ERISA lawsuit roundup: Court backs ADP (again), Mutual of America settles

ERISA lawsuit roundup: Court backs ADP (again), Mutual of America settles
Mutual of America agreed to settle an ERISA excessive fee lawsuit filed by 401(k) participants last week.
APR 05, 2023

Mutual of America agreed to settle an ERISA excessive fee lawsuit filed by 401(k) participants last week. The preliminary settlement notice filed Friday in a U.S. District Court in New York did not reveal the terms of the settlement.

The plaintiffs alleged in a complaint filed last September that Mutual of America caused plan participants to pay excessive administrative fees by “using its own proprietary recordkeeping platform and by failing to monitor or control the Plan’s administrative expenses.”

The court ordered the plaintiffs to file their unopposed motion for preliminary approval of the settlement by April 14 for a hearing on the motion scheduled for June 6 in New York City.

Elsewhere, an ERISA lawsuit filed against ADP Inc. by a company that participates in the ADP TotalSource Retirement Savings Plan was dismissed by a federal judge in Newark, New Jersey, last week.

According to a filing Friday, the court backed ADP's motion for dismissal against McCaffree Financial Corp. of Overland Park, Kansas, saying the plaintiff “failed to sufficiently plead constitutional standing.”

The case was originally brought in May 2020 with plaintiffs claiming ADP caused the plan to pay excessive record-keeping fees to Voya Institutional Plan Services, the plan’s record keeper since 2013. The case was dismissed last April after the court found the participating employer was not a fiduciary with respect to the allegations in the lawsuit. The latest dismissal involved an amended version of the complaint.

In its ruling, the Court held that the amended complaint provided "no information suggesting  that  McCaffree invested in any of the challenged investment options. In fact, the Amended Complaint contains no details as to McCaffree’s specific investments.”

Floating-rate loans are the perfect antidote for a hawkish Fed

Latest News

Most investors are still positioned for the old environment
Most investors are still positioned for the old environment

Matthew Klein on Rethinking Portfolios in a New Era.

Financial dependence on parents persists as retirement concerns grow, Northwestern Mutual finds
Financial dependence on parents persists as retirement concerns grow, Northwestern Mutual finds

As retirement costs climb, millions of millennials and Generation X adults continue relying on parental support, highlighting obstacles to retirement readiness. 

Former Detroit Tigers prospect moves from Edward Jones to LPL
Former Detroit Tigers prospect moves from Edward Jones to LPL

Les Smith, who once played alongside future MLB stars Eugenio Suárez and Nick Castellanos, says lessons from professional baseball helped fuel his transition to independent wealth management after 11 years at Edward Jones.

Mariner discloses cloud breach impacting nearly 9,000 individuals
Mariner discloses cloud breach impacting nearly 9,000 individuals

A November hacking incident involving cloud apps used by three employee exposed names, Social Security numbers, and other account data, the mega-RIA said.

Merrill broker, whose name was in the Epstein files, has left the firm: Reports
Merrill broker, whose name was in the Epstein files, has left the firm: Reports

Paul V. Morris worked at multiple firms across Wall Street and most recently in Manhattan for Merrill Lynch.

SPONSORED Estate planning isn't a service add-on. It's your retention strategy.

As $84 trillion prepares to change hands, advisors who treat estate planning as peripheral are quietly building a sieve, not a book.

SPONSORED Why strategy matters more than performance

In volatile markets, the advisors who win aren't the ones with the best calls - they're the ones whose clients stay the course.