trust funds, the index fund behemoth now controls nearly 37% of the roughly $1.8 trillion market, according to Sway. The asset manager's market share has swelled five percentage points, from 32%, in the last three years.

Fidelity Investments and T. Rowe Price, the second- and third-largest TDF providers, respectively, behind Vanguard, saw their market shares decline over the same time period. Fidelity's decreased three points to 13.9%, and T. Rowe's fell two points to 12.6%, according to Sway.

Meanwhile, Vanguard's share of passively managed TDFs — those whose underlying investments are primarily index funds — sits at nearly 70%.

"Their share of passive assets is obscene," said Chris Brown, founder and principal of Sway Research.

Vanguard and other index-focused providers, such as BlackRock Inc. and State Street Global Advisors, have ridden the trend of passive investing in retirement plans and the broader market as investors seek lower costs.

The slew of lawsuits targeting employers for excessive 401(k) investment and administration fees have concerned plan sponsors, Mr. Brown said. In addition, the Labor Department's fiduciary rule, parts of which went into effect in 2017 but which was subsequently killed in court, caused plan sponsors and their advisers to focus more keenly on their fiduciary responsibilities.

"It's hard to see much changing this right now," Mr. Brown said of the trend toward index TDFs. "The focus is still so much on fees right now."

(More: Investor confusion about target-date funds is alarming)

Vanguard's target-date mutual fund fees are among the industry's lowest, at a cost of 0.09% on an asset-weighted basis for its Vanguard Institutional Target Retirement funds, tied with SSgA's Target Retirement funds, according to Sway data. Only Charles Schwab's Target Index funds are cheaper, at 0.08%.

By comparison, the cheapest actively managed target-date mutual fund costs 0.51%, for TIAA-CREF's Lifecycle funds.

Also working against active funds right now is the fact that they performed worse last year, on an asset-weighted basis, than index TDFs, even though the stock market was down — an environment in which active managers are thought to show more relative value.

Passive TDFs returned an average -6.18% in 2018, compared with -6.56% for active funds, according to Sway. The S&P 500 was down 6.2% last year.

Passive TDFs now have better one-, three- and five-year asset-weighted returns than active TDFs, a reversal from a year ago. Those statistics could accelerate the flow of TDF assets from active to passive funds, Mr. Brown said.

(More: Fidelity faces Galvin inquiry over fees charged for 401(k) plans)


What do you think?

View comments

Most watched


Finding innovation in your firm

Adam Holt of AssetMap explains how advisers understand they need to grow, but great innovation may be lurking right under your nose.


Finding your edge from Tony Robbins

Guru Tony Robbins has helped a lot of people, but armed with his psychology Financial Advisor Josh Nelson has helped his practice soar.

Latest news & opinion

How to battle sequence-of-returns risk

Retiring during the longest-running bull market in history can be scary, as some begin to wonder when the good times will end.

Tony Robbins loses role with RIA amid charges of sexual misconduct

String of allegations costs the self-help guru his gig as chief of investor psychology at Creative Planning.

SEC sets June 5 date for vote on Regulation Best Interest

Commission adds new item to agenda: Interpretation of broker guidance that qualifies as advice

House passes SECURE retirement bill with massive bipartisan support

The measure allows small employers to band together to offer plans and raises the RMD age. Another provision eases use of annuities in 401(k)s, which critics say goes too far

10 IBDs with the most annuity revenue

Here are the independent broker-dealers that brought in the most annuity revenue last year.


Hi! Glad you're here and we hope you like all the great work we do here at InvestmentNews. But what we do is expensive and is funded in part by our sponsors. So won't you show our sponsors a little love by whitelisting It'll help us continue to serve you.

Yes, show me how to whitelist

Ad blocker detected. Please whitelist us or give premium a try.


Subscribe and Save 60%

Premium Access
Print + Digital

Learn more
Subscribe to Print