Independent advisers are not gig workers

Independent advisers are not gig workers
Let’s hope that by skillful lobbying, thoughtful consideration or through sheer dumb luck, financial advisers can stay independent.
OCT 24, 2022

Financial advisers — as well as others who want to remain independent contractors and not become employees — should be free to choose the work model they prefer. That’s our message to the Department of Labor after it published a proposed rule in the Federal Register on Oct. 13 that would make it more difficult for employers to designate workers as independent contractors. 

As InvestmentNews’ Mark Schoeff Jr. reported, Labor Secretary Marty Walsh said the regulation is designed to combat the misclassification of employees as independent contractors, which “deprives workers of their federal labor protections, including their right to be paid their full, legally earned wages.”

It’s commendable and understandable that the Labor Department wants to protect workers who are performing the same work under the same conditions and following the same mandates as company employees, but whom employers deem independent contractors. It’s obvious to everyone except lawyers and lobbyists that most of the independent contractors in that position would rather be employees but continue working as independent contractors because they have little alternative; the companies employing them won’t hire them because they wish to save money on benefits and to show investors how lean they are. 

Financial advisers should be free to choose the work model they prefer.

But what about workers who don’t want benefits, who don’t want to be employees, who have the freedom to come and go as they please and do their work in any way they choose, and want to keep it that way? In short, why impose employee status on those who truly want to remain independent contractors?

The DOL proposal wouldn’t take away those freedoms directly, but it would rescind a Trump administration independent-contractor rule that was upheld by a federal court when the Biden administration tried to vacate it. As reported, the Trump approach gives greater weight to whether a worker exercises control over job duties and profit and loss of the operation. The Biden proposal would “restore the multifactor, totality-of-the-circumstances analysis” to determine whether a worker is an independent contractor under federal labor law, according to a DOL statement. Those in favor of maintaining the current rule believe the change would lead to greater restrictions on workplace choice.

In the past, when independent-contractor rules were the subject of legislative and regulatory discussion, advisory industry trade groups including the National Association of Insurance and Financial Advisors and the Financial Services Institute were able to negotiate carve-outs for independent financial advisers. They will try to do so again. Legal action against the Department of Labor is not out of the question either. 

The issue probably will wind up bouncing back into the hands of Congress, where agreeing on something in a commonsense way is never easy. In today’s hyper-partisan world, where compromise is seen as moral weakness, getting Republicans and Democrats to agree on a subject as arcane to most of the public (including members of Congress) as independent registered representatives is probably impossible.

Let’s hope that by skillful lobbying, thoughtful consideration by everyone involved or through sheer dumb luck, independent financial advisers can stay that way. 

'IN the Office' with alternatives and BDC specialist Michael Reisner

Latest News

The fight over the CFPB is just beginning
The fight over the CFPB is just beginning

Locked out of their offices and told to stay home, employees at the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau have asked the courts to intervene as Elon Musk and Republican leaders move to shut down the agency that was established to protect people from predatory lending and financial scams.

Business-focused wealth tech RISR lands $8B Wealthcare Capital Management partnership
Business-focused wealth tech RISR lands $8B Wealthcare Capital Management partnership

Fintech platform interVal has also introduced a new feature to help advisors support entrepreneurial business owner clients better.

LPL boosts revenue potential with amped-up alts platform
LPL boosts revenue potential with amped-up alts platform

Along with greater revenue, alternative investments also carry risks, one industry lawyer noted.

How SageSpring Wealth Partners' next-gen strategy has fueled its success
How SageSpring Wealth Partners' next-gen strategy has fueled its success

President Jeff Dobyns unpacks the strategic power of mentorship, what makes an "ideal team player," and how the firm's 89 percent success rate has paid off for veteran advisors.

Powell heads for hot-seat hearings with ongoing pressure from Trump policies
Powell heads for hot-seat hearings with ongoing pressure from Trump policies

The Fed chair is in for some "hyper-charged" meetings, with legislators likely to raise questions on tariff threats and apparent steps to comply with anti-DEI orders.

SPONSORED Taylor Matthews on what's behind Farther's rapid growth

From 'no clients' to reshaping wealth management, Farther blends tech and trust to deliver family-office experience at scale.

SPONSORED Why wealth advisors should care about the future of federal tax policy

Blue Vault features expert strategies to harness for maximum client advantage.