Sales tax advice court battle a warning for wealth managers

Sales tax advice court battle a warning for wealth managers
Island Consolidated claims it restructured its business based on flawed advice from Grassi & Co and that it was never part of a formal agreement.
JUN 09, 2025

Grassi & Co., a New York-based accounting firm, is facing a professional malpractice lawsuit over sales tax guidance it provided without a separate engagement agreement. 

In a June 5 ruling, the Appellate Division, First Department, allowed Island Consolidated and affiliated companies to proceed with claims that Grassi’s sales tax advice in early 2015 led to significant expenses and changes to their business operations. 

According to the court, Grassi had been retained under written engagement agreements to perform specific services: preparing and auditing financial statements and preparing corporate and partnership income tax returns. These agreements also included a clause requiring notice and mediation before any lawsuit could be filed. 

The agreements did not mention sales tax advice. While they allowed for “Additional Services” through a separate written agreement, no such agreement was created when Grassi, at the plaintiffs’ request, provided sales tax advice in early 2015. 

Years later, in 2021, Island Consolidated faced a New York State tax audit. The plaintiffs allege that Grassi again became involved—this time representing them in defense of the sales tax guidance it had given in 2015. That continued involvement became central to the court’s conclusion that the firm’s representation extended into the audit process, supporting the application of the continuous representation doctrine. 

Grassi moved to dismiss the complaint, arguing the plaintiffs failed to meet the contract’s pre-litigation requirements and that the claims were time-barred. The court disagreed. It found that because sales tax advice was not listed in the original scope of services, the mediation clause did not clearly apply. The court also ruled that the 2021 representation was sufficient to toll the statute of limitations. 

The decision also held that it would be premature to dismiss any of the plaintiffs’ claims for damages at this early stage, especially given the allegations of gross negligence. 

For financial advisors and accounting professionals, the ruling serves as a cautionary reminder: offering services outside the agreed scope—without formal documentation—can create long-tail liability. Firms should be diligent in ensuring all additional services are covered by written agreements, particularly in areas with regulatory or tax implications. 

Related Topics:
Tax ‘advice’ more important than ever Deloitte pays $40M for Pa. carrier malpractice

Latest News

What advisors need to know about SECURE 2.0’s impact on retirement income planning
What advisors need to know about SECURE 2.0’s impact on retirement income planning

Catch-up contributions, required minimum distributions, and 529 plans are just some of the areas the Biden-ratified legislation touches.

EToro to tokenize US stocks on Ethereum network for 24/7 trading
EToro to tokenize US stocks on Ethereum network for 24/7 trading

Following a similar move by Robinhood, the online investing platform said it will also offer 24/5 trading initially with a menu of 100 US-listed stocks and ETFs.

GTCR to acquire FMG Suite, expanding its wealth tech portfolio
GTCR to acquire FMG Suite, expanding its wealth tech portfolio

The private equity giant will support the advisor tech marketing firm in boosting its AI capabilities and scaling its enterprise relationships.

$29B Lido Advisors expands in Utah with Olympus Wealth Management
$29B Lido Advisors expands in Utah with Olympus Wealth Management

The privately backed RIA's newest partner firm brings $850 million in assets while giving it a new foothold in the Salt Lake City region.

Annuities hit new $223B high in H1 2025, LIMRA says
Annuities hit new $223B high in H1 2025, LIMRA says

The latest preliminary data show $117 billion in second-quarter sales, but hints of a slowdown are emerging.

SPONSORED How advisors can build for high-net-worth complexity

Orion's Tom Wilson on delivering coordinated, high-touch service in a world where returns alone no longer set you apart.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today's choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.