In the age of Trump, America's biggest foreign creditors are suddenly having second thoughts about financing the U.S. government.
In Japan, the largest holder of Treasuries, investors culled their stakes in December by the most in almost four years, the Ministry of Finance's most recent figures show. What's striking is the selling has persisted at a time when going abroad has rarely been so attractive. And it's not just the Japanese. Across the world, foreigners are pulling back from U.S. debt like never before.
From Tokyo to Beijing and London, the consensus is clear: Few overseas investors want to step into the $13.9 trillion U.S. Treasury market right now. Whether it's the prospect of bigger deficits and more inflation under President Donald J. Trump or higher interest rates from the Federal Reserve, the world's safest debt market seems less of a sure thing — particularly after the upswing in yields since November. And then there is Mr. Trump's penchant for saber rattling, which has made staying home that much easier.
“It may be more difficult than usual for Japanese to invest in Treasuries and the dollar this year because of political uncertainty,” said Kenta Inoue, chief strategist for overseas bond investments at Mitsubishi UFJ Morgan Stanley Securities in Tokyo. “Treasury yields may rise rapidly again in the near future, which will continue to discourage them from buying aggressively.”
Nobody is saying that foreigners will abandon Treasuries altogether. After all, they still hold $5.94 trillion, or roughly 43% of the U.S. government debt market. (Though that's down from 56% in 2008.) A significant drawdown can harm major holders like Japan and China as much as it does the U.S.
(More: Trump's DOL fiduciary directive triggers chaos)
And, of course, homegrown demand has of late been able to absorb the pickup in overseas selling. Since reaching 2.64% in mid-December, yields on benchmark 10-year notes have come back and are essentially flat this year. They were at 2.43% Monday.
LASTING CONSEQUENCES
Nevertheless, any consistent drop-off in foreign demand could have lasting consequences on America's ability to finance itself cheaply, particularly in light of Mr. Trump's ambitious plans to boost infrastructure spending, cut taxes and put “America First.” The president has singled out Japan and China, the two biggest overseas creditors, as well as Germany, for devaluing their currencies to gain an unfair advantage in trade.
In December, Japanese investors reduced their investments in U.S. debt by 2.39 trillion yen ($21.3 billion) after a smaller pullback in November. While only a fraction of Japan's $1.1 trillion of holdings, they were the first back-to-back declines since the start of 2014. China, which owns just over $1 trillion of Treasuries, has been selling since May. Its holdings are at a seven-year low.
(More: Where Donald Trump stands on top financial adviser issues)
For now, risk-averse bond buyers like Daiwa SB Investments's Shinji Kunibe are cutting back on Treasuries, despite some clear advantages.
Like many institutional money managers that invest abroad, Mr. Kunibe, Daiwa SB's head of fixed-income management, likes to hedge away the risk of the dollar's ups and downs. And right now, it makes sense. After accounting for hedging costs, 10-year Treasuries yield about 0.9%, roughly 10 times the return offered by Japanese government bonds. Going back to the 1980s, Treasuries have rarely enjoyed such a big edge over JGBs.
However, he sees U.S. yields rising further as Mr. Trump pursues expansionary fiscal policies and takes a protectionist stance on trade.
“Yields are going to be in an uptrend,” he said.
BIG LOSSES
And investors like Mr. Kunibe can ill-afford more losses. Last quarter, Japanese investors who hedged all their dollar exposure in Treasuries suffered a 4.7% loss — the biggest in at least three decades, data from
Bank of America showed. The same thing happened in Europe, where record currency-hedged losses also stung euro-based buyers.
“It was a deer in the headlights moment,” said Zoltan Pozsar, a research analyst at
Credit Suisse.
Combined with
the unpredictability of Mr. Trump's tweet storms, interest-rate increases in the U.S. could further sap overseas demand. Mark Dowding, who helps oversee about $50 billion as co-head of investment-grade debt at BlueBay Asset Management in London, said the firm has already moved to insulate itself from further losses due to higher rates.
What's more, central bankers in Japan and Europe are still experimenting with monetary policies that may benefit bond investors locally.
Right now, it's just “much easier to stay home than go abroad,” said Shyam Rajan, Bank of America's head of U.S. rates strategy.
