Liquid alts' drawback: High cost

MAY 29, 2015
The more alternative products that fund companies offer, the bigger the dilemma facing financial advisers. For those who favor alternatives, managers are working to bring risk-diversifying strategies — long the exclusive province of big institutional investors and ultrawealthy individuals — into mom-and-pop-friendly mutual funds known as liquid alternatives. But adopting those strategies may cost you. The difficulties of bringing products to market and increasing their size without sacrificing performance means that, as much as firms might like to compete, few seem to feel the need to compete aggressively on price. “There's no Vanguard that's really dragging down the price,” said Morningstar Inc. analyst Jason Kephart. “Competition is still in the very early innings, so you don't have anyone who's established, like Pimco with bonds or Fidelity used to be with growth equity.” So far, the popularity of funds with exotic investment strategies means boom times for the relatively small number of big money managers. The top funds vying for attention in the space include bond behemoth Pacific Investment Management Co., the Natixis Funds roll-up of boutiques, the academically inclined AQR Funds and allocation-oriented John Hancock Investments. Large firms such as BlackRock Inc., The Goldman Sachs Group Inc. and Invesco Ltd. have also been making moves to build out their lineup of alternatives funds. Fund fees dropped nearly 5% to an average of 1.02% in 2013 from 1.07% in 2009. But alts charged 1.45% in 2013, down less than a percent from 2009, according to Lipper Inc. Behind that are at least two areas in which supply is constrained. First, managers with strong track records in niche strategies who will trade lucrative hedge fund fees for the lower revenue of a liquid-alts version are in short supply. And many of those strategies are limited in the amount of money they can take in without compromising performance. “It's a space where there's a lot of demand but not a lot of managers that have time-tested and proven records,” said Andrew Arnott, president of John Hancock Investments, which has $8.6 billion in alternative assets. “There are certain types of strategies that are not on the platform today that we are considering that will have very specific and stated capacity issues going out the door.”

"SEEDING' PRODUCTS

Second, the bandwidth of the broker-dealer gatekeepers charged with recommending funds to financial advisers is also limited. That creates advantages for firms that can invest in or “seed” those products in their infancy and gain a track record as well as an early share of assets. “The bottleneck in the pipeline is due diligence — it always is due diligence,” Mr. Arnott said. “The stacks on the desks of the gatekeepers at these broker-dealers is high. There is a lot to work through.” Matthew Coldren, who manages relationships with U.S. broker-dealers at Natixis Global Asset Management, said the research teams at those firms are cautious and “don't want to drop all these products on the platform.” But those broker-dealers are not pressuring Natixis — which markets the funds of a set of affiliates, including Loomis Sayles & Co. — to lower its management fees, he said. “That's completely up to us,” said Mr. Coldren, whose firm manages nearly $12.5 billion in alternative assets. Alternatives funds held nearly $206 billion in the U.S. as of Sept. 30, up an eye-popping 764% from $24 billion a decade ago. Despite that growth, the big firms in the category are struggling to differentiate their products, which fund managers complain are lumped together in overly diverse categories such as managed futures, unconstrained fixed income or long/short equity.

LONG/SHORT FUNDS

When the well-known $18 billion MainStay Marketfield Fund (MFADX) stumbled and broke its 31-month asset-gathering streak in April, investors across the board soured on long/short equity funds. In the past two quarters, inflows slowed by nearly 83%. Funds registering outflows for the period rose 56%, according to an InvestmentNews analysis of Morningstar data. Jason Ainsworth, head of the adviser sales business at Neuberger Berman Group, said long/short funds vary from those relying on macroeconomic predictions in picking companies to “short,” or bet against, to those relying primarily on “bottom-up” analyses of companies. “We definitely still have difficulty in the field with clients and advisers saying, "I have long/short, and I've got it covered,' “ said Mr. Ainsworth, whose firm offers a fund that competes with Marketfield. “As you've seen some of the larger players struggle — given their unique style and strategy — flows have slowed.” MainStay funds are managed by a subsidiary of the New York Life Insurance Co., which declined to comment. The fact that alternatives can charge a premium is helping to finance industry best practices, according to Evan Mizrachy, who runs the retail business at the alternatives subsidiary of BlackRock, the world's largest money manager. “The alternatives mutual funds require substantial investment in risk management,” Mr. Mizrachy said. “As more and more funds come to market, you'll start to see pricing get increasingly competitive.”

Latest News

Devoe: Record-breaking RIA M&A run led by private equity's consolidator comeback
Devoe: Record-breaking RIA M&A run led by private equity's consolidator comeback

A drop in interest rates and easier access to capital has reignited appetite among private equity-backed consolidators, who accounted for 53% of RIA deals so far this year- their highest share since 2021 according to Devoe & Company.

Fintech bytes: Advisor360, Nitrogen unveil AI updates for advisor productivity
Fintech bytes: Advisor360, Nitrogen unveil AI updates for advisor productivity

Also, Advisor CRM announces a new data integration partnership to ease the pain of client onboarding.

Bank of America, Morgan Stanley earnings roll despite roiled markets
Bank of America, Morgan Stanley earnings roll despite roiled markets

Meanwhile, Merrill Lynch intends to continue building its alternative investment platform for wealthy clients.

David Fischer of Independent Financial Group talks culture, future growth
David Fischer of Independent Financial Group talks culture, future growth

The co-founder of IFG discussed with InvestmentNews the unique opportunity that remaining independent offers to build a successful firm.

Wealth Consulting Group taps veterans from Envestnet, Emigrant Partners for new advisory board
Wealth Consulting Group taps veterans from Envestnet, Emigrant Partners for new advisory board

Three industry leaders will join the hybrid RIA's president and LPL alum, Andy Kalbaugh, to help guide its organic and merger-based growth strategy.

SPONSORED How advisors can build for high-net-worth complexity

Orion's Tom Wilson on delivering coordinated, high-touch service in a world where returns alone no longer set you apart.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today's choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.