Georgia court refuses to dismiss 401(k) suit, citing SCOTUS Northwestern decision

Georgia court refuses to dismiss 401(k) suit, citing SCOTUS Northwestern decision
The case filed against the Columbus Regional Health System cited breaches similar to those alleged in the Northwestern case, such as offering retail share classes of mutual funds instead of lower-cost institutional shares.
JAN 31, 2022

A federal district court in Georgia refused to dismiss a 401(k) lawsuit filed against the Columbus Regional Healthcare System, and it cited the Supreme Court's ruling last week in Hughes v. Northwestern University in its decision.

The Supreme Court overturned a lower court's dismissal of the lawsuit against Northwestern, ruling that the lower court had put too much weight on the Northwestern plans’ inclusion of some low-cost options as a sign that the plans' fiduciaries abided by their duties under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act.

The lawsuit filed against the North Carolina-based Columbus Regional Healthcare System also cited breaches of the organization's fiduciary duties to its retirement plan similar to those alleged in the Northwestern case, including offering the retail share classes of mutual funds instead of identical, but lower-cost, institutional shares; selecting and retaining underperforming funds; and overpaying for record-keeping services.

In its decision, the Georgia court “also rejected defendant’s argument that plaintiffs’ claims should be dismissed in part because the plan offered a variety of investment options that participants could select, including lower-cost passive investment options,” according to a blog from the Proskauer law firm. “The district court explained that Hughes rejected this exact argument in holding that a fiduciary’s decisions are not insulated merely by giving participants choice over their investments and that fiduciaries have a continuing duty to monitor plan investments.”

Latest News

Raymond James, Osaic laud new bank partnerships
Raymond James, Osaic laud new bank partnerships

A Texas-based bank selects Raymond James for a $605 million program, while an OSJ with Osaic lures a storied institution in Ohio from LPL.

Bessent backpedals after blowback on 'privatizing Social Security' comments
Bessent backpedals after blowback on 'privatizing Social Security' comments

The Treasury Secretary's suggestion that Trump Savings Accounts could be used as a "backdoor" drew sharp criticisms from AARP and Democratic lawmakers.

Alternative investment winners and losers in wake of OBBBA
Alternative investment winners and losers in wake of OBBBA

Changes in legislation or additional laws historically have created opportunities for the alternative investment marketplace to expand.

Financial advisors often see clients seeking to retire early; Here's what they tell them
Financial advisors often see clients seeking to retire early; Here's what they tell them

Wealth managers highlight strategies for clients trying to retire before 65 without running out of money.

Robinhood beats Q2 profit estimates as business goes beyond YOLO trading
Robinhood beats Q2 profit estimates as business goes beyond YOLO trading

Shares of the online brokerage jumped as it reported a surge in trading, counting crypto transactions, though analysts remained largely unmoved.

SPONSORED How advisors can build for high-net-worth complexity

Orion's Tom Wilson on delivering coordinated, high-touch service in a world where returns alone no longer set you apart.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today's choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.