SEC rules will make Treasuries market safer, but may cut trading volumes as costs rise

SEC rules will make Treasuries market safer, but may cut trading volumes as costs rise
Market participants give view on fast-approaching mandatory central clearing.
SEP 05, 2024

The Securities and Exchange Commission announced in December 2023 that it was bolstering risk management practices for the US Treasury market. But as implementation approaches, how do market participants view its impact?

The adoption of rules updating the membership standards required of covered clearing agencies for the US Treasury market with respect to a member’s clearance and settlement of specified secondary market transactions was welcomed by SEC chair Gary Gensler at the time.

“The $26 trillion Treasury market — the deepest, most liquid market in the world — is the base upon which so much of our capital markets are built,” he said. “Having such a significant portion of the Treasury markets uncleared — 70 to 80 percent of the Treasury funding market and at least 80 percent of the cash markets — increases system-wide risk.”

The final rules make changes to enhance customer clearing and broaden the scope of which transactions clearinghouse members must clear.

The first phase of adoption comes into effect by March 2025, including changes regarding the separation of house and customer margin, the broker-dealer customer protection rule, and access to central clearing required to be completed. Further changes will be implemented in 2026.

MARKET PARTICIPANTS

In a report published this week, Coalition Greenwich said that experts from market participants have tried to predict the impact of the new regulations and debated the potential pros and cons for all sides since the rules were adopted in December 2023.

Some of the most influential firms in the market including four of the top five Treasury dealers by revenue, the largest pension funds, asset managers and hedge funds in the world by assets, and some of the largest non-bank Treasury market liquidity providers, were interviewed for the report.

More than 70% of respondents believe that trading costs will increase as a result of the changes, specifically new margin requirements and clearing fees. Most (85%) expect that costs will force them to reduce trading activity.

However, it’s expected that dealers and trading venues will see benefits from the changes while hedge funds and non-bank liquidity providers will be negatively impacted, which may improve competition.

“Despite the expected increase in costs, the majority of respondents believe that clearing will make the market safer and more resilient in times of stress, reducing systemic risk and contagion risk,” says Kevin McPartland, Head of Research at Coalition Greenwich Market Structure & Technology and author of The Impact of Treasury and Repo Clearing Mandates: The Industry View. “This aligns with the SEC’s goal in implementing the clearing rule.”

Latest News

Most investors are still positioned for the old environment
Most investors are still positioned for the old environment

Matthew Klein on Rethinking Portfolios in a New Era.

Financial dependence on parents persists as retirement concerns grow, Northwestern Mutual finds
Financial dependence on parents persists as retirement concerns grow, Northwestern Mutual finds

As retirement costs climb, millions of millennials and Generation X adults continue relying on parental support, highlighting obstacles to retirement readiness. 

Former Detroit Tigers prospect moves from Edward Jones to LPL
Former Detroit Tigers prospect moves from Edward Jones to LPL

Les Smith, who once played alongside future MLB stars Eugenio Suárez and Nick Castellanos, says lessons from professional baseball helped fuel his transition to independent wealth management after 11 years at Edward Jones.

Mariner discloses cloud breach impacting nearly 9,000 individuals
Mariner discloses cloud breach impacting nearly 9,000 individuals

A November hacking incident involving cloud apps used by three employee exposed names, Social Security numbers, and other account data, the mega-RIA said.

Merrill broker, whose name was in the Epstein files, has left the firm: Reports
Merrill broker, whose name was in the Epstein files, has left the firm: Reports

Paul V. Morris worked at multiple firms across Wall Street and most recently in Manhattan for Merrill Lynch.

SPONSORED Estate planning isn't a service add-on. It's your retention strategy.

As $84 trillion prepares to change hands, advisors who treat estate planning as peripheral are quietly building a sieve, not a book.

SPONSORED Why strategy matters more than performance

In volatile markets, the advisors who win aren't the ones with the best calls - they're the ones whose clients stay the course.