Investment returns do not move in a straight line. Markets experience periods of growth, followed by corrections and downturns. While portfolios may grow over the long term, short-term fluctuations can lead to negative returns at critical moments. This becomes more important when investors begin withdrawing from their portfolios, especially during retirement.
This is where sequence of returns risk becomes a central concern. Sequence of returns risk refers to how the timing and order of investment returns can affect a portfolio's ability to sustain withdrawals. When negative returns occur early, the impact can be severe. You may need to sell investments at a loss to generate income, reducing the portfolio's capacity to recover even when markets improve.
Sequence of returns risk becomes most critical during retirement because of the shift from accumulation to distribution. While working, the focus is on building wealth. Market downturns may reduce portfolio value, but there's still time to recover. In retirement, that dynamic changes. You stop contributing and begin relying on your portfolio to generate income.
This increased dependence on portfolio withdrawals makes timing more important. You are no longer waiting for investments to grow. You are actively drawing from them to support living expenses.
If market downturns occur during this phase, especially early in retirement, you may need to sell investments at a loss. This reduces the overall value of the portfolio and weakens its ability to recover over time.
Recovery time is also more limited in retirement. A retiree may face a 20- to 30-year horizon, but losses in the early years can create lasting damage. Without new contributions and with ongoing withdrawals, the portfolio has fewer opportunities to rebuild. Even if markets improve later, the reduced asset base may not be enough to sustain long-term income needs.
This risk is closely linked to longevity risk. As life expectancy increases, your portfolio must support income over a longer period. A poorly timed sequence of returns can shorten the lifespan of retirement savings.
Financial research, including work by Wade Pfau, shows that advisors generally rely on four core approaches to manage sequence of returns risk. Each approach focuses on reducing pressure on the portfolio during periods of market decline, especially in the early years of retirement.
Advisors may recommend withdrawing less than traditional rules such as the 4 percent rule. Lower withdrawal rates reduce the strain on the portfolio during downturns and improve the chances that assets will last throughout retirement. Even small differences can lead to very different outcomes.
For example, two investors with the same starting portfolio may experience different recovery paths depending on whether they withdraw 2 percent or 4 percent. The lower withdrawal rate allows the portfolio to recover faster and improve long-term sustainability. A higher withdrawal rate creates a stronger headwind, requiring more years of consistent returns to rebuild value.
This effect becomes more pronounced when withdrawals continue during a downturn. Selling investments to meet income needs reduces the portfolio base, which makes future recovery more difficult. Managing inflation adjustments is also important. A balanced approach that considers withdrawal rate, flexibility, and market conditions improves the chances that retirement income will last.
Instead of fixed withdrawals, advisors often suggest adjusting spending based on market performance. When markets decline, you reduce withdrawals. When markets perform well, you can increase spending. This flexibility helps prevent locking in losses during unfavorable conditions.
Maintaining buffer assets such as cash reserves, short-term instruments, or even structures like cash value life insurance provides an alternative source of funds. These buffers allow you to meet spending needs without selling investments at depressed prices.
Using guaranteed income sources helps manage sequence of returns risk by reducing reliance on market-based withdrawals during downturns. Social Security often provides a stable income base while income annuities and similar products create consistent cash flow. Additional tools such as cash value life insurance can also provide liquidity, helping protect your portfolio during the most vulnerable years.
In addition to these four core approaches, advisors may also use the following strategies:
Asset allocation helps by balancing exposure to growth and stability across stocks, bonds, and cash. A diversified structure, such as a 60/40 portfolio, combined with regular rebalancing, can reduce volatility. However, diversification has limits, so it works best alongside strategies like cash buffers, flexible withdrawals, and guaranteed income.
Preparation should begin two to five years before retirement. During this period, you gradually shift part of your portfolio toward more stable assets such as bonds and cash equivalents while still maintaining growth investments.
