Financial advisory firms vary widely in their service models, target clients, and planning focus, so there are few pieces of technology that are universal to every advisor. The closest major categories to achieving universal adoption, according to the 2024 Kitces Research on Advisor Technology, were financial planning software (95%), CRM (92%), and performance reporting (87%). But one category of provider that is just as ubiquitous is RIA custodians – which are technically service providers and not pure technology (since RIAs generally don't custody assets and clear trades themselves); hence, they are not included in the Technology Study, but they do require a heavy technology infrastructure to facilitate the services they provide and the interface that advisors use to interact with them.
The combination of near-universal adoption and existing technology resources would seemingly make RIA custodians prime candidates for making other technology offerings as well. If an advisor is already logging into the custodian's platform every day, that gives the custodian many opportunities to get their other offerings in front of the advisor, and given the underlying economics of the custodial business they could probably afford to offer the technology at low (or even no) cost since the revenue from additional client assets that advisors bring on the platform could make up the cost of offering the software. In fact, that has been almost the exact business model of Altruist since its early days, which packaged rebalancing and performance reporting software for 'free' alongside its custodial offering, betting successfully that the ability to save what could amount to $10,000+ on portfolio management software would entice newer and growing RIAs to hand them their custody business as well.
However, this was also one of the driving factors behind BNY's Wove platform, which officially launched in 2023 (though it brought together components that existed previously under its predecessor, Pershing X). BNY's initial ambitions for Wove were possibly even more ambitious than Altruist's: To bring together portfolio management and CRM and financial planning, with a selection of in-house native apps (Salesforce CRM, Conquest financial planning, Albridge portfolio reporting, etc.) and connectivity for advisors to integrate their own software. All sitting on top of BNY/Pershing's custodial platform – because while Wove always purported to be multicustodial in functionality, the purpose was clearly to bring advisors closer to BNY's custodial ecosystem.
However, just over three years after its initial launch, BNY announced this month that it is dismantling Wove. Although some of the components (presumably including its Archer managed accounts technology and its Albridge reporting platform) will reportedly be retained and tucked into BNY's wealth solutions arm, they'll no longer be sold as a unified offering.
As the diverging paths of Altruist and Wove's advisor technology offerings show, it isn't necessarily a slam-dunk proposition for a custodian to get into the SaaS business. The technology has to be carefully calibrated against what advisors actually want and need, and the more separate pieces there are, the harder it is to get it right for a high enough number of advisors to gain any traction. It's possible that Wove was simply trying to do too much: although Altruist has since expanded its offerings to include things like donor advised funds, direct indexing, and cash management (along with its separate Hazel AI notetaker, tax planning, and financial planning suite), it started with a narrower range of technology that fit a high number of advisors' needs (rebalancing, performance reporting, and billing) and grew gradually from there rather than trying to be everything to everyone at the outset.
It's also worth noting that BNY isn't the only custodian that has struggled to gain traction on its software offerings. Fidelity once aspired for its Wealthscape platform to replace third party portfolio management tools, only to reverse course in 2024 and announce a bundle of third-party tools like Advyzon and Fidelity-owned eMoney (which it even seems to have backed off on since then, as no evidence of the bundle is available on Fidelity's site as of now). And Schwab's Portfolio Connect, which has been around since 2018, still offers little more than basic performance reporting and billing capabilities and lags far behind third party tools in adoption. From that perspective, Altruist is actually the outlier in having a reasonably successful technology offering as a custodian.
Which suggests that the reason behind Wove's struggles might not be (just) vision and execution, but also the hard reality of building new technology at a large and established financial institution. Because not only are there the challenges of competing for resources among the many divisions of a company like BNY, Fidelity, or Schwab, but once you actually get the green light to build something, the underlying infrastructure that you have to build on may well have been around for decades, making it hard to make something that feels truly modern and functional. To Pershing's credit, it did seem to be building Wove from the ground up – not just tacking it onto legacy technology – but performance is everything at a massive corporation like BNY, and after three years of not gaining much traction (as well as the departure of Pershing president Ainslie Simmonds earlier in the year) the parent corporation decided it had seen enough.
The takeaway, in part, is that it's just easier to build fast as a startup that can iterate and change directions when need be but still be focused on the end goal (e.g., having a successful technology offering to bring advisors and ultimately client assets onto the custody platform). Bigger organizations have the double whammy of being more cumbersome (requiring more time and dollars to turn the ship around) while also having a limited time to prove performance while risking having the entire operation cut. But the other side of it is that execution matters as well, and the bigger that you try to build all at once (say, with a multi-functional, multi-custodian, open-architecture-plus-native-app all-in-one platform) the riskier it is that key portions of it won't land with advisors. And in the end that proved too hard even for a company with BNY's size and balance sheet.
This article first appeared on the Nerd’s Eye View at Kitces.com at https://kitc.es/advisortech-nov2026, and has been reprinted here with permission.
Ben Henry-Moreland
Ben Henry-Moreland is a Senior Financial Planning Nerd at Kitces.com, where he specializes in writing and speaking on financial planning topics including tax, practice management, and technology. He also co-authors the monthly Kitces #AdvisorTech column. Drawing from his experience as a financial planner and a solo advisory firm owner, Ben is passionate about fulfilling the site’s mission of making financial advicers better and more successful.
Michael Kitces
Michael Kitces is Head of Planning Strategy at Focus Partners Wealth, which provides an evidence-based approach to private wealth management for near- and current retirees, and Focus Partners Advisor Solutions, a turnkey wealth management services provider supporting thousands of independent financial advisors through the scaling phase of growth.
In addition, he is a co-founder of the XY Planning Network, AdvicePay, fpPathfinder, and New Planner Recruiting, the former Practitioner Editor of the Journal of Financial Planning, the host of the Financial Advisor Success podcast, and the publisher of the popular financial planning industry blog Nerd’s Eye View through his website Kitces.com, dedicated to advancing knowledge in financial planning. In 2010, Michael was recognized with one of the FPA’s “Heart of Financial Planning” awards for his dedication and work in advancing the profession.
Altruist’s AI platform will let financial advisors summarize, build and discuss client estate plans starting in early 2027
Navigation and security beat flashy features for advised investors as U.S. Bank and Vanguard top digital experience rankings
The RIA consolidator's M&A run continues with a Louisville acquisition, a Nashua deal and a Dallas-area advisor
The Lenexa, Kansas broker-dealer and its 25 advisors managing $2.5 billion will gain expanded technology and product resources
DeepVest, Asset-Map and Aidentified launch automation that spots household gaps, wealth events and portfolio triggers for advisor sign-off.
Advisors are broadening the conversation beyond savings to help clients prepare for the realities of longer lives
Growing wealth, evolving priorities, and untapped opportunities are reshaping how women approach long-term investing.