Regulatory turf war brewing over indexed annuities?

Regulatory turf war brewing over indexed annuities?
Fine issued by Illinois securities cops over sale of fixed annuities raises questions of jurisdiction; others say no conflict exists
OCT 12, 2011
State regulators say that securities regulators in Illinois were operating within their jurisdiction when they punished two investment adviser representatives for allegedly moving clients into “unsuitable” investments. A recent order from the office of Secretary of State Jesse White revoked the securities registrations of Thomas N. Cooper and Susan B. Cooper, a married couple who are both IARs and insurance licensed. The two, along with their practice, Senior Financial Strategies Inc., were also prohibited from offering or selling securities in Illinois. The Coopers were fined $10,000 following an investigation of 12 cases involving clients who had allegedly liquidated annuities or individual retirement accounts to fund the purchase of fixed indexed annuities from Aviva USA, according to Mr. White’s order. In that group of cases, the 12 investors were saddled with a total of $122,630 in surrender charges after liquidating their annuities, according to the order. The Coopers’ attorney, Tom Kelty of the Kelty Law Office, argued that the Illinois Securities Department had no business regulating a product that would otherwise be under the jurisdiction of the state’s insurance department. “I say they have no real basis for going after the Coopers,” Mr. Kelty said. He cited as his primary point of contention a paragraph in the order that says “each of the above investment plans is an investment contract and is therefore a security.” Mr. Kelty contends that for the securities regulator to punish the Coopers, the agency had to conclude the insurance product is a security. Otherwise, he said, “they have no case and no basis for issuing this order.” Some members of the insurance industry, particularly the indexed annuity industry,” are watching the case with interest, said Jack Marrion, president of Advantage Compendium Ltd. He noted that this wasn’t the first time the securities department in the state had punished an insurance agent: In January, the department barred an agent who sold fixed indexed annuities from selling securities in the state after he failed to respond to a series of inquiry letters from the department. But regulators claim the latest order is hardly a sign of a turf war over indexed annuities. “I see this as a case against a producer — an investment adviser — and they violated the fiduciary responsibility,” said James R. Mumford, first deputy commissioner in Iowa’s insurance division and its securities administrator. “It has nothing to do with the issue as to whether indexed annuities are securities or not.” State law in Illinois subjected the Coopers to a fiduciary duty as registered investment advisers and IARs. The transactions were found to be neither suitable nor in the clients’ best interests because of their age and the surrender fees, the order said. “It doesn’t matter if they sold insurance, a [certificate of deposit] or telephones,” Mr. Mumford said. “It’s a violation of fiduciary duty.” The Illinois Securities Department said those who questioned its authority in the case are missing the point. “To make this an issue on whether indexed annuities are securities or not is going beyond what the order states,” said David Finnigan, senior enforcement attorney for the department. “That wasn’t an issue in the hearing or the order.” He reiterated that the regulators took action because the Coopers were IARs. Currently, the Coopers are still licensed with the state insurance department. Anjali Julka, spokeswoman for the Illinois Insurance Department, declined to comment on the case. Kim O’Brien, executive director of the National Association for Fixed Annuities, noted while some might suspect an unseemly motive for the regulators’ action — be it political or motivated by revenue — this doesn’t seem to be the case with the Coopers’ order. “This isn’t an attempt to bring in indexed annuities under their wing,” said Ms. O’Brien. “I think it’s less of a turf war and more to protect the consumer.”

Latest News

SEC bars ex-broker who sold clients phony private equity fund
SEC bars ex-broker who sold clients phony private equity fund

Rajesh Markan earlier this year pleaded guilty to one count of criminal fraud related to his sale of fake investments to 10 clients totaling $2.9 million.

The key to attracting and retaining the next generation of advisors? Client-focused training
The key to attracting and retaining the next generation of advisors? Client-focused training

From building trust to steering through emotions and responding to client challenges, new advisors need human skills to shape the future of the advice industry.

Chuck Roberts, ex-star at Stifel, barred from the securities industry
Chuck Roberts, ex-star at Stifel, barred from the securities industry

"The outcome is correct, but it's disappointing that FINRA had ample opportunity to investigate the merits of clients' allegations in these claims, including the testimony in the three investor arbitrations with hearings," Jeff Erez, a plaintiff's attorney representing a large portion of the Stifel clients, said.

SEC to weigh ‘innovation exception’ tied to crypto, Atkins says
SEC to weigh ‘innovation exception’ tied to crypto, Atkins says

Chair also praised the passage of stablecoin legislation this week.

Brooklyn-based Maridea snaps up former LPL affiliate to expand in the Midwest
Brooklyn-based Maridea snaps up former LPL affiliate to expand in the Midwest

Maridea Wealth Management's deal in Chicago, Illinois is its first after securing a strategic investment in April.

SPONSORED How advisors can build for high-net-worth complexity

Orion's Tom Wilson on delivering coordinated, high-touch service in a world where returns alone no longer set you apart.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today's choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.