Diversification should extend beyond asset classes to include a tax-efficient portfolio design. Structuring assets across taxable, tax-deferred, and tax-free accounts gives you flexibility. Here's more on tax-efficient investing:
Financial advisors can design asset allocation strategies, set sustainable withdrawal rates, and implement approaches such as bucket strategies or guaranteed income solutions.
The goal is not to avoid market losses entirely. Instead, you aim to reduce their impact when they occur at the worst possible time. By combining liquidity, diversification, flexible withdrawals, and guaranteed income, you build a resilient portfolio that can support long-term financial stability.
Find out how the top financial advisors in the US use these strategies in this special report.
A bucket strategy is a common approach advisor use to protect portfolios from sequence of returns risk. You divide your retirement portfolio into separate "buckets" based on time horizon and purpose. This structure allows you to match specific assets to specific spending needs, rather than treating the portfolio as a single pool of funds.
The short-term bucket focuses on immediate expenses, typically covering one to five years of withdrawals. You allocate this portion to cash, cash equivalents, or short-term bonds. These assets are more stable, so they provide a reliable source of income even when markets decline. This reduces the need to sell volatile investments during downturns.
The medium-term bucket supports spending needs over the next several years. You usually invest this portion in bonds or conservative assets that can generate modest growth while preserving capital. This bucket acts as a bridge between short-term liquidity and long-term growth.
The long-term bucket focuses on growth. You typically allocate this portion to equities and other higher-risk investments designed to support income later in retirement. Because you do not need these assets immediately, they can stay invested through market cycles and recover from downturns.
Here's more on the bucket strategy:
The main benefit of this structure is that it reduces forced selling during market declines. When markets fall, you can draw income from the short-term bucket instead of selling growth assets at depressed prices. Cash reserves serve a similar purpose. Many advisors recommend holding one to several years of income in cash as a buffer during market downturns.
Visit and bookmark our retirement planning news section for the latest updates on sequence of returns risk.
Average returns are often used to evaluate investment performance. However, average return alone does not capture how a portfolio behaves when withdrawals are involved. Two portfolios can generate the same average annual returns but produce very different outcomes depending on the sequence of those returns.
The key difference lies in timing. During accumulation, the order of returns has little effect if no withdrawals are made. In retirement, the situation changes. When you withdraw income from a portfolio, the sequence of returns becomes critical. Negative returns early in the withdrawal phase can reduce the capital, which limits the ability of the portfolio to recover even if returns improve later.
This is why overall performance metrics can be misleading. A portfolio that shows consistent long-term average returns may still fail to sustain retirement income if losses occur at the wrong time. The path of returns, not just the level of returns, determines the outcome.
Consider two investors with identical starting portfolios, the same withdrawal rate, and the same average return over time. One investor experiences negative return early in retirement while the other encounters those same losses later. Despite having similar annual returns, their results can be very different. The investor with early losses may see their portfolio depleted much sooner while the other may maintain or even grow their assets over the same period.
Sequence of returns risk shows that the timing of investment returns matters just as much as the returns themselves. Two portfolios can generate the same average performance over time but produce very different outcomes depending on when gains and losses occur. When withdrawals begin, early negative returns can permanently reduce the capital base and limit the portfolio's ability to recover.
This is why retirement planning must focus not only on accumulation, but also on how income is generated and sustained. A portfolio that performs well on paper may still fail if it cannot support withdrawals during unfavorable market conditions. Ultimately, managing sequence of returns risk is about building a resilient strategy.
The partnership helps more advisors address Peak 65 clients' concerns with a new retirement income offering on LPL's managed accounts platform.
Advisors offer tips on how to keep investors from constantly checking their retirement accounts and making rash portfolio moves.
Financial professionals tend to emphasize the strong quantitative benefits annuities provide, yet it’s the emotional and behavioral benefits that often make them the ideal choice for consumers.
Experts discuss life expectancy and other retirement risks faced by advisors and their clients at a recent RIA LABs webinar.
