Should advisors bet on another big year for BDCs?

Should advisors bet on another big year for BDCs?
The S&P 500 BDC Total Return Index increased 27.6 percent in 2023, with about half of that return coming from capital appreciation.
FEB 21, 2024

Advisors who bet on business development companies in 2023 turned out to be big winners. The question now is whether they should take some money off the table in case adverse economic forces weigh on these high-yielding investments.

BDCs blend attributes of publicly traded companies and closed-end funds, giving holders exposure to high-yielding, private equity-like investments. As a result of those higher yields, however, BDCs also tend to carry additional risk and can sell off quickly. BDCs primarily invest in the debt of small to midsize domestic companies, a strategy that has become all the rage of late as more advisors seek exposure to private credit. 

That strategy paid off last year, with the S&P 500 BDC Total Return Index increasing by an impressive 27.6 percent, with about half of that return coming from capital appreciation.

Credit rating agency Fitch wrote in a report last November that it expects net investment income and dividend coverage for BDCs to remain relatively strong in 2024 despite “weakening asset-quality metrics and increased debt-service costs resulting from higher interest rates for borrowers.” And so far that has remained the case, with the S&P 500 BDC Total Return Index slightly higher year-to-date.

John Cole Scott, chief investment officer at Closed-End Fund Advisors, agrees with that generally positive outlook, saying BDCs' prospects and debt coverage remain strong.

“A lot of the BDCs leverage is fixed and a lot of its loans are variable,” said Scott. “The coverage right now for the average BDC for their dividend policy is almost 130 percent, so we expect less increases. There's a lot of coverage for increased cost of leverage or lower cost of loans if they trend lower.”

As for his top picks in the BDC space, Scott recommends CION Investment Corp. (CION) and Trinity Capital (TRIN).

“CION is a direct-listed large BDC trading at about a 30 percent discount to its NAV, a 12 percent yield, and leverage around 54 percent. It’s basically still hurting from that direct listing and the generally wide discounts when that happens,” Scott said. “Trinity Capital is internally managed, trading at an 8 percent premium and 14 percent yield that's covered. It's a much different fund but they're both attractive uncovered gems in our opinion.”

Scott is also bullish on municipal bond closed-end funds, especially for those investors with high federal taxes to pay, saying the funds are poised to bounce back after a rough 2023, when they saw heightened selling and widening discounts toward year-end.

“We don't know the timing, but right now there is a great opportunity for the historic wide discounts to narrow,” he said, adding that concerns over the leverage found in many closed-end funds tend to be “more hype than reality.”

In terms of specific closed-end fund picks, Scott suggests the Pioneer Municipal High Income Opportunities Fund (MIO), which was yielding 5.4 percent at last check, and the abrdn National Municipal Income Fund (VFL), yielding 4.4 percent.

As to the potential effects of interest rate cuts on closed-end funds which some say are likely on tap for later this year, Rob Shaker, chief investment strategist for Shaker Financial Services, says bond closed-end funds should be able to effectively weather rate movements in either direction as a result of their unique structure. 

“While many investors fear investing in bond funds in a rising-rate environment, the fixed capital structure of closed-end funds allows the funds the opportunity to hold through duration without incurring any unnecessary penalties due to short-term dislocations,” he said.

“And when rates fall, CEFs get a double benefit as the movements will not only benefit bond pricings and the fund's day-to-day net asset value, but will also reduce the fund's leverage expenses,” Shaker added.

Tony Robbins explains how to profit from real estate, energy and sports teams

Latest News

Add Commonwealth Financial – a blockbuster – to the list of potential LPL targets
Add Commonwealth Financial – a blockbuster – to the list of potential LPL targets

Chatter about LPL, a behemoth, buying Commonwealth Financial Network, a boutique, has been building all week.

Younger Americans are changing the dynamics of IRAs
Younger Americans are changing the dynamics of IRAs

Millennials, Gen Zs are not following the preferences of older generations.

How does your schedule stack up against a typical advisor?
How does your schedule stack up against a typical advisor?

Report reveals how advisors in RIAs, broker-dealers split their time.

Global stock selloff continues into a third day
Global stock selloff continues into a third day

Tariffs are the focus as risk aversity intensifies.

Gold sets new record at $3,077 as trade war fears rise
Gold sets new record at $3,077 as trade war fears rise

Havens are in demand as investors weigh likely impact of tariffs.

SPONSORED Retirement plan balances are flourishing. Why are so many advisors missing out on a $3 trillion opportunity?

Participants who receive professional 401(k) advice see higher returns on average, net, than those who don't.

SPONSORED Focus on clients, not compliance – why Gary Corderman found his fit with Farther

This wealth management platform finally delivers on the technology promises other firms couldn't - giving advisors a better way to scale and serve