Fed must remain independent to be effective, warns CIO

Fed must remain independent to be effective, warns CIO
Mark Malek, Ed Cofrancesco
After Fed Chair Jerome Powell goes on the offensive, wealth managers weigh up potential consequences of Department of Justice investigation.
JAN 12, 2026

Wealth managers are weighing the potential consequences of President Trump's legal campaign against Federal Reserve chair Jerome Powell.

In a statement late Sunday, Powell said that the Department of Justice served the Federal Reserve with grand jury subpoenas, threatening a criminal indictment relating to the testimony he gave to the Senate Banking Committee last June over the renovation of historic Federal Reserve office buildings.

Officially, the investigation concerns what the Trump administration has called the "grossly mismanaged" $2.5 billion reconstruction project. Powell, however, claimed that the investigation was spurred by a different motive.

"This new threat is not about my testimony last June or about the renovation of the Federal Reserve buildings. It is not about Congress's oversight role; the Fed through testimony and other public disclosures made every effort to keep Congress informed about the renovation project. Those are pretexts. The threat of criminal charges is a consequence of the Federal Reserve setting interest rates based on our best assessment of what will serve the public, rather than following the preferences of the President," he said in his statement.  

Powell went on to say that the action was about whether the Fed would maintain its independence to set interest rates based on its economic assessments, or if monetary policy would be under political pressure or "intimidation." 

Powell has served at the Federal Reserve under four administrations, Republicans and Democrats alike. And while Powell’s term as chair ends in May, he can stay on as governor until 2028.

"In every case, I have carried out my duties without political fear or favor, focused solely on our mandate of price stability and maximum employment. Public service sometimes requires standing firm in the face of threats. I will continue to do the job the Senate confirmed me to do, with integrity and a commitment to serving the American people," Powell said.

For his part, Mark Malek, CIO at Siebert Financial, won’t specifically affirm that the subpoenas and threat of criminal prosecution against Chairman Powell are a Presidential ploy to manipulate the Fed, but he sincerely “hopes” that is not the case.

“The Fed must remain independent in order for the central bank to remain effective and this is important for the integrity of the US Dollar and the all-important Treasury markets to remain the world’s benchmarks. Full stop,” Malek said.

He points out that earlier this year bond and currency traders expressed concerns of a manipulated Fed by pushing yields higher and weakening the dollar.

“This latest move is looking like we will get a repeat,” added Malek.

Elsewhere, Seth Meyer, global head of client portfolio management & portfolio manager at Janus Henderson, believes this weekend’s news can be interpreted as a direct challenge to Fed independence, which markets have long assumed as a cornerstone of U.S. credibility. In Meyer’s opinion, Powell’s video response frames this as a fight over whether monetary policy will be driven by data or political pressure.

The investment implications are clearly “risk-off,” according to Meyer. In his view, actions like this could result in a “sell-America” trade similar to April 2025 where U.S. equities, and the dollar could come under pressure, as global investors demand a higher risk premium for U.S. assets. Safe havens are likely to rally under this scenario, while non-U.S. equities and emerging markets could benefit from relative flows.

“We maintain a favorable view on international diversification, and this event reinforces that stance. Near-term volatility will hinge on whether Congress or the Treasury Department can orchestrate another simmering down of the administration’s rhetoric,” Meyer said.

Meanwhile, Ed Cofrancesco, CEO of International Assets Advisory, highly doubts this latest kerfuffle between Trump and Powell will have much impact on the economy one way or another.

From a market perspective Cofrancesco was proven correct as the S&P 500 started the day deep in the red due to the Powell headlines, but the index turned slightly green by midday. Gold, meanwhile, rose over 2% as fears grew over the potential for further declines in the US Dollar.

“Now did anything he do cross into the line of criminality, I don’t know, but that’s why we have subpoenas and investigation.  Hopefully, the truth will come out in the end but like with so many other things that happen inside the beltway, probably not,” Confrancesco said.

Jim Carroll, senior wealth advisor and portfolio manager at Ballast Rock Private Wealth, calls the whole affair a "tempest in a teapot," primarily because Chair Powell will step down in May and the next Chair will have the President's stamp of approval. The more interesting twist, according to Carroll, relates to Powell's choice to leave the Fed completely or stay on as a Governor until 2028.

“We may find that the administration's efforts to pressure Powell result in him staying around longer,” Carroll said, adding that from an investment perspective, this episode does not change his view that broad diversification across geographies and asset classes will be “increasingly important against a backdrop of economic and geopolitical uncertainty."

Finally, Dr. Preston D. Cherry, founder & wealth Advisor at Concurrent Wealth, says political pressure on the Fed risks turning U.S. credibility into a “slow-burn issue.” Over time, he believes that can mean a weaker dollar, higher long-term yields, and U.S. assets quietly repriced as riskier.

“Markets are increasingly pricing political theatrics as a baseline condition rather than a shock. The danger isn’t volatility. It’s the normalization of pressure on independent institutions. When monetary policy starts to look political, markets don’t panic. They quietly reprice risk,” Cherry said.

Latest News

Newsom wants nationwide billionaires tax as presidential bid may loom on the horizon
Newsom wants nationwide billionaires tax as presidential bid may loom on the horizon

“It’s time for an economic reset,” wrote the California governor, in a post on X.

Maryland regulators spank fledgling art-focused RIA Masterworks over registration snafus
Maryland regulators spank fledgling art-focused RIA Masterworks over registration snafus

Masterworks was launched in 2017 but its RIA, Masterworks Advisers, is just three years old.

Investors allege Miami operator took over $1.5 million in EB-5 scheme
Investors allege Miami operator took over $1.5 million in EB-5 scheme

One 2017 form, no broker license, and a $42 million gap they say surfaced on a webinar.

Gen X, millennials lag in retirement confidence amid knowledge gap
Gen X, millennials lag in retirement confidence amid knowledge gap

Fewer than half of Americans in their peak earning years feel on track for retirement, while many say limited financial knowledge and access to professional guidance are holding them back.

Advisor moves: Veteran-led UBS team overseeing $460 million migrates to Merrill
Advisor moves: Veteran-led UBS team overseeing $460 million migrates to Merrill

Meanwhile, Wells Fargo hauled advisors overseeing $825 million in the West Coast, while Wedbush has welcomed a seasoned professional from Stifel in California.

SPONSORED Who builds the income when the pension disappears?

Dan Biagini of American Equity says the steady decline of pensions, longer lifespans and a reset in interest rates are rewriting how advisors build retirement income

SPONSORED Why direct indexing stopped being optional

Direct indexing is on pace to outgrow ETFs and mutual funds. Northern Trust's Ken Lassner explains why the advisors who get it wish they had started sooner.