Financial firms' war for wallet share intensifies with households cutting ties

Financial firms' war for wallet share intensifies with households cutting ties
Report finds loyalty, trust increasingly important as retail consumers and millionaire households reduce their savings and investing relationships.
JAN 16, 2025

As everyday Americans reduce their savings and investing relationships for the first time in over a decade, financial firms must work harder to maintain loyalty and trust among their customers. 

That's the key insight from a new report by Hearts & Wallets, which found American households cut back the number of retail financial services firms they work with for the first time since 2013.

In a report titled "Industry Performance Metrics: Competitive Penetration, Share and Loyalty Measures as Consumers Consolidate," the market intelligence firm highlighted a drop in the percentage of households using four or more firms – from 25 percent in 2023 to 20 percent in 2024. Along with that was an 8 percent decline in total saving and investing relationships across all households, falling from 351 million in 2023 to 323 million in 2024.

"With intensifying competition for the $78 trillion controlled by the 131 million households in the US, it’s more important than ever to monitor consumer behavior and competitive buying patterns,” Laura Varas, CEO and founder of Hearts & Wallets, said in a statement revealing the findings.

The study noted a corresponding rise in the average share of wallet (SOW) per firm, which increased from 37 percent in 2023 to 39 percent in 2024, the first uptick in five years. Among households with $5 million or more in investable assets, SOW climbed 4 percentage points year over year, reaching 28 percent. These affluent households also reduced the number of firms they use, with only 17 percent working with six or more firms in 2024, down from 23 percent the prior year.

The report found a link between integration, the ability to serve households with both products and stores, and a firm's leadership position. In last year's leaderboard for household penetration, the report said Fidelity and JPMorgan Chase, both of which offer investment products and services, gained ground but didn't catch up to Merrill, which narrowly kept its lead. Looking at share of household assets, Fidelity led the way while Merrill and Schwab were tied for second place.

Given the trend of consumers consolidating their relationships, the report said customer loyalty and trust are emerging as crucial competitive differentiators. Edward Jones and Vanguard earned top marks for loyalty and high trust, according to the report. LPL and Fidelity also stood out for strong scores across those metrics.

“Robinhood is a good example of how primacy, loyalty and trust metrics can reveal important competitive data,” said Amber Katris, a subject matter expert at Hearts & Wallets. “Only 46 percent of Robinhood customers entrust the firm as one of their primary or secondary stores, below the industry average of 63 percent. Yet, among those who do, 54 percent are highly likely to invest more.”

Latest News

Osaic discloses conflict tied to overlapping Envestnet ownership
Osaic discloses conflict tied to overlapping Envestnet ownership

Osaic’s Form ADV says majority owner Reverence Capital’s stake in Envestnet gives the firm and its advisors an incentive to recommend Envestnet programs. Reverence and Bain Capital backs both firms.

IRS hands down final auto enrollment rules for new 401(k), 403(b) plans
IRS hands down final auto enrollment rules for new 401(k), 403(b) plans

Treasury’s final SECURE 2.0 regulations give plan sponsors flexibility, though Vanguard calls for existing plans to face the mandate too

Embattled Nvidia faces SEC probe as California attorney general mulls action
Embattled Nvidia faces SEC probe as California attorney general mulls action

Regulators zero in on disclosures after Jensen Huang’s exit, while ETF data shows how deeply the fallout reaches client portfolios

FINRA penalizes Spartan Capital $3.18 million, charges pre-IPO fraud, Reg BI violations
FINRA penalizes Spartan Capital $3.18 million, charges pre-IPO fraud, Reg BI violations

Meanwhile, Spartan’s owner and former CEO John Lowry was suspended from the securities industry for two years.

Advisor moves: &Partners lands $1.3B multigenerational team as Merrill adds $1.7B
Advisor moves: &Partners lands $1.3B multigenerational team as Merrill adds $1.7B

Merrill recruits from UBS, Morgan Stanley and Edward Jones as an Oklahoma credit union moves its $430M wealth program to Ameriprise

SPONSORED The new retirement challenge: Preparing for a longer future

Advisors are broadening the conversation beyond savings to help clients prepare for the realities of longer lives

SPONSORED Best Practices for Engaging Women Around Alternatives

Growing wealth, evolving priorities, and untapped opportunities are reshaping how women approach long-term investing.