New York court shoots down state's annuity best-interest rule

New York court shoots down state's annuity best-interest rule
The court found that the rule was unconstitutionally vague and gave the state too much latitude to find violations.
APR 29, 2021

A New York Court Thursday shot down the state’s relatively new “best interest” regulation for annuity and life insurance sales, ruling that it was too vague and gave the state too much latitude in finding violations.

In 2018, the state’s department of financial services issued Insurance Regulation 187 to the dismay of insurance companies and industry groups, which saw the potential for the rule to disrupt business substantially.

The regulation’s language was similar to that used in the now-defunct Obama-era fiduciary rule from the Department of Labor, establishing a uniform standard of care that required agents and brokers to act in the best interest of customers when recommending products. The annuity requirement took effect in 2019, while the life insurance component became effective last year.

Two different groups of plaintiffs, including the National Association of Insurance and Financial Advisers, sued the state agency in 2018 seeking to overturn the regulation, and the cases were consolidated. In 2019, the New York State Supreme Court upheld the best-interest regulation, finding that the department did not exceed its powers in establishing the rule and that it was neither arbitrary nor capricious.

But Thursday, in a big win for the insurance industry, that judgment was reversed by the New York Supreme Court Appellate Division. The standards in the state regulation are unconstitutionally vague, the court found.

The state has the option of appealing the decision to a higher court.

“While the consumer protection goals underlying promulgation of the amendment are laudable, as written, the amendment fails to provide sufficient concrete, practical guidance for producers to know whether their conduct, on a day-to-day basis, comports with the amendment's corresponding requirements for making recommendations and compiling and evaluating the relevant suitability information of the consumer,” the opinion read. “Although the amendment provides certain examples of what a recommendation does not include … the remaining definitional language is so broad that it is difficult to discern what statements producers could potentially make that would not be reasonably interpreted by the consumer to constitute advice regarding a potential sales transaction and therefore fall within the purview of the amendment.”

Further, the law’s ambiguous language and lack of clear standards gave the state “virtually unfettered discretion” to determine whether a broker or agent broke the law, the order stated.

Latest News

Advisor360 hires two execs, says LPL relationship continues after Commonwealth deal
Advisor360 hires two execs, says LPL relationship continues after Commonwealth deal

Advisor360, spun out of Commonwealth in 2019, adds two execs and is ‘excited to support LPL’ after the conversion

Pathstone’s venture bet put clients in Anthropic ahead of IPO
Pathstone’s venture bet put clients in Anthropic ahead of IPO

The multi-family office says its earliest participating funds invested in Anthropic at a $45 billion valuation, while the vast majority of its access came at $183 billion.

Senate passes elder fraud bill letting mutual funds pause redemptions
Senate passes elder fraud bill letting mutual funds pause redemptions

Financial Exploitation Prevention Act wins unanimous Senate approval as advisor groups press for White House signature

LPL and Ameriprise: Why can’t we be friends?
LPL and Ameriprise: Why can’t we be friends?

The two financial advice leaders announce a settlement to ongoing trade disputes involving financial advisors.

Veteran Indiana financial advisor at center of alleged $600 million Ponzi
Veteran Indiana financial advisor at center of alleged $600 million Ponzi

Phillip Patrick Williams allegedly launched the scheme in 2022 and eventually pocketed more than $100 million.

SPONSORED The new retirement challenge: Preparing for a longer future

Advisors are broadening the conversation beyond savings to help clients prepare for the realities of longer lives

SPONSORED Best Practices for Engaging Women Around Alternatives

Growing wealth, evolving priorities, and untapped opportunities are reshaping how women approach long-term investing.