Young investors have weakened their stance on ESG, study reveals

Young investors have weakened their stance on ESG, study reveals
Gen Z and millennials are less prepared to give up returns to meet their ideals.
DEC 12, 2023

Support for ESG has plummeted among Millennial and Gen Z investors, typically the strongest backers for environmental, social and governance-related issues, as a more turbulent financial outlook tempers enthusiasm, according to a survey from Stanford University and the Hoover Institution.

Less than half of millennial and Gen Z investors, those aged 41 and younger, said they were “very concerned” about environmental issues this year, down from 70% in 2022. That same group is now much less willing to give up market returns to meet their ideals, according to the survey of about 1,000 investors conducted this fall.

Higher borrowing costs helped spur a $30 billion slump in U.S. clean energy stocks over the past six months. Those companies had been seen as likely to flourish with passage of the Inflation Reduction Act, which promises billions of dollars for America’s switch to clean energy. 

“This last year was somewhat of a gut check,” said Amit Seru, one of the study’s authors and a professor at the Stanford Graduate School of Business and a member of the Hoover Institution working group on corporate governance. “When interest rates go up, inflation shoots up and people certainly grapple with reality.”

A few years ago, millennial and Gen Z investors were described by consultants as key drivers of the boom in ESG investing because of their concerns about climate change, as well as gender and racial inequalities. Conservative investors have led the criticisms against ESG, calling it “woke capitalism” that’s more focused on social concerns than generating profits.

It’s not clear whether the erosion of support is a blip or will be long-lasting, Seru said. The shift puts younger investors more in line with the older investors, those over 58, who continued to express very little concern about ESG topics, according to the survey. 

“You’re inherently more liberal when you’re just coming out of college,” said David Larcker, another author of the study and a professor at the Stanford Graduate School of Business. “All of a sudden the bills come due and you kinda go, ‘Yeah, we’re pro this, but we’re not gonna give up everything to push this forward.’”

Latest News

Supreme Court strengthens SEC power to claw back fraud profits from violators
Supreme Court strengthens SEC power to claw back fraud profits from violators

No investor losses? The SEC can still claw back every dollar of pro

Wirehouse moves: RBC nabs experienced Wells Fargo advisor in New England
Wirehouse moves: RBC nabs experienced Wells Fargo advisor in New England

Plus, Well Fargo hails May recruitment haul totaling more than $3 billion in assets, while UBS recruits a top advisor and women's champion from Lazard.

Robinhood Concierge for millionaire investors nears 60,000 clients
Robinhood Concierge for millionaire investors nears 60,000 clients

Robinhood’s invite-only Concierge unit now serves about 60,000 affluent customers with CFP access, tax planning, and estate planning resources as the retail brokerage expands further into wealth management.

Advisor360, Willow Wealth tap seasoned veterans for C-suite roles
Advisor360, Willow Wealth tap seasoned veterans for C-suite roles

The two wealthtech platforms name new C-level executives as AI-native strategy and private markets growth accelerate across the advice industry

Western Asset agrees to $100M SEC penalty over cherry-picking scheme
Western Asset agrees to $100M SEC penalty over cherry-picking scheme

Franklin Resources' fixed-income unit settles SEC charges and closes firm-level DOJ and regulatory probes, but Kenneth Leech's criminal case continues.

SPONSORED Estate planning isn't a service add-on. It's your retention strategy.

As $84 trillion prepares to change hands, advisors who treat estate planning as peripheral are quietly building a sieve, not a book.

SPONSORED Why strategy matters more than performance

In volatile markets, the advisors who win aren't the ones with the best calls - they're the ones whose clients stay the course.