Clients using social media for advice likely to getting misinformation most of the time

Clients using social media for advice likely to getting misinformation most of the time
An analysis of financial advice shows high levels of bad information.
OCT 28, 2024

Younger Americans are the most likely to be using social media for information on investments and other financial advice and this approach is frequently risky.

A new analysis of social media video posts relating to investing in equities highlights just what a ‘wild west’ major platforms are in this regard, with users attracted by hashtags promising the next big stock pick.

Social Capital Markets looked at more than 2,700 stock-related videos on YouTube, TikTok, and Instagram and found a startling level of misinformation and lack of basic messaging around claims being made.

More than eight in ten videos omitted disclaimers informing viewers of the risks of investing, while seven in ten did not give context to the specific stock investments they were recommending and again, often without warning of the risks.

Worryingly, almost six in ten videos promised guaranteed returns and 45% suggested a specific proportion of income should be invested.

The analysis also found that just 13% of the videos were from sources with the relevant qualifications or credentials to offer financial advice.

The report reveals that 91% of the TikTok videos included lacked disclaimers along with 88% of those on Instagram and 76% of the YouTube videos.  For encouraging particular stock purchases, YouTube was the worst with 75%, followed by TikTok (70%) and Instagram (65%).

Overall, TikTok is deemed the worst with a higher rate of videos promising guaranteed returns and recommending specific percentages of income should be invested.

The study was conducted by a team led by Sudhir Khatwani who has made significant contributions as a Programmer Analyst at Cognizant, where he worked on critical projects for leading financial institutions like MUFG and CITI Bank.

Latest News

Advisors targeted in ‘pretexting’ phishing scam impersonating SEC
Advisors targeted in ‘pretexting’ phishing scam impersonating SEC

Financial services compliance consultant ACA Group told InvestmentNews it had four clients report receiving emails that impersonated David Bottom, the SEC's chief information officer, with smaller firms being targeted.

'Independence Stories': Show conviction and clients will make the transition
'Independence Stories': Show conviction and clients will make the transition

Financial advisor Derek Wittjohann shares the lessons he learned after leaving a major wirehouse to set up his own practice in the second installment of InvestmentNews' new 'Independence Stories' series.

Building a legacy that lasts: why succession planning needs to start on day one
Building a legacy that lasts: why succession planning needs to start on day one

Whether a firm manages $50 million or $5 billion in client assets, building a succession strategy needs to be a priority at least a decade out from retirement.

Ex-Pennsylvania RIA hit with 8-year sentence over $23M client fraud
Ex-Pennsylvania RIA hit with 8-year sentence over $23M client fraud

The former investment advisor misled clients in a decade-long scheme to fund international travel expenses, country club fees, and other personal expenses, according to three government agencies.

SPONSORED How advisors can build for high-net-worth complexity

Orion's Tom Wilson on delivering coordinated, high-touch service in a world where returns alone no longer set you apart.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today's choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.