Writing on the wall for direct-to-consumer robo startups

Writing on the wall for direct-to-consumer robo startups
Client acquisition costs and increasing competition proved too much for Hedgeable.
JUL 16, 2018

The consolidation of direct-to-consumer robo-advisers is in full swing. Hedgeable, an early digital adviser that stood out for targeting wealthier clients with active management, hedging strategies and access to alternative investments like venture capital funds and cryptocurrency, announced last week that it will discontinue its investment management service on Aug. 9. The news comes just two months after Northwestern Mutual's decision to shut down LearnVest.​ In December, Amanda Steinberg closed WorthFM, a female-focused robo-adviser launched in 2015. The WorthFM website, which now directs users to Sallie Krawcheck's Ellevest, cites "industry shifts and our own business" as reasons it can no longer offer investment advice. The announcement from Hedgeable was surprising, but not entirely unexpected. Industry observers have long forecast doom for the direct-to-consumer startups not named Betterment and Wealthfront as banks, broker-dealers, asset managers, custodians and large RIAs all come out with their own version of digital advice. But what's driving the consolidation isn't a market downturn that causes investors to fearfully pull money out of their robo-adviser, as many predicted. Instead, venture-backed startups like Hedgeable simply haven't been able to carve out enough market share to remain sustainable, independent businesses. The biggest problem is, and has always been, client acquisition costs. Conservative estimates peg the cost per client at $100 for the startups. Michael Kitces, partner and director of wealth management at Pinnacle Advisory Group, estimates it could as high as $300, and he has been sounding this alarm since 2016. "You need a lot of money in order to be successful as a robo if you're not an incumbent firm, if you're not a broker-dealer and have an existing clientele." said Ken Schapiro, the president of Backend Benchmarking, a research firm that publishes a quarterly report on robo-adviser performance. "When [the startups] were originally funded, no one really knew that the client acquisition cost was going to be that high. And now there's a lot more competition; the incumbents all have [a robo-adviser]." (More: Robo-advisers offering incentives to attract new clients) Hedgeable raised a total of $1.9 million in funding (its most recent round was in November 2015) and turned that into 1,698 clients and $80 million in clients, according to its most recent Form ADV. Meanwhile, Betterment raised $275 million and manages $14 billion in client assets, while Wealthfront manages $10 billion after raising $204.5 million. The big two robos still pale in comparison to technology products offered at Charles Schwab and Vanguard, primarily because the companies have simply moved existing client assets to their digital platforms. As Wells Fargo, Merrill Lynch and Morgan Stanley all push out their own robo-advisers, they can simply offer the service through existing channels. (More: Wirehouses using digital advice technology to boost cross-selling) "Large firms can use it as a loss leader or part of a customer acquisition strategy," Mr. Schapiro said. "It's just another arrow in the quiver, and you're going to see more of them from the Goldmans of the world." Most of the other robos have either been purchased, like FutureAdvisor, or have pivoted toward a business-to-business model, like SigFig. Mr. Schapiro expects Wealthfront and Betterment are large enough to survive for a while, as well as hybrid robo-provider Personal Capital. But the writing is on the wall for other technology startups, and Hedgeable's closure should serve as a wake-up call. You're no longer the new tech on the block, and that VC funding will only go so far in buying you customers. I'm looking at you, WiseBanyan.

Latest News

SEC bars ex-broker who sold clients phony private equity fund
SEC bars ex-broker who sold clients phony private equity fund

Rajesh Markan earlier this year pleaded guilty to one count of criminal fraud related to his sale of fake investments to 10 clients totaling $2.9 million.

The key to attracting and retaining the next generation of advisors? Client-focused training
The key to attracting and retaining the next generation of advisors? Client-focused training

From building trust to steering through emotions and responding to client challenges, new advisors need human skills to shape the future of the advice industry.

Chuck Roberts, ex-star at Stifel, barred from the securities industry
Chuck Roberts, ex-star at Stifel, barred from the securities industry

"The outcome is correct, but it's disappointing that FINRA had ample opportunity to investigate the merits of clients' allegations in these claims, including the testimony in the three investor arbitrations with hearings," Jeff Erez, a plaintiff's attorney representing a large portion of the Stifel clients, said.

SEC to weigh ‘innovation exception’ tied to crypto, Atkins says
SEC to weigh ‘innovation exception’ tied to crypto, Atkins says

Chair also praised the passage of stablecoin legislation this week.

Brooklyn-based Maridea snaps up former LPL affiliate to expand in the Midwest
Brooklyn-based Maridea snaps up former LPL affiliate to expand in the Midwest

Maridea Wealth Management's deal in Chicago, Illinois is its first after securing a strategic investment in April.

SPONSORED How advisors can build for high-net-worth complexity

Orion's Tom Wilson on delivering coordinated, high-touch service in a world where returns alone no longer set you apart.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today's choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.