Jury: Allianz used deceptive materials to market its two-tiered EIAs

A federal jury in Minnesota ruled last week that Allianz Life Insurance Company of North America used deceptive materials to market its two-tiered equity-indexed annuities, but declined to assess damages against the company, saying that the plaintiffs suffered no harm.
OCT 18, 2009
A federal jury in Minnesota ruled last week that Allianz Life Insurance Company of North America used deceptive materials to market its two-tiered equity-indexed annuities, but declined to assess damages against the company, saying that the plaintiffs suffered no harm. The class action was originally filed in 2006 in the U.S. District Court for the District of Minnesota on behalf of named plaintiff Linda L. Mooney, a 65-year-old retiree.

COMPLAINT

In the complaint, Ms. Mooney said that she paid $216,189 in premiums for an Allianz MasterDex 10 equity-indexed annuity. She claimed that she bought the product because Allianz had promised to pay her an upfront 10% premium bonus of about $21,600. Ms. Mooney claimed that the company's marketing materials were filled with industry jargon that made it difficult for her to understand the product fully. She claimed the documents clearly stated that she would receive this bonus. Traditional indexed annuities don't require annuitization in order to receive the indexed gains and premium bonuses. However, a two-tiered annuity — such as the one Ms. Mooney had — requires annuitization, and the policyholder can take the premium bonus and indexed gains only if the product is annuitized for a stated term after a specific deferral period. In its ruling, the jury concluded that Allianz had used a misrepresentation or deceptive practice in selling its two-tiered annuities and that it had intended that others would rely on its misrepresentation or deceptive practice, according to the -verdict. However, the jury also concluded that the plaintiffs weren't adversely affected as a result of these practices, and assessed no damages against the company.

REACTION

“We are very pleased that the jury concluded that no harm came to our policyholders,” Allianz Life president and chief executive Gary C. Bhojwani said in a statement.
“The jury made its decision, but hopefully we'll be able to get an injunction based on the findings that they used deceptive practices,” said plaintiff's attorney Karl L. Cambronne of Chestnut & Cambronne PA. “People will have a newfound level of understanding when they buy these products in the future.” The class action covered products that were purchased between Feb. 9, 2000, and May 10, 2007. In 2007, in a related matter, Minnesota Attorney General Lori Swanson took Allianz to court, accusing it of selling unsuitable annuities to seniors and alleging that the company failed to disclose adequately that the clients' savings and bonuses could be tied up for as long as 15 years. However, Allianz settled later that year, paying the state $500,000 in fees and expenses, offering Minnesota seniors a chance to get their money back without penalties, and tightening its underwriting and suitability processes. E-mail Darla Mercado at [email protected].

Latest News

Vanguard seeking SEC green light to expand trademark tax-busting fund design
Vanguard seeking SEC green light to expand trademark tax-busting fund design

The Jack Bogle-founded firm is looking to apply its famed dual-share class structure to actively managed strategies.

UBS keeps focus on costs in US wealth management business
UBS keeps focus on costs in US wealth management business

Meanwhile, the bank is also investing in technology for its financial advisors in the United States.

Advisor moves: LPL and Raymond James add veteran advisors in California
Advisor moves: LPL and Raymond James add veteran advisors in California

LPL welcomes a Beverly Hills-based practice from Wedbush Securities as RayJay adds a Stifel alum to its employee advisor arm.

Is the SEC's private fund exemption rule about to change?
Is the SEC's private fund exemption rule about to change?

House bill seeks inflation-based adjustment to private fund advisor exemption.

Congress pushes to make fintech oversight offices permanent at SEC, CFTC
Congress pushes to make fintech oversight offices permanent at SEC, CFTC

A new House measure would enshrine FinHub and LabCFTC as permanent fixtures, deepening ties with financial technology sector.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today’s choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.

SPONSORED Beyond the dashboard: Making wealth tech human

How intelliflo aims to solve advisors' top tech headaches—without sacrificing the personal touch clients crave