Robo says investors want a human touch in retirement accounts

When it comes to 401(k) plans, people want to talk to people.
NOV 05, 2015
It turns out, people just want to talk to other people when it comes to their 401(k) accounts. A Financial Engines survey released on Tuesday found that of the 1,000 401(k) participants, 54% said they do not work with a financial adviser — but they'd like to in the future. There were three reasons investors weren't already working with an adviser: 46% said it had to do with affordability, 36% said they didn't have enough assets to get an adviser interested and 26% said they weren't sure advisers could help them. "You see all of this innovation but one constant remained throughout all of those: the financial adviser," said Kelly O'Donnell, executive vice president of Financial Engines. Financial Engines, one of the original robo-advisers and one geared toward retirement accounts, had noted that already. Last month, the digital advice platform, which has $104 billion in assets under management, announced it was adding more human advisers to its services, free of charge to all 401(k) participants. The offering is similar to the hybrid model used by Vanguard Personal Advisor Services or Personal Capital. The relationship between advisers and technology highlights the benefits of both sides of the partnership. Other firms, like Capital One, for example, see the perks of this model, too. Fred Barstein, founder and chief executive of the Retirement Advisor University, said these models will prove successful — especially if advisers can make it feel for investors as though there isn't any additional involvement with technology. "I don't think that droves and droves of people are going to want to get investment advice from computers, but I think there is a place for it," Mr. Barstein said. Survey respondents also said they value fiduciary standards. When asked about desirable qualities of an adviser, 69% said it was very important that their advisers be legally required to act in their best interests, while another 18% said it was somewhat important. Less than 2% said it was not very or at all important. Jamie Hopkins, associate professor of taxation and associate director of the New York Life Center for Retirement Income at the American College, said investors want advisers because they add value by talking clients through difficult situations, while the software adds value in the behind-the-scenes asset allocation. "People are going to continue to want the human adviser because a lot of the planning here is personal and relates to your specific situation," Mr. Hopkins said. Technology platforms are great, but "what it lacks is personalization." "That's what people want, especially during financial planning," he added.

Latest News

Bluespring Wealth snaps up $1.1B New Jersey RIA in fifth deal of 2026
Bluespring Wealth snaps up $1.1B New Jersey RIA in fifth deal of 2026

Synthesis Wealth Planning brings a fivefold asset growth story and a recently merged practice to the Bluespring fold.

Clients expect to know if you use AI, but don’t realize that their portfolios are likely exposed
Clients expect to know if you use AI, but don’t realize that their portfolios are likely exposed

Janus Henderson Investors research reveals demand for transparency, but lack of awareness of AI’s prevalence in the corporate world.

Retirement dream looking more like a luxury as cost-of-living squeezes savings
Retirement dream looking more like a luxury as cost-of-living squeezes savings

New research reveals rising expenses, forced early exits, and a widening gap between how long people live and how long their money lasts.

Advisor moves: LPL, Raymond James, Brighton Jones raid the talent pool
Advisor moves: LPL, Raymond James, Brighton Jones raid the talent pool

Firms continue their quest to attract and retain the best advisor teams.

Most advisors say AI portfolio construction is worth $500 a month
Most advisors say AI portfolio construction is worth $500 a month

A survey from TacticalMind AI found 69% of advisors say a high-quality AI platform that makes investment recommendations and constructs portfolios is worth $500 monthly, while research-only tools are valued closer to $250.

SPONSORED Beyond wealth management: Why the future of advice is becoming more human

As technical expertise becomes increasingly commoditized, advisors who can integrate strategy, relationships, and specialized expertise into a cohesive client experience will define the next era of wealth management

SPONSORED Durability over scale: What actually defines a great advisory firm

Growth may get the headlines, but in my experience, longevity is earned through structure, culture, and discipline