Fossil fuel funds may outperform ESG for now, but not in long run, experts say

Fossil fuel funds may outperform ESG for now, but not in long run, experts say
Experts participating in the InvestmentNews ESG Summit assert that using ESG factors provides better insight on potential return.
DEC 01, 2022

Investment funds constructed using environmental, social and governance factors may be down for now, but will outperform over time, experts said Thursday.

Taking a broad view of ESG investing was one topic at the InvestmentNews ESG Summit. Senior columnist Jeff Benjamin opened that session by pointing out that the iShares energy exchange-traded fund that includes fossil fuels is up 70.96% through November, while an iShares clean energy ETF is down 2.76% over the same period.

Peter Krull, founder, chief executive and director of investments at Earth Equity Advisors, was nonplussed. “This is about investing long-term,” he said during the panel. “We are not speculating.”

While he was participating in the discussion, Krull dug up statistics to illustrate the benefit of the ESG approach over a longer horizon. He said that from 2010 to 2020, the Energy Select Sector SPDR Fund was down 33.5% while the QCLN clean energy fund was up 397%. Over that time frame, the S&P 500 was up 233.7%.

Krull called it the “lost decade” for fossil fuel investments. “That certainly dragged down the S&P.”

Elizabeth Levy, head of ESG strategy and portfolio at Trillium Asset Management, said the downturn for ESG funds is a short-term situation that shouldn’t discourage financial advisers from considering ESG factors for their clients’ portfolios.

“We don’t think that there is a structural reason that using ESG information means you would underperform over the long term,” Levy said during the panel. “We think that it helps lead to a more complete picture, which over time, over business cycles, will give us we believe stronger performance.”

One factor weighing down ESG funds in the current market is the emphasis on investing in value stocks rather than growth stocks, because there's less emphasis on sustainability among companies that fall in the value category, Krull said.

“That’s a big part of what we’re seeing, is the skewing of sustainable portfolios that are typically more on the growth side,” he said.

ESG is more about data than an investing style, Levy said. The motivation for investors to look at ESG factors is “they really care about these issues.”

But she was somewhat skeptical that funds and advisers are taking advantage of that enthusiasm to hoodwink their investors and clients about ESG strategies.

“A lot of the frustration and greenwashing claims is really just investors not understanding what kind of product they have,” Levy said.  “What that specific product is doing with the data … and what the outcome is.”

Krull cautioned against taking funds that promote ESG investing at face value.

“It comes down to due diligence and looking under the hood,” he said.

‘IN the Office’ with Nationwide retirement strategist Kristi Rodriguez

Latest News

'Bogged down' advisors just want to have fun (again)
'Bogged down' advisors just want to have fun (again)

Jim Cahn, of Wealth Enhancement Group, lifts the lid on his firm's partnership model, his views on RIA M&A, and the widely slept-on reason why advisors are merging into larger organizations.

Vestwell unveils new emergency savings account offering
Vestwell unveils new emergency savings account offering

The fintech firm is cementing its status in the workplace savings space with its latest ESA offering, which employers can integrate into their existing benefits package.

'Money Mimosas' and other ways to show your Valentine financial love
'Money Mimosas' and other ways to show your Valentine financial love

Wealth managers offer unique ideas for couples to grow closer emotionally and financially.

Limra research finds financial confidence on the rise among Black American workers
Limra research finds financial confidence on the rise among Black American workers

Survey findings suggest increased sense of financial security and more optimistic 2025 outlook, while highlighting employers' role in ensuring retirement readiness.

DOGE efforts sideswipe muni bonds backed by federal lease payments
DOGE efforts sideswipe muni bonds backed by federal lease payments

Falling prices for some securities within the $4 trillion state and local government debt market spotlight how the push to shrink spending is sending shockwaves across the US.

SPONSORED Record growth: Interval funds emerge as key players in alternative investments

Blue Vault Alts Summit highlights the role of liquidity-focused funds in reshaping advisor strategies

SPONSORED Taylor Matthews on what's behind Farther's rapid growth

From 'no clients' to reshaping wealth management, Farther blends tech and trust to deliver family-office experience at scale.