Washington advisor claims victories in Hightower noncompete saga

Washington advisor claims victories in Hightower noncompete saga
The legal skirmish has taken several turns, including a temporary restraining order and a decision kicking the case back to the state level.
APR 03, 2024

The ongoing skirmish between Bellevue, Washington-based financial advisor Lars Knudsen and independent wealth giant Hightower Advisors has taken another turn as Knudsen claims a number of legal wins.

The saga, which has drawn considerable attention, revolves around contractual breaches and defamation.

It began with a lawsuit Knudsen filed against Hightower in King County, Washington, on March 20, in which Knudsen claimed Hightower employed questionable tactics, such as illegal noncompete clauses and false allegations about him, in an effort to poach his clients.

In the weeks since, the two parties have engaged in a furious legal back-and-forth.

Immediately after Knudsen’s filing, Hightower launched its own suit against him in Illinois federal court, after which Knudsen filed to request a temporary restraining order against the firm. When that failed, he challenged Hightower’s motion to move the case to federal court, filing a motion to stay the Illinois action in favor of the action he launched in Washington.

So far, Knudsen’s camp has claimed victories on several fronts, including a Washington district court decision to remand the lawsuit back to the state level, a decision by the state court’s commissioner granting a temporary restraining order against Hightower, and a Washington state court judge's decision to quash a request from Hightower to hear a motion to dismiss the case on an expedited basis.

The state commissioner’s temporary restraining order against Hightower, handed down Tuesday, was sought by Knudsen – supported by more than a dozen sworn declarations from his clients – to halt what he described as a campaign of disinformation by Hightower along with Hightower Bellevue partners Dan Stober, Randy Williams-Gurian, Tara Johnson, and Sharon Lailey.

“The legal process can be complicated with a lot of moving parts, but we will continue to work with integrity and respect for the judicial system,” Andrew R. Escobar, a partner at Seyfarth Shaw who’s representing Knudsen, said in an emailed statement.

“While we hope for a quick resolution to this legal matter, these milestone victories keep us on a legal pathway we hope will lead to an amicable and swift conclusion that allows Lars to move forward serving his clients as he has for decades,” Escobar said.

“HighTower seems to think they can say anything, even the most egregious accusations, without any repercussions,” Knudsen said in the statement. “I have always been willing to reach a resolution and maybe these rulings will lead to a more productive discussion with HighTower executives and advisors.”

The case parallels another recent lawsuit against Hightower in California, where veteran advisor Darren Reinig said the firm was kneecapping his ability to build a new business with overreaching noncompete claims.

'Magnificent 7' slowdown creating opportunities for stock pickers, Stance fund manager says

More goRIA

Advisor optimism on organic growth clashes with reality: SEI
Advisor optimism on organic growth clashes with reality: SEI

Data from SEI says 81% of advisors are bullish on their expectations to add new clients, despite underwhelming organic growth rates across the industry.

Schwab IMPACT 2026 set to kick off in Boston
Schwab IMPACT 2026 set to kick off in Boston

More than 6,000 people are expected to attend the event at the Thomas M. Menino Convention and Exhibition Center in Boston.

SEC 2027 exam priorities target RIA fees, cash management and M&A 
SEC 2027 exam priorities target RIA fees, cash management and M&A 

Examiners will probe economic conflicts, private fund valuations and amended Reg S-P compliance as super intelligence enters the agenda.

RIA M&A runs up to 5x reported totals, Steward Partners CEO says
RIA M&A runs up to 5x reported totals, Steward Partners CEO says

Steward executives say small succession deals and book buyouts go unreported, tilting RIA valuation data toward big firms.

RIA IPO 'probably' coming within two years, dealmaker predicts
RIA IPO 'probably' coming within two years, dealmaker predicts

Private equity needs a public exit for mega-RIAs, ‘or else we have a big problem,’ warns M&A attorney Corey Kupfer.

SPONSORED Built on insurance experience to deliver on long-term promises

Knighthead Life entered the market with a competitive MYGA. A strong launch earned advisor confidence and paved the way for FIAs.

SPONSORED In the Age of AI, Trust Becomes the Advisor's Greatest Asset

As AI makes financial information more accessible than ever, Lana Hock explains why human judgment, trust, and empathy remain the qualities clients value most in a financial advisor