How nuns got Wells Fargo to address its ethical lapses

Group of investors withdraws a shareholder proposal after bank agrees to prepare report on root causes of its scandal.
MAR 06, 2018

Wells Fargo & Co. agreed to publicly report on the root causes that led to a rash of ethical lapses in recent years, a group of investors said. The group, led by the Interfaith Center on Corporate Responsibility and including about 20 religious organizations as well as state officials from Rhode Island and Connecticut, said Tuesday they would withdraw a shareholder proposal on the issue following the bank's decision. They had sought to put it to a vote at the lender's annual meeting in April. "They were in a culture where they believed their vision and values have carried them for the past 30 years and were continuing to carry them," said Sister Nora Nash, who oversees retirement funds for Sisters of St. Francis of Philadelphia, which led the proposal. "Obviously, there was tremendous risk in their culture, and we need to take a serious look at the code of ethics, accountability and really look at the needs of the customer and community." The investors asked Wells Fargo to produce evidence that its incentive programs are aligned with clients' interests. They also asked the lender to report on how it is strengthening risk management and controls to prevent such lapses.

'First Step'

"Wells Fargo has agreed to prepare and publish a business standards report on our website," Ancel Martinez, a spokesman for the San Francisco-based bank, said in an emailed statement. "We look forward to continuing to work with the members of the Interfaith Center on Corporate Responsibility." Rhode Island Treasurer Seth Magaziner, who oversees the state's public pension fund, called the bank's decision "a first step toward changing the culture at Wells Fargo that harmed a lot of customers and shareholders." Wells Fargo has yet to put behind it 18 months of scandal in its retail banking business, where employees under pressure to meet aggressive sales goals may have opened millions of accounts in customers' names without permission. The bank has said it's facing at least three major probes, including one by the U.S. Department of Justice. Separately, Well Fargo agreed this week to put a shareholder proposal on its proxy ballot from the New York State Common Retirement Fund that seeks more information about employee incentives beyond its executive officers, according to correspondence with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission.

Latest News

Advisor moves: UBS pries Merrill veteran loose as LPL adds $200M duo
Advisor moves: UBS pries Merrill veteran loose as LPL adds $200M duo

Raymond James lures a $125M Merrill Lynch advisor in Charlotte while a Stifel pair breaks away to go independent in Southern Oregon

People moves: Crestwood Advisors taps Morgan Stanley veteran as CIO
People moves: Crestwood Advisors taps Morgan Stanley veteran as CIO

Pave Finance, DPL Financial Partners and Gottfried & Somberg also add senior leaders as RIAs and wealthtech firms deepen their benches

Slice on purpose
Slice on purpose

What the feud between “twin” index funds teaches thematic investors

RIAs flag AI risk in Form ADV more often than they admit using AI
RIAs flag AI risk in Form ADV more often than they admit using AI

RIAs flag AI risk in Form ADV more often than they admit using AI

SEC sues eight fake advisor firms over $37m rotating crypto scheme
SEC sues eight fake advisor firms over $37m rotating crypto scheme

Fake advisors, fake platforms, fake crypto - all on a six-month timer

SPONSORED The new retirement challenge: Preparing for a longer future

Advisors are broadening the conversation beyond savings to help clients prepare for the realities of longer lives

SPONSORED Best Practices for Engaging Women Around Alternatives

Growing wealth, evolving priorities, and untapped opportunities are reshaping how women approach long-term investing